Item5
Resolved
Resolved – That the application for a Premises Licence be refused. Reasons: 1. In reaching the above decision the Panel had consideration of: a. The Officer Report (including appendices) of the Licensing Manager; b. The representations made by the Applicant in support of the application via his agent ([name removed]); c. The representations made by [name removed] (Licensing Officer from Wiltshire Police), and [name removed] (Environmental Health Officer from Swindon Borough Council); d. Swindon Borough Council’s Statement of Licensing Policy (March 2021); e. The Guidance Under Section 182 of the Licensing Act 2003 (December 2022); f. The Licensing Act 2003. 2. The Panel were of the view that it preferred the evidence provided by Wiltshire Police, Environmental Health, and HMRC. Weighting was given to the fact that the information provided was provided in the form of witness statements with a statement of truth. 3. However the weighting given to HMRC’s representation was minimal on the basis that they did not attend. 4. The Panel were not satisfied that the information given by the Applicant was credible as he could not provide a coherent account as to: a. Why there were numerous persons who had his mobile telephone number saved and associated with “FAG BOSS MAN”; b. Why there were strings of text messages between his mobile telephone number and another discussing tobacco; c. Why the suspected vehicles were still parked outside under the watch of CCTV linked to the suspect’s home address; d. Why the other premises he manages (14 Manchester Road) sold counterfeit tobacco products in January 2023 as part of a test purchase. 5. Therefore, when compared to the evidence provided by Wiltshire Police and Trading Standards specifically, the Panel were not satisfied that the Applicant was not engaged in the supply of illicit tobacco products. 6. The Panel was therefore not satisfied that, if granted, the Premises would not be used for the sale of illicit tobacco products. As such the Panel felt that this would undermine all of the licensing objectives in that in respects of: a. The prevention of crime and disorder – The sale of counterfeit and/or otherwise unlawful tobacco products amounts to a criminal offence; b. Public safety – The sale of unlawful tobacco can undermine safety in that they often contain harmful materials and/or do not satisfy the anti-burn requirements; c. The prevention of public nuisance – Persons who are sold counterfeit products under the guise of them being genuine are likely to be caused nuisance; d. The protection of children from harm – As pointed out by Trading Standards, counterfeit tobacco products are sold to underage persons and can lead to underage smoking. 7. As the supply of tobacco is not a licensable activity it would not be possible to limit any undermining of the licensing objectives via the use of the conditions. Appeal: The Applicant and any person who has made a relevant ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Word for word from the decision Swindon published for this meeting.
Source: ww5.swindon.gov.uk