CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Teignbridge District Council
Full Council, Tuesday 19 May 2026 at 10.00am

Member Conduct Review Report

Agreed Committee 1 paper

AI summaryTeignbridge Full Council adopts a member conduct code and pledges on civility, but rejects a proposal to bar the ruling group from chairing regulatory committees.

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeAgreedRecommendations 1 to 6 and 8 adopted
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextReports and training to followMonitoring Officer to report to Governance Committee
Who it affectsAll councillors and officersConduct standards across the council

What was decided

All members will treat each other, council staff and the public with politeness and courtesy, while respecting the right to challenge political views within the law. Report P2

Each member will personally pledge to listen, respect fellow councillors' roles, hold themselves to account, be open and be civil. Report P3, P4, P5, P6, P7, P8

The council will bring forward a training programme for all members, a revised member-officer protocol, and work with the Local Government Association on support for the Executive and Overview and Scrutiny, but will not require regulatory committees to be chaired outside the ruling group. Report P9, P11, P14, P15, P16, P18

Why

To commit councillors, both collectively and individually, to high standards of conduct and to support and protect members from abusive behaviour. Report P10

To provide clarity on expected standards of conduct between councillors and staff, and on the rights of councillors to obtain and scrutinise council information. Report P13

To assist the council in achieving strong governance through clear Executive leadership subject to effective scrutiny. Report P17

What happens next

The Monitoring Officer will report to the Governance Committee on adopting the Local Government Association's Debate Not Hate campaign and Ending Abuse in Public Life Council Self-Assessment toolkit. Report P9

The Monitoring Officer and Head of Paid Service will report jointly to the Governance Committee on a revised member-officer protocol covering information access and member visits to officer working areas. Report P11, P12

A comprehensive training programme for all members will be rolled out and reviewed annually, covering the code of conduct, roles of members and officers, decision-making, chairing skills and the constitution. Report P18

Options considered

  • Chosen: Adopt conduct pledges covering politeness, listening, respect, accountability, openness and civility. To commit members to high standards and protect them from abuse Report P2, P3, P4, P5, P6, P7, P8, P10
  • Chosen: Adopt the Local Government Association Debate Not Hate campaign and Ending Abuse in Public Life self-assessment toolkit. To create a culture of safety and respect for members Report P9, P10
  • Chosen: Revise the member-officer protocol with guidance on information access and member visits. To clarify expected standards of conduct both ways Report P11, P12, P13
  • Chosen: Work with the Local Government Association on support to strengthen the capacity of the Executive. To strengthen Executive leadership Report P14, P17
  • Chosen: Provide further training and assistance to strengthen the Overview and Scrutiny process. To strengthen scrutiny capacity and capability Report P15, P17
  • Rejected: Require all regulatory committees to be chaired by a councillor who is not a member of the ruling group. Not included in the resolutions adopted by Full Council Report P16
  • Chosen: Introduce a comprehensive annual training programme for all members, rolled out for new members. To cement good governance where debate is hard on the issue and soft on the person Report P18, P19

Implications

  • Governance: All members are now bound by the adopted pledges on politeness, listening, respect, accountability, openness and civility. Report P2, P3, P4, P5, P6, P7, P8
  • Staffing: A revised member-officer protocol will set new guidance on councillors' rights to information and visits to officer working areas. Report P11, P12, P13
  • Other: The Monitoring Officer will explore adoption of the LGA Debate Not Hate campaign and the Ending Abuse in Public Life Council Self-Assessment toolkit, addressing safety and respect for members in and out of the chamber. Report P9
  • Other: An annual training programme will be put in place covering the code of conduct, roles, decision-making, chairing skills and the constitution. Report P18, P19

Who and where

  • All Teignbridge District Council councillors Report P2, P3, P18
  • Council staff and officers Report P2, P11, P12
  • Members of the public engaging with councillors Report P2
  • The Governance Committee, which will receive follow-up reports Report P9, P11
  • The Executive, which will be supported through work with the Local Government Association Report P14
  • The Overview and Scrutiny process, which will receive further training and assistance Report P15

Timeline

  • 5th May 2026: External consultants submitted the Member Conduct Review Report Report P20, P21
  • 2026-05-19: Full Council considered the report and adopted recommendations 1 to 6 and 8

Plain English for the jargon

  • Debate Not Hate: A Local Government Association campaign aimed at tackling abuse aimed at councillors in public life.
  • Ending Abuse in Public Life Council Self-Assessment toolkit: An LGA toolkit that helps councils check and improve how they protect elected members from abuse.
  • Monitoring Officer: The senior council officer responsible for ensuring the council acts lawfully and ethically.
  • Head of Paid Service: The council's most senior officer, usually the chief executive.
  • Overview and Scrutiny: The formal process by which non-executive councillors review and challenge Executive decisions and policies.
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item14

Resolved

RESOLVED The report and recommendations 1-6 and 8 be received and accepted as follows: 1. All members treat each other, Council staff and the public with politeness and courtesy in behaviour, speech and in the written word, whilst respecting the right of members to express, debate and challenge political views freely within the law. 2. All members pledge personally to:- · listen and respect differing views Actively listen to others and acknowledge differing political, professional or personal perspectives. Express disagreement constructively and without dismissiveness. · respect the rights of all councillors to carry out their roles and the roles of officers Uphold the legitimate roles, responsibilities and democratic mandates of all councillors, irrespective of political affiliation or position, and refrain from any conduct that undermines another councillor’s ability to discharge their duties. This includes respecting the authority of the chair, engaging appropriately with officers in line with respective roles, and supporting a culture where poor behaviour is constructively and appropriately challenged. · hold themselves and fellow councillors to account Take responsibility for own conduct and decisions and raise concerns about behaviour or actions that fall below agreed standards in an appropriate, proportionate and professional manner. · be open Communicate honestly and transparently, sharing information where appropriate and providing clear reasons for decisions, constraints or changes . · be civil Treat others with courtesy, respect and professionalism at all times, including during disagreement or challenge, and avoid language or behaviour. 3. The Monitoring Officer report to the Governance Committee on the adoption by the Council of the Local Government Association’s Debate Not Hate campaign and in particular the Ending Abuse in Public Life Council Self-Assessment toolkit as a means of creating a culture of safety and respect for members within and without the Council Chamber. Rationale for the above resolutions: for councillors collectively and individually to commit to high standards of conduct and for the Council as an organisation to take steps to support and protect members from abusive behaviour. 4. The Monitoring Officer and Head of Paid Service report jointly to the Governance Committee on a revised member – officer protocol to include clear guidance on:- · Members’ rights to accessing Council information; · Member visits to officer working areas Rationale: to provide clarity on expected standards of conduct by councillors towards staff, staff conduct towards councillors and the rights of councillors to obtain and scrutinise Council information. 5. The Council identify with the Local Government Association what support it might offer to strengthen the capacity of the Executive. 6. The Council provide further training and assistance to strengthen the capacity and capability of the Overview and Scrutiny process. Rationale for the above 2 resolutions: to assist the Council in achieving strong governance through clear Executive leadership which is subject to effective scrutiny. 8 . There be a comprehensive training programme for all members to be reviewed annually and rolled out for all new members. This would include training on the code of conduct, the different role of members and officers, effective decision-making, chairing skills and understanding ...
Word for word from the decision Teignbridge published for this meeting. Source: democracy.teignbridge.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Teignbridge's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Full Council

TEIGNBRIDGE DISTRICT COUNCIL MEMBER CONDUCT REVIEW REPORT 5th May 2026

Page 1 of 22 This page is intentionally blank

Page 2 of 22 Contents Page

1. Executive Summary 4 2. Introduction 7 3. Background 9 4. Review Methodology 12 5. Report and Findings 14 6. Improvements, Conclusions and Recommendations 18

Page 3 of 22 1. Executive Summary

1.1From 2019 onwards, concerns around the organisational culture (in particular, behaviours and the relationships between councillors, and between councillors and officers) and governance at Teignbridge District Council were identified by the Centre for Governance and Scrutiny, the Local Government Association, and the District Council’s external auditors, Grant Thornton.

1.2Grant Thornton’s Annual Reports for each of the financial years from 2020/21, to 2023/24 identified significant weaknesses in the District Council’s governance arrangements.

1.3Grant Thornton made recommendations in its 2020/21 Report and the 2021/22 and 2022/23 Joint Report relating to upholding good standards in councillor behaviour and in councillor-officer relationships. The 2023/24 Report noted that underlying poor behaviour had continued with a lack of trust underpinning some of those behavioural issues. The auditors felt that the issues with relationships and trust were affecting arrangements for supporting decisions once they had been made.

1.4The 2023/24 Report also found that there was insufficient progress on the implementation of the key recommendation from the previous two Reports and instances of poor behaviour from 2023/24 were noted, including a councillor swearing at the Chair at a full Council meeting and councillors talking over one another and using condescending and aggressive language. As a result, the Report made a statutory recommendation under section 24 of the Local Audit and Accountability Act 2014, which included:

“The Council should commission a suitably qualified expert to investigate the underlying causes of member behaviours which contravene the standards set out in the Council’s constitution under the Members Code of conduct and the member/officer protocol; and which have impacted the Council’s reputation and working culture.”

1.5Wilkin Chapman Rollits, working with Hoey Ainscough Associates and Fortis Therapy and Training were commissioned by the Council in relation to the above. This is our report to the Council of our findings and recommendations, based on responses by councillors and senior staff to our questionnaire and three days of interviews with a range of members and officers.

1.6In 2019, control of the Council passed from the Conservative Group to the Liberal Democrat Group. At the same time a number of local campaigners seeking to oppose a large housing development under the slogan “Newton Says No” were elected as the South Devon Alliance (SDA) Group.

1.7Many interviewees felt that Newton Says No/SDA councillors were elected on a promise to disrupt and challenge, and the confrontational nature of their approach caused tension and brought a climate of defensiveness and mistrust to the District Council. This was exacerbated by the combative use of social media by the Newton Says No group prior to the 2019 election and a perception that SDA councillors sought to encourage public outrage online, primarily through voicing controversial political agendas at filmed meetings.

1.8Though there is a feeling among some councillors that the mood at the District Council has started to improve since the SDA Group disbanded and became part of the Independent Group, it is evident that there is still a pervasive negative view of former

Page 4 of 22 Newton Says No/SDA councillors. This is illustrated by a number of the comments we received, which asserted that some members of the Independent Group had been confrontational, abusive and disruptive.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Member Conduct Review ReportReport 371 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

39 of 58 attended
JA
Councillor Joan AtkinsCommittee Member, present
NB
Neil BlaneyOfficer, expected
JB
Councillor Janet BradfordCommittee Member, apologies
PB
Councillor Phil BullivantCommittee Member, present
RB
Councillor Richard BuscombeCommittee Member, present
CC
Councillor Chris ClaranceCommittee Member, present
TC
Trish CornsOfficer, in attendance
DC
Councillor David CoxCommittee Member, present
RD
Councillor Richard DawsCommittee Member, present
RD
Councillor Rosie DawsonCommittee Member, present
JF
Councillor John Farrand-RogersCommittee Member, apologies
KF
Kay FiceOfficer, expected

All 58 on the meeting page

On this subject at Teignbridge

Search all
  1. Member Conduct Review ReportThis decision
  2. Adoption of the revised process for dealing with Member Code of Conduct ComplaintsApproved
  3. Revision of the Appendix of the Council's Code of Conduct for membersDecided

More from Teignbridge Full Council

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
28 Jul 2026 MinutesRESOLVED That the minutes of the meeting held on 19 May 2026 be approved as a correct record and signed by the Chair.... Approved Open
28 Jul 2026 Referral from Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Play Parks Improvement ProjectRESOLVED That Full Council: Approve the Play Parks Improvement Project and the proposed phased approach to governance... Approved Open
28 Jul 2026 Referral from Governance Committee - Debate Not Hate CampaignRESOLVED That Full Council: 1. Adopt the Local Government Association ‘Debate not Hate’ campaign and sign up to the ‘... Approved Open
28 Jul 2026 Referral from Executive - Revenue, Capital and Treasury Outturn 2025/2026RESOLVED That Full Council approves: 1. The proposed establishment and transfers into the Coastal Resilience Reserve ... Approved Open
28 Jul 2026 Biodiversity Enhancements of Local Nature ReservesRESOLVED That Full Council: 1. Accept £321,806 of s106 funding from Devon County Council, for biodiversity enhancemen... Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies