RESOLVED that the Head of Planning (or equivalent authorised officer) be authorised to defend the forthcoming planning appeal and argue that outline planning permission for the development should be refused for the following reasons: · The site lies outside the settlement development boundary for Elmstead Market as defined in both the adopted and emerging Local Plans. The Council is very close to being able to identify a five-year supply of deliverable housing sites and the new Local Plan is progressing well, so the urgency to approve housing developments contrary to the Local Plan is low. The NPPF advocates a plan-led approach that actively seeks to achieve sustainable patterns of growth, but this development would add to what is already considered to be a disproportionate level of new housing development in Elmstead Market. In applying the NPPF’s presumption in favour of sustainable development, the adverse impacts of the proposal, both on the character of Elmstead Market and on the Council’s ability to manage growth through the plan-led approach, are not outweighed by the benefits. The development is unnecessary and there is no support from the local ... view the full minutes text for item 127.
Word for word from the decision Tendring published for this meeting.Source: tdcdemocracy.tendringdc.gov.uk
1.1The is an outline planning application seeking approval for the principle of developing 62 dwellings, with all other matters reserved for approval through a detailed application at a later date. The site is 4.37 hectares of open agricultural land located to the south of the main village and immediately south of Market Field School. The application has attracted a mix of support and objection from local residents although Elmstead Market Parish Council object to the application. Councillor Nicholls has specifically requested that the application be determined by the Committee.
1.2The applicant for the application has however referred the matter to Appeal against non- determination of the application and therefore the Council can no longer determine the application. This report sets down why officers consider that the application would have been recommended for refusal and members are invited to endorse this recommendation as the basis for defending the forthcoming appeal.
1.3In recent months a number of similar greenfield sites, outside the Development Boundary and other sites have been permitted providing a significant number of extant planning permissions for new residential development either permitted by the Council or from the Secretary State following an appeal.
1.4Elmstead Market is defined as a ‘village’ in the adopted Local Plan and as a ‘rural service centre’ in the emerging Local Plan and whilst some growth will be accommodated, the levels of development that have been approved are already well above what was ever envisaged to be appropriate and proportionate for such a rural location. Although Elmstead Market is considered to be one of the district’s larger and more sustainable villages, this is not a justification for supporting or allowing unlimited growth.
1.5The technical reports provided by the applicants along with the comments from statutory agencies suggest that there are no site-specific technical reasons why the proposed development could not proceed. However Officers are conscious that the cumulative impacts of this development alongside others already approved in the village are of great concern to the Parish Council and some local residents. Even though mitigation measures could be put in place to reduce impacts to a technically acceptable level, the effect of many new developments in the village on its character, including those resulting from additional traffic and permanent loss of agricultural land would be adverse and, in line with the NPPF, these need to be weighed up against the benefits of development.
1.6Unlike the situation for much of 2016, the urgency to release land for housing development contrary to the Local Plan is now much reduced now that the new Local Plan is progressing well and the Council is very close to being able to identify a full five-year supply of deliverable housing sites. Following the Rush Green Road appeal decision in February 2017, Officers consider that the Council is in a stronger position to uphold the ‘plan-led’ approach to planning and to resist unnecessary and unwanted development proposals that are contrary to the Local Plan.
Recommendation: Refuse
The development is considered unacceptable for the following (summarised) reasons:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.