That Cabinet agrees that – 1. the Spendells and Honeycroft Sheltered Housing schemes have proven to be unpopular for several years due to their shared facilities and dated design and that it is economically unviable for the Housing Revenue Account (HRA) to continually subsidise the on-going and increasing revenue loss of rental income at these schemes; 2. formal consultation on the principle of closing both the schemes be commenced with residents in accordance with Section 105 of the Housing Act 1985; 3. that the Portfolio Holder for Housing present the outcome of the viability work for each scheme to the Service Development and Delivery Committee, during the consultation period; 4. the outcome of the formal consultation, along with more detail on the costs associated with closure, be reported back to Cabinet to inform the final decisions on the future of these schemes; 5. an associated budget of £200,000 within the HRA in 2017/18, be established to support residents throughout the whole process, funded from the HRA General Reserve; 6. Officers be authorised to commence preparations to secure alternative accommodation for affected residents in the event that Cabinet decides to close these schemes, including holding open voids at other sheltered schemes; and 7. further work be undertaken by Officers exploring the provision of alternative sheltered type housing accommodation after detailed financial modelling within the HRA.
Word for word from the decision Tendring published for this meeting.Source: tdcdemocracy.tendringdc.gov.uk
Key Decision Required: Yes In the Forward Plan: Yes
CABINET
10 NOVEMBER 2017
REPORT OF THE PORTFOLIO HOLDER FOR HOUSING
A.16 FORMAL CONSULTATION ON THE FUTURE OF TWO SHELTERED HOUSING SCHEMES (Report prepared by Tim Clarke)
PART 1 – KEY INFORMATION
PURPOSE OF THE REPORT To inform Cabinet of the outcome from an initial viability assessment into the Spendells and Honeycroft sheltered housing schemes and seek agreement to commence a formal consultation with residents and affected staff on future proposals for the schemes.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Following Cabinet’s decision in June 2016, viability appraisals of two Sheltered Housing Schemes, Spendells House and Honeycroft, including the future of the two sites has been undertaken by Officers. The viability work has considered the level of occupancy at both schemes and costs associated with running them. Various options were produced and presented to residents within the Schemes in October 2016 as part of an informal consultation exercise. It was clear from that consultation there was little support for continuing to operate the schemes without making significant changes to the layout and quality of the accommodation. Options 1 and 2 demonstrate that the Housing Revenue Account would have to continue subsidising an ongoing revenue loss. As a result it is not a viable option to keep operating these two premises with such low occupancy rates. Therefore, it is proposed that the Spendells House scheme should be closed which will provide annual savings to the Housing Revenue Account (HRA). Options in respect of the future use of the site will be brought back to Cabinet once fully evaluated. The recommendation is that the sheltered accommodation in the Honeycroft scheme, not including the 8 bungalows, will also be closed which will provide on-going savings to the HRA, but with further work being undertaken to explore future possibilities for the site. These may include the provision of alternative bungalow accommodation potentially for the use of existing residents but such options will require detailed financial modelling within the HRA to determine viability. A statutory formal consultation on these proposals must be undertaken with residents and affected staff before the final recommendation is brought back to Cabinet.
RECOMMENDATION(S) It is recommended that Cabinet agrees: 1. That the Spendells and Honeycroft Sheltered Housing schemes have proven to be unpopular for several years due to their shared facilities and dated design and that it is economically unviable for the Housing Revenue Account to continually subsidise the on-going and increasing revenue loss of rental income at the schemes; 2. formal consultation on the principle of closing both the schemes be commenced with residents in accordance with Section 105 of the Housing Act 1985; 3. that the Portfolio Holder for Housing will present the outcome of the viability work for each scheme to the Service Development and Delivery Committee, during the consultation period; 4. the outcome of formal consultation along with more detail on the costs associated with closure be reported back to Cabinet to inform the final decisions on the future of these schemes; 5. to establish an associated budget of £200,000 within the HRA in 2017/18, to support residents throughout the whole process, funded from the HRA General Reserve. 6. Officers be authorised to commence preparations to secure alternative accommodation for affected residents in the event that Cabinet decides to close the schemes, including holding open voids at other sheltered schemes; and 7. further work be undertaken by officers exploring the provision of alternative sheltered type housing accommodation after detailed financial modelling within the HRA.
PART 2 – IMPLICATIONS OF THE DECISION
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
108Cabinet Members' Items - Report of the Housing Portfolio Holder - A.16 - Formal Consultation on the future of two Sheltered Housing SchemesThis decision
Cabinet Members' Items - Report of the Housing Portfolio Holder - A.16 - Formal Consultation on the future of two Sheltered Housing SchemesThis decision
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.