CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
May16Thursday

Standards Committee

TendringHeldPapers from tdcdemocracy.tendringdc.gov.uk
Thursday 16 May 2024, 10.00amHeld 918 days ago.
Town HallStation Road, Clacton-on-Sea, CO15 1SE. Open to the public except for exempt items.
20 items, 17 papersAbout 12 MB, led by Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.1 - Report Outcome of Members' Code of Conduct Investigation.
1 item with exempt partsExclusion of Press and Public may be taken in private.
This meeting was held16 May 2024
20items
17papers
3decisions
1exempt
Running order, sized by papersItem 1 to 20
ReportsProcedureExempt parts

The agenda, item by item

What the committee will consider, in order, with every paper attached to its item. Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.1 - Report Outcome of Members' Code of Conduct Investigation is the main business; one item may be taken in private.

1
Procedure

Apologies for Absence and Substitutions

The Committee is asked to note any apologies for absence and substitutions received from Members.

2
Report

Minutes of the Last Meeting

To confirm and sign as a correct record, the minutes of the meeting of the Standards Committee, held on Wednesday 24 April 2024.

Decision: RESOLVED that the Minutes of the meeting of the Committee held on Wednesday 24 April 2024 be approved as a correct record and be signed by the Chairman. Decision page

1 paper, 182 KBSearch inside with Pro
ReportMinutes of the Last Meeting182 KBDownload
3
Procedure

Declarations of Interest

Councillors are invited to declare any Disclosable Pecuniary Interests, Other Registerable Interests of Non-Registerable Interests, and the nature of it, in relation to any item on the agenda.

4
Procedure

Questions on Notice pursuant to Council Procedure Rule 38

Subject to providing two working days’ notice, a Member of the Committee may ask the Chairman of the Committee a question on any matter in relation to which the Council has powers or duties which affect the Tendring District and which falls within the terms of reference of the Committee.

5
ReportMain business

Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.1 - Report Outcome of Members' Code of Conduct Investigation

In accordance with paragraph 7 of the District Council’s Complaints Procedure, the Monitoring Officer is required to refer a matter for a hearing before the Standards Committee, where an investigation concludes that there is evidence of a failure to comply with the Members’ Code of Conduct and the Monitoring Officer has determined informal resolution is not appropriate. This Part A Report provides background...

5 papers, 3.6 MBSearch inside with Pro
AppendixA1 APPENDIX B: TDC COMPLAINTS PROCEDURE91 KBDownload
AppendixA1 Appendix A Local Government Association Model Councillor Code of Conduct: TDC adopted286 KBDownload
AppendixA1 Appendix C: Standards Committee Hearing Procedures: April 202429 KBDownload
AppendixA1 Appendix D: Guidance on Local Governemt Association Model Councillor Code of Conduct3 MBDownload
ReportReport of the Monitoring Officer: A.1: Report Outcome of Members' Code of Conduct Investigation159 KBDownload
6
Exempt parts

Exclusion of Press and Public

The Committee is requested to consider passing the following resolution:- “That, under Section 100A(4) of the Local Government Act 1972, the press and public be excluded from the remainder of the meeting on the grounds that the conduct of the Hearing will involve the likely disclosure of exempt information as defined in Paragraphs 1 and 5 of Part 1 of Schedule 12A, as amended, of the Act.” Monitoring Officer’s...

7
Report

Report of the Monitoring Officer - B.1 - Investigator's Report & Findings

This Part B Report provides background information and advice with regard to the Investigator’s report and findings. (THIS REPORT IS “TO FOLLOW”)

AppendixB1 Annex 1 FINAL SUMMARY Ernest Gibson 20092023177 KBDownload
AppendixB1 Annex 2 FINAL SUMMARY Sidonie Kenward 21092023184 KBDownload
AppendixB1 Annex 3 FINAL SUMMARY Beccy Lofts 25092023182 KBDownload
AppendixB1 Annex 4 FINAL SUMMARY Ross MacLeod 06102023143 KBDownload
AppendixB1 Appendix: FINAL INVESTIGATION REPORT TENDRING TURNER1.2 MBDownload
ReportReport of the Monitoring Officer: B.1: Investigator's Report & Findings167 KBDownload
8
Procedure

Opening of the Hearing

The Chairman will explain that:- (1) the hearing has been convened in accordance with the Council’s Complaints Procedure and that an investigation has been conducted, the outcome of which is that it is considered there is evidence of a failure to comply with the Members’ Code of Conduct; (2) the Parties have been made aware of the content of the Investigator’s Report and that this has been circulated to all Members...

9
Procedure

Hearing the Complaint - Presentation of the Investigator's Report

The Investigating Officer shall be invited to present their report including: (i) any documentary evidence or other material; (ii) call such witnesses as considered necessary; and (iii) make representations to substantiate the conclusion that the Councillor has failed to comply with the Code of Conduct This report and documentary evidence must be based on the complaint made to the Council – no new points will be...

10
Procedure

Hearing the Complaint - Questions by the Respondent Councillor

The Respondent Councillor (or their representative) may question (not cross-examine) through the Chairman: (i) the Investigating Officer upon the content of their report; and/or (ii) any witnesses called by the Investigating Officer. This is solely the Councillor’s opportunity to ask questions rising from the Investigator’s report i.e. not to make a statement.

11
Procedure

Hearing the Complaint - Committee Members' Questions

Members of the Committee may question (not cross-examine) through the Chairman: (i) the Investigating Officer upon the content of their report; and/or (ii) any witnesses called by the Investigating Officer. This is the Committee’s opportunity to ask questions rising from the Investigator’s report but not to make statements.

12
Procedure

The Respondent Councillor's Case

The Respondent Councillor (or their representative) may: (i) present their case; (ii) call any witnesses as required by the Councillor or their representative; and (iii) make representations as why they consider that they did not fail to comply with the Code of Conduct. The Investigating Officer may then question (not cross-examine) through the Chairman, the Respondent Councillor and/or any of their witnesses....

13
Procedure

Summing Up

The Investigating Officer may sum up the Complaint. The Respondent Councillor (or their representative) may sum up their case.

14
Procedure

Independent Person's Views as to whether there has been a failure to comply with the Code of Conduct

The Independent Person will provide their views on this matter as to whether there has been a failure to comply with the Code of Conduct, which the Committee will take into account before it makes its decision on the allegation that has been investigated .

15
Procedure

The Committee's Deliberations as to whether there has been a failure to comply with the Code of Conduct

The Committee will retire to consider and deliberate in private the complaint prior to reaching its decision.

16
Procedure

The Committee's Decision as to whether there has been a failure to comply with the Code of Conduct

Upon the Committee’s return the Chairman will announce the Committee’s decision in the following terms:- (i) the Councillor has failed to comply with the Code of Conduct; or (ii) the Councillor has not failed to comply with the Code of Conduct The Committee will also give detailed reasons for its decision, which will be included within the published Decision Notice.

Decision: RESOLVED that the Committee’s formal decision is as follows:- Case: Concerns a complaint received in August 2023 from Cllr Ernest Gibson of South Tyneside Council. Cllr Gibson was (and is) the Chair of the Local Government Association’s Coastal Special Interest Group (SIG) and presided at meetings of that Group’s meetings on 5 and 23 June 2023. Those meetings were held online. The complaint is set out in the Investigator’s report at page 37 of the Report to this meeting as referenced at agenda... Decision page

17
Procedure

Only required if Committee decides that the Councillor has failed to comply with the Code of Conduct - Representations as to Sanction(s)

If the Committee decides that the Councillor has failed to comply with the Code of Conduct it will then consider any representations from the Investigator and/or the Respondent Councillor as to the appropriate sanction, as set out in Section 8 of the Complaints Procedure, and based on relevance to the breach, being proportionate and necessary to promote and maintain high standards of conduct. Section 8 sets out the...

18
Procedure

Independent Person's Views as to the Sanction(s) to be applied (if any)

The Independent Person will provide their views on this matter as to the Sanction(s) to be applied (if any), which the Committee will take into account before it makes its decision.

19
Procedure

The Committee's deliberations as to Sanction(s) to be applied

The Committee will then retire once more to consider and deliberate in private what action, if any, should be taken .

20
Procedure

The Committee's decision as to Sanction(s) to be applied

On the Committee’s return the Chairman will announce the Committee’s decision as to what actions they resolve to take, having regard to Section 8 of the Complaints Procedure. The Committee will consider whether it should make any specific recommendations to the Council with a view to promoting and maintaining high standards of conduct among Members. The Chairman will confirm that a full written Decision Notice shall...

Decision: RESOLVED that the Committee’s formal decision as to the sanctions to be applied is as follows:- “The Committee has considered the representations from the subject member and the views of the Independent Person. It also acknowledges that the Investigating Officer did not make representations on the sanctions. It is the Committee’s considered view that the following sanctions should be applied in response to the finding of the breach of the Code of Conduct for Members, announced already: (1)... Decision page

Read inside all 17 papersPro opens every page, searches every appendix, and keeps the papers if the council removes them.

The main business: Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.1 - Report Outcome of Members' Code of Conduct Investigation

Item 5 is where most of this meeting's papers sit: 5 papers, about 3.6 MB.

Item 5

Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.1 - Report Outcome of Members' Code of Conduct Investigation

In accordance with paragraph 7 of the District Council’s Complaints Procedure, the Monitoring Officer is required to refer a matter for a hearing before the Standards Committee, where an investigation concludes that there is evidence of a failure to comply with the Members’ Code of Conduct and the Monitoring Officer has determined informal resolution is not appropriate. This Part A Report provides background...

What is in the pack5 papers, about 3.6 MB
Appendix
A1 APPENDIX B: TDC COMPLAINTS PROCEDURESupporting paper
91 KB
Appendix
A1 Appendix A Local Government Association Model Councillor Code of Conduct: TDC adoptedSupporting paper
286 KB
Appendix
A1 Appendix C: Standards Committee Hearing Procedures: April 2024Supporting paper
29 KB
Appendix
A1 Appendix D: Guidance on Local Governemt Association Model Councillor Code of ConductSupporting paper
3 MB
Report
Report of the Monitoring Officer: A.1: Report Outcome of Members' Code of Conduct InvestigationThe report to the committee
159 KB
Read and search every page of this itemPro opens all 5 papers, and keeps them if the council removes them.

How this item got here

This committee has dealt with the subject before.

24 April 2024Complaints UpdateThe Committee will receive the Monitoring Officer’s update regarding standards complaints.
24 April 2024Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.2 - Members' Code of Conduct Complaints Procedure - Hearing ProcedureTo present the Standards Committee with a proposed updated Hearing Procedure, reflecting best practice and case law, for consideration for approval...
24 April 2024Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.1 - Annual Report on Declarations of Interest and Associated MattersTo present the Committee with an overview on the register of, and declarations of, interests made by Members from 1 January 2023 until 31 March 2024.
16 May 2024Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.1 - Report Outcome of Members' Code of Conduct InvestigationThis meeting.

Every paper for this meeting

All 17 papers in one list, with the item each belongs to, its size, and our copy of it. Download any paper from our archive once signed in; read and search it here with Pro.

PaperSizeOur copy
Agenda frontsheetItem
206 KB
Kept 3 Oct
Becky MacDonald-Lofts' Responses to Councillor Turner's QuestionsItem
265 KB
Kept 3 Oct
Councillor Turner's Defence Submission and Recorded Text of Interview with the InvestigatorItem
1.3 MB
Kept 3 Oct
Part B Confidential Report & AppendicesItem
3.5 MB
Kept 3 Oct
Printed minutesItem
974 KB
Kept 3 Oct
Minutes of the Last MeetingItem 2, Minutes of the Last Meeting
182 KB
Kept 3 Oct
A1 APPENDIX B: TDC COMPLAINTS PROCEDUREItem 5, Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.1 - Report Outcome of Members' Code of Conduct Investigation
91 KB
Kept 3 Oct
A1 Appendix A Local Government Association Model Councillor Code of Conduct: TDC adoptedItem 5, Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.1 - Report Outcome of Members' Code of Conduct Investigation
286 KB
Kept 3 Oct
A1 Appendix C: Standards Committee Hearing Procedures: April 2024Item 5, Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.1 - Report Outcome of Members' Code of Conduct Investigation
29 KB
Kept 3 Oct
A1 Appendix D: Guidance on Local Governemt Association Model Councillor Code of ConductItem 5, Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.1 - Report Outcome of Members' Code of Conduct Investigation
3 MB
Kept 3 Oct
Report of the Monitoring Officer: A.1: Report Outcome of Members' Code of Conduct InvestigationItem 5, Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.1 - Report Outcome of Members' Code of Conduct Investigation
159 KB
Kept 3 Oct
B1 Annex 1 FINAL SUMMARY Ernest Gibson 20092023Item 7, Report of the Monitoring Officer - B.1 - Investigator's Report & Findings
177 KB
Kept 3 Oct
B1 Annex 2 FINAL SUMMARY Sidonie Kenward 21092023Item 7, Report of the Monitoring Officer - B.1 - Investigator's Report & Findings
184 KB
Kept 3 Oct
B1 Annex 3 FINAL SUMMARY Beccy Lofts 25092023Item 7, Report of the Monitoring Officer - B.1 - Investigator's Report & Findings
182 KB
Kept 3 Oct
B1 Annex 4 FINAL SUMMARY Ross MacLeod 06102023Item 7, Report of the Monitoring Officer - B.1 - Investigator's Report & Findings
143 KB
Kept 3 Oct
B1 Appendix: FINAL INVESTIGATION REPORT TENDRING TURNERItem 7, Report of the Monitoring Officer - B.1 - Investigator's Report & Findings
1.2 MB
Kept 3 Oct
Report of the Monitoring Officer: B.1: Investigator's Report & FindingsItem 7, Report of the Monitoring Officer - B.1 - Investigator's Report & Findings
167 KB
Kept 3 Oct

Last time, and what carried over

The committee last met on 24 April 2024. 3 of its items lead into this meeting; 1 item is new. Point at any item to follow a thread. Procedural items are left out.

Apr24
24 April 20249 items, 10 papers
Held
carried over
May16
16 May 202420 items, 17 papers
Held
18
Minutes of the Last MeetingTo confirm and sign as a correct record, the minutes of the meeting...
21
Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.1 - Annual Report on Declarations of Interest and Associated MattersTo present the Committee with an overview on the register of, and...
22
Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.2 - Members' Code of Conduct Complaints Procedure - Hearing ProcedureTo present the Standards Committee with a proposed updated Hearing...
23
Draft Committee Work Plan for 2024/2025The Committee is invited to give consideration to its draft Work Plan...
24
Complaints UpdateThe Committee will receive the Monitoring Officer’s update regarding...
2
Minutes of the Last MeetingTo confirm and sign as a correct record, the minutes of the meeting...
5
Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.1 - Report Outcome of Members' Code of Conduct InvestigationIn accordance with paragraph 7 of the District Council’s Complaints...
6
Exclusion of Press and PublicNew this time
7
Report of the Monitoring Officer - B.1 - Investigator's Report & FindingsThis Part B Report provides background information and advice with...

The threads

  • Minutes of the Last Meeting leads to item 2, Minutes of the Last Meeting
  • Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.1 - Annual Report on Declarations of Interest and Associated Matters leads to item 5, Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.1 - Report Outcome of Members' Code of Conduct Investigation
  • Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.1 - Annual Report on Declarations of Interest and Associated Matters leads to item 7, Report of the Monitoring Officer - B.1 - Investigator's Report & Findings
  • Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.2 - Members' Code of Conduct Complaints Procedure - Hearing Procedure leads to item 5, Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.1 - Report Outcome of Members' Code of Conduct Investigation
  • Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.2 - Members' Code of Conduct Complaints Procedure - Hearing Procedure leads to item 7, Report of the Monitoring Officer - B.1 - Investigator's Report & Findings

Not carried over

Draft Committee Work Plan for 2024/2025, Complaints Update do not return this time.

See the 24 April meeting

This committee over time

Every Standards Committee meeting we have read, the dates it has set for the future, and each time those dates have changed.

69 meetings, 2011 to 2026Dot size shows the number of papers
20112013201520172019202120232025
HeldThis meeting
MeetingItemsPapers
21 Oct 2026Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
15 Jul 2026Wednesday
7items
10papers
HeldOpen
22 Apr 2026Wednesday
10items
14papers
HeldOpen
11 Mar 2026Wednesday
7items
9papers
HeldOpen
8 Oct 2025Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
9 Jul 2025Wednesday
8items
10papers
HeldOpen
9 Apr 2025Wednesday
8items
12papers
HeldOpen
5 Feb 2025Wednesday
8items
12papers
HeldOpen
24 Oct 2024Thursday
9items
11papers
HeldOpen
9 Oct 2024Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
10 Jul 2024Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
16 May 2024Thursday, this meeting
20items
17papers
24 Apr 2024Wednesday
9items
10papers
HeldOpen
20 Mar 2024Wednesday
7items
8papers
HeldOpen
5 Mar 2024Tuesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
7 Feb 2024Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
6 Dec 2023Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
11 Oct 2023Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
19 Jul 2023Wednesday
8items
14papers
HeldOpen
15 Mar 2023Wednesday
7items
7papers
HeldOpen
8 Feb 2023Wednesday
8items
11papers
HeldOpen
1 Feb 2023Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
26 Oct 2022Wednesday
7items
11papers
HeldOpen
3 Aug 2022Wednesday
8items
11papers
HeldOpen
27 Jul 2022Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
6 Apr 2022Wednesday
8items
10papers
HeldOpen
2 Feb 2022Wednesday
11items
11papers
HeldOpen
27 Oct 2021Wednesday
6items
8papers
HeldOpen
28 Jul 2021Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
21 Apr 2021Wednesday
8items
10papers
HeldOpen
3 Feb 2021Wednesday
8items
9papers
HeldOpen
16 Jul 2020Thursday
7items
9papers
HeldOpen
8 Apr 2020Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
5 Feb 2020Wednesday
8items
9papers
HeldOpen
2 Oct 2019Wednesday
9items
10papers
HeldOpen
3 Jul 2019Wednesday
9items
7papers
HeldOpen
20 Mar 2019Wednesday
8items
12papers
HeldOpen
16 Jan 2019Wednesday
6items
4papers
HeldOpen
3 Oct 2018Wednesday
6items
6papers
HeldOpen
23 Jul 2018Monday
6items
6papers
HeldOpen
20 Jun 2018Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
19 Mar 2018Monday
7items
10papers
HeldOpen
22 Jan 2018Monday
6items
7papers
HeldOpen
27 Sep 2017Wednesday
7items
16papers
HeldOpen
28 Jun 2017Wednesday
7items
10papers
HeldOpen
27 Mar 2017Monday
11items
10papers
HeldOpen
6 Mar 2017Monday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
19 Jan 2017Thursday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
12 Dec 2016Monday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
26 Sep 2016Monday
7items
11papers
HeldOpen
29 Jun 2016Wednesday
0items
1papers
HeldOpen
12 May 2016Thursday
0items
1papers
HeldOpen
14 Mar 2016Monday
0items
1papers
HeldOpen
14 Oct 2015Wednesday
0items
1papers
HeldOpen
22 Jun 2015Monday
0items
1papers
HeldOpen
16 Mar 2015Monday
0items
1papers
HeldOpen
2 Feb 2015Monday
0items
1papers
HeldOpen
26 Jan 2015Monday
0items
1papers
HeldOpen
17 Dec 2014Wednesday
0items
1papers
HeldOpen
29 Sep 2014Monday
0items
1papers
HeldOpen
25 Jun 2014Wednesday
0items
1papers
HeldOpen
18 Mar 2014Tuesday
0items
1papers
HeldOpen
12 Dec 2013Thursday
0items
1papers
HeldOpen
19 Nov 2013Tuesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
15 Jul 2013Monday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
26 Oct 2012Friday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
28 Sep 2012Friday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
22 Aug 2012Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
14 Mar 2011Monday
0items
1papers
HeldOpen

Follow the Standards Committee

Choose what you want to hear about. The preview is built from this committee's real papers and changes, so you can see what would have reached you.

What should we tell you?

Tendring, Standards Committee

Standards Committee: 3 kinds of updateTendring, sent the same day
PDF
17 papers published for 16 MayReport of the Monitoring Officer - A.1 - Report Outcome of Members' Code of Conduct Investigation and 16 more papers
DAT
Meeting dates updatedAny date added, moved or dropped
DEC
Decisions from 16 MayThe committee's resolutions, the day they are recorded
ABC
"monitoring" found in 2 papersReport of the Monitoring Officer: A.1: Report Outcome of Members' Code of Conduct Investigation and Report of the Monitoring Officer: B.1: Investigator's Report & Findings
Each update links to the paper and the council's own copy
Free: one weekly alert. Pro: every option, the same day. Pro Plus: straight into your own systems.

Free

One alert, sent weekly, on titles and decisions.

£0for good
  • 1 alert, weekly summary
  • Titles and decisions
  • Link to every official paper
Save this alert free
Most chosen

Pro

Unlimited alerts the same day, searching every page.

£99per user a month
  • Unlimited alerts, same day
  • Matches inside every page and appendix
  • Every council, not just this one

Pro Plus

Your team, with every match pushed into your own tools.

£449a month, 3 users included
  • Everything in Pro, for 3 users
  • Alerts as webhooks into Slack or a CRM
  • API key and bulk export of this council

Data licence

Every council's records in your own products and research.

£12,000a year, from
  • Unlimited API and full archive delivery
  • Rights to use the data in your products
  • Back to 2000, every council
Talk to us

Never miss what this committee decides

Papers, decisions and date changes for the Standards Committee, and every other committee you follow, the day they appear.

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies