RESOLVED that Cabinet - (a) in the light of the ongoing delays and costs, as well as the significant risk of failing to conclude the disposal Option Agreement for the former Weeley Council Offices site, agrees to no longer pursue further negotiations with the current bidder, based on the existing Heads of Terms agreed in April 2023; and (b) requests Officers explore alternative disposal options and report these back to Cabinet for consideration and further decisions.
Word for word from the decision Tendring published for this meeting.Source: tdcdemocracy.tendringdc.gov.uk
To evaluate whether, given the extended negotiations, the Council should continue with negotiating an Option Agreement for the disposal of the redundant Council Office at Weeley. This is in line with Cabinet’s decision on 17 December 2021 to dispose of the Weeley Office site, based on the Heads of Terms finalised by the then Leader following consultation, with the then Portfolio Holder for Housing along with the Corporate Director (Operations and Delivery), the Section 151 Officer, and the Monitoring Officer on 25 April 2023.
Executive summary
Cabinet agreed transformation proposals on the 16 December 2016 which included disposing of a number of Council facilities, Weeley Offices being one of them. On the 17 December 2021 following an invitation of bids from two special purchasers, Cabinet agreed to enter into an option agreement with the successful bidder, delegating authority to agree Heads of Terms on the principles set out in the report. Heads of Terms were agreed on 25 April 2023.
Since the Heads of Terms were agreed, negotiations in respect of the full text of the Options Agreement, the legally binding document that needs to be completed in order for planning consent to be submitted, have been ongoing. This has still not been finalised.
Negotiations between the successful bidder and the Council in respect of the Options Agreement have reached a stalemate with each party’s legal advice being on opposing sides of the opinion on a key issue, the extent and effect of highway rights adjoining the site.
This report looks at whether, based on the ongoing costs and liabilities of a currently vacant site, the Council should continue with negotiations to try and finalise the Option Agreement, or choose to withdraw from further negotiations in order to consider alternative routes to dispose of the site.
Ongoing costs for the Weeley site are in the region of £65,000.00 p/a. Given the issues highlighted above, the risks of not being able to satisfactorily move beyond the current stalemate / stalled position are now significant. Planning Consent, which will take a minimum of 12 weeks, possibly longer because of the size and complexity of the development, hasn’t yet been submitted and won’t be until the Option Agreement has been resolved.
RECOMMENDATION(S) It is recommended that Cabinet: (a) in the light of ongoing delays and costs, as well as the significant risk of failing to conclude the disposal Option Agreement for the former Weeley Council Offices site, agrees to no longer pursue further negotiations with the current bidder, based on the existing Heads of Terms agreed in April 2023; and
(b) requests Officers explore alternative disposal options and report these back to Cabinet for consideration and further decisions.
REASON(S) FOR THE RECOMMENDATION(S)
Due to the complex and multilayered considerations of the transaction, it took 16 months to agree heads of terms for the Option Agreement and has taken a further 2 years in negotiations over the legally binding agreement. These negotiations have not currently been concluded and despite significant time and effort by the legal and property teams on both sides, are considered to be at a stalemate. Each party’s legal advice sits on opposing sides of the opinion on a key issue: the extent and effect of highway rights adjoining the site. Due to the time and cost that has already been expended and there being no confidence that matters can be resolved quickly, if at all, withdrawing from the agreement in order to consider alternative disposal routes is recommended in order to mitigate further expense.
If Cabinet agrees to no longer pursue current negotiations, alternative options can be explored and brought forward in a future Cabinet Report for decision. Along with the approach adopted previously, these could also include:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
160Cabinet Members' Items - Report of the Assets and Community Safety Portfolio Holder - A.2 - Freehold Disposal of Redundant Office Site at WeeleyThis decision
Cabinet Members' Items - Report of the Assets and Community Safety Portfolio Holder - A.2 - Freehold Disposal of Redundant Office Site at WeeleyThis decision
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.