Cabinet Members' Items - Report of the Corporate Finance & Governance Portfolio Holder - A.1 - Delegated Powers for Assets of Community Value & Determination of a Nomination to Register an Asset of Community Value: Great Bentley Footpath 2
ApprovedExecutive1 paper
AI summaryCabinet approves delegating Assets of Community Value decisions to officers and rejects Great Bentley Parish Council's nomination to list Footpath 2, finding it ancillary to agricultural land.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedFuture ACV decisions to be made by officers
MoneyNo sum allocatedCompensation risk not quantified; £20,000 MHCLG threshold noted
What happens nextConstitution amended; parties informedAmendments take effect after call-in period
Who it affectsThe Bentleys and Frating wardFootpath 2 at Crabtree Farm and Sturrick Lane
What was decided
Cabinet approved delegating ACV determinations and internal reviews to officers, with the Assets and Community Safety Portfolio Holder holding oversight. Report P3, P9, P40
Cabinet determined that Great Bentley Footpath 2 does not meet the definition of an Asset of Community Value under Section 88 of the Localism Act 2011 and should not be added to the list. Report P7, P9, P13
The Monitoring Officer was asked to amend Part 3, Schedule 3 of the Council's Constitution to give effect to the delegations, after the Chief Executive identifies the relevant directorate. Report P9, P39, P68
Why
Officers assessed that the footpath is ancillary to the agricultural use of the surrounding land and that listing only the footpath would not further social wellbeing or interests of the local community. Report P14, P57, P60
The Parish Council acknowledged in the nomination form that purchasing only the footpath would be difficult due to the scale of the surrounding land, and did not provide evidence of financial viability. Report P15, P60, P150
Benchmarking and a 2022 Cabinet instruction found that ACV determinations are best made by officers under a strict statutory framework, with internal reviews by a director not previously involved. Report P11, P29, P105
What happens next
The Chief Executive will identify the directorate and officers to exercise the new delegations, and the Monitoring Officer will amend the Constitution, taking effect after the call-in period. Report P9, P39, P68
The unsuccessful nomination will be added to the Council's list of unsuccessful community nominations and the Parish Council and landowners will be notified with written reasons. Report P67
The new officer-led process will follow the gateway assessment, eight-week decision window and internal review arrangements set out in the report. Report P31, P33, P35
The money
£20,000 MHCLG burdens funding threshold if compensation payments in a year exceed this Report P63
Options considered
Chosen: Delegate ACV determinations and internal reviews to officers. Best practice, benchmarked elsewhere; supports efficiency and statutory timescales Report P3, P11, P29
Rejected: Keep decisions with Cabinet (status quo). Against Cabinet's collective strategic responsibility Report P20
Rejected: Delegate to the responsible Portfolio Holder. Against best practice and benchmarking for this type of decision Report P21
Rejected: List Great Bentley Footpath 2 as an Asset of Community Value. Statutory criteria under Section 88 of the Localism Act 2011 not met; footpath is ancillary to agricultural land Report P14, P22, P57, P60
Implications
Legal: Written reasons for refusing the nomination must be given to the nominating body under Section 90(6) of the Localism Act 2011; only the owner can seek a review under Section 92, and any challenge by a nominator is limited to judicial review. Report P62
Financial: Compensation may be payable to owners in certain circumstances; the risk is not quantified and no specific allocation is proposed, with MHCLG support available if payments exceed £20,000 in a year. Report P63, P65
Other: Decision is neutral on the Council's net zero 2050 aim and will not change crime and disorder or health inequalities in the area. Report P78, P80, P81
Equalities: The nominating body's social and community activities are described as likely progressive on equality and diversity, and will not be affected by the decision. Report P71
Risk: ACV listing decisions can be controversial whichever way they go; consultation with the Monitoring Officer was used to mitigate risk and articulate clear reasons. Report P69, P70
Who and where
Great Bentley Parish Council as the nominating body Report P2, P115, P116
Owners of the land crossed by Footpath 2 at Crabtree Farm and north of Sturrick Lane Report P42, P143
Residents and users of the footpath in The Bentleys and Frating ward Report P83, P146
Tendring District Council officers in the directorate to be identified by the Chief Executive Report P9, P39
Timeline
16 December 2022: Cabinet Minute 88(2) asked for a review of ACV procedures to allow officer determinations Report P105
2026-01-30: Cabinet decision to delegate ACV functions and reject the Great Bentley Footpath 2 nomination
Within 8 weeks of nomination: Statutory window for the responsible authority to decide on listing an ACV nomination Report P31
After call-in period: Delegations take effect and the Constitution is amended Report P68
5 years: Period that a listed ACV remains on the list Report P92
6 weeks from owner notice: Window for community groups to register an intent to bid Report P92
6 months from owner notice: Maximum moratorium during which community groups may bid Report P92
18 months from owner notice: Period during which no further moratorium or community bid can be triggered Report P92
Within 28 days of internal review notice: Deadline for an owner to appeal to the First Tier Tribunal Report P38
Plain English for the jargon
Asset of Community Value (ACV): Land or a building listed by a local authority under the Localism Act 2011 that meets the social wellbeing test and triggers a community right to bid when sold.
Community Right to Bid: The scheme in Chapter 3 of the Localism Act 2011 and the 2012 Regulations that lets community groups nominate land as an ACV and bid if it is sold.
Section 88 Localism Act 2011: The statutory definition of an asset of community value, covering current or recent past non-ancillary use that furthers social wellbeing, with a realistic prospect of continuing.
Internal review: A review of a listing decision by a senior officer not previously involved, available to the owner under the 2012 Regulations.
Gateway assessment: Initial officer check that the nominator is a valid community group and that the asset appears to fit the ACV definition before a full assessment is made.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item102
Resolved
RESOLVED that Cabinet – a) approves that the determination and internal review process for Assets of Community Value be delegated to Officers in line with the process identified within the report for future nominations received; b) requests the Chief Executive to identify the relevant directorate and Officers to exercise the delegations and agrees that the Portfolio Holder with responsibility for the oversight of assets of community value should be the Portfolio Holder for Assets and Community Safety; c) requests the Monitoring Officer, following consultation with the Chief Executive on the relevant service area, to make the necessary amendments to the Responsibility for Executive Functions section within Part 3, Schedule 3 of the Council’s Constitution; d) following consideration of the contents of the report, formally determines that Great Bentley Footpath 2 going through land at Crabtree Farm, Colchester Road, Great Bentley, and land lying to the north of Sturrick Lane, Great Bentley, does not meet the definition of an Asset of Community Value as set out in Section 88 of the Localism Act 2011; and e) determines therefore that the asset should not be added to the Council’s list of Assets of Community Value for the reasons set out in the report and which shall be notified to the nominating body.
Word for word from the decision Tendring published for this meeting.Source: tdcdemocracy.tendringdc.gov.uk
To agree that determinations and internal reviews for future applications for Assets of Community Value be delegated to Officers, under the Council’s Scheme of Delegation for Executive Functions and that the Monitoring Officer amend Part 3, Schedule 3 of the Council’s Constitution accordingly.
To determine whether Great Bentley Footpath 2 meets the criteria set out in the Localism Act 2011 (“the Act”) and the Assets of Community Value (England) Regulations 2012 (“the Regulations”) following its nomination as an Asset of Community Value by Great Bentley Parish Council.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Following a review undertaken by the Council’s Corporate Director (Law and Governance) in accordance with a former decision of Cabinet, best practice indicates that decisions on listing nominations for assets of community value are determined by officers and an internal review is undertaken by a director not previously involved with the decision. Consequently, Cabinet’s authority is sought for the Scheme of Delegation for Executive Functions (Part 3, Schedule 3) of the Council’s Constitution to be amended to include the determinations and review process at Officer level.
A valid nomination to register an asset of community value has been received for Great Bentley Footpath 2 as identified in the plan included within Appendix A.
If a local authority receives a valid nomination, it must determine whether the land or building nominated meets the definition of an Asset of Community Value as set out in Section 88 of the Localism Act 2011 and The Assets of Community Value Regulations 2012.
Cabinet is requested to consider the content of the nomination assessed against the statutory criteria (and no other factors) and determine whether the asset should be included within the Council’s List of Assets of Community Value.
Taking the evidence provided into account and following the assessment undertaken by Officers it is recommended that Cabinet determine that the land nominated does not meet the criteria set out Section 88 of the Localism Act 2011 for the reason set out in the report and therefore should not be listed as an Asset of Community Value.
RECOMMENDATION(S) That Cabinet:
a) approves the determination and internal review process for Assets of Community Value being delegated to Officers in line with the process identified within the report for future nominations received; b) subject to (a) requests the Chief Executive to identify the relevant directorate and Officers to exercise the delegations and agrees that the Portfolio Holder with responsibility for the oversight of Assets of Community Value should be the Portfolio Holder for Assets and Community Safety; c) subject to (a) and (b) requests the Monitoring Officer, following consultation with the Chief Executive on the relevant service area, to make the necessary amendments to the Responsibility for Executive Functions section within Part 3, Schedule 3 of the Council’s Constitution; d) following consideration of the contents of the report, determines that Great Bentley Footpath 2 going through land at Crabtree Farm, Colchester Road, Great Bentley, and land lying to the north of Sturrick Lane, Great Bentley, does not meet the definition of an Asset of Community Value as set out in Section 88 of the Localism Act 2011; and e) subject to (d) determines the asset should not be added to the Council’s list of Assets of Community Value for the reasons set out in the report being notified to the nominating body.
REASON(S) FOR THE RECOMMENDATION(S) Procedures:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Cabinet Members' Items: Report of the Corporate Finance & Governance Portfolio Holder: A.1: Delegated Powers for Assets of Community Value & Determination of a Nomination to Register an Asset of Community Value: Great Bentley Footpath 2 going through land at Crabtree Farm, Colchester Road, GreatReport
102Cabinet Members' Items - Report of the Corporate Finance & Governance Portfolio Holder - A.1 - Delegated Powers for Assets of Community Value & Determination of a Nomination to Register an Asset of Community Value: Great Bentley Footpath 2This decision
Cabinet Members' Items - Report of the Corporate Finance & Governance Portfolio Holder - A.1 - Delegated Powers for Assets of Community Value & Determination of a Nomination to Register an Asset of Community Value: Great Bentley Footpath 2This decision
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.