CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Tendring District Council
Cabinet, Friday 20 March 2026 at 10.30am

Management Team Items - Report of the Assistant Director (Corporate Policy & Support) - A.13 - Outcome of the Council's Carnarvon Terrace Regeneration Project Task & Finish Group

Noted Executive 1 paper

AI summaryTendring Cabinet noted the Task and Finish Group's findings on the Carnarvon Terrace regeneration in Clacton and endorsed the Portfolio Holder's response, after a single tender bid came in at least £1.7 million over budget.

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeNoted
Money£19,743,739 total project costSingle tender bid exceeded available budget by at least £1.7 million
What happens nextRe-tender via open processPre-market engagement closed 13 February 2026; contract target Summer 2026
Who it affectsClacton-on-Sea town centre28 flats, multi-storey car park, mixed-use space and public realm

What was decided

Cabinet noted the comments of the Carnarvon Terrace Regeneration Project Task and Finish Group and endorsed the Portfolio Holder for Economic Growth, Regeneration and Tourism's response.

The Group had recommended ongoing use of pre-market engagement, supported ending the initial procurement, noted lessons learned, and endorsed that actions taken had protected the Council's reputation. Report P109, P110, P111, P112, P113

Why

A tender exercise using a procurement framework returned only a single bid, which exceeded the available budget by a minimum of £1.7 million, leading to tenders being withdrawn. Report P91, P92

The Deputy Chief Executive and Corporate Director (Place and Wellbeing) took a formal decision, in consultation with relevant officers, not to award the contract and to withdraw tenders for the Local Regeneration Fund projects including Carnarvon Terrace. Report P92, P93

Ground contamination risks were one principal factor behind the over-budget tendered sum, and procurement frameworks are seen to favour a restricted number of national companies over smaller local firms. Report P106, P108

What happens next

A revised procurement approach will be reported to Cabinet on 20 March 2026, informed by a pre-market engagement exercise run with Essex Procurement Partnership. Report P100, P102

If reprocured, the Council aims to enter into contract in Summer 2026, with a practical completion drop-dead deadline of March 2028 tied to grant funding. Report P104, P54

Officers propose replacing the single agency Programme Delivery contractor with two in-house fixed-term project managers recruited through Public Practice, with MHCLG match-funding one post. Report P103

The money

  • £16,855,239 Total request to Levelling Up Fund Report P95
  • £2,078,500 Match Funding Contribution provided by TDC Report P95
  • £420,000 Brownfield Land Release Funding Report P95
  • £390,000 Electric Vehicle Fund (not yet secured) Report P95
  • £19,743,739 Total Project Costs Report P95
  • £1.7million Minimum amount by which the single tender bid exceeded the available budget Report P91
  • £17m (Exc VAT) Total Budget for both sites (Carnarvon Terrace and Milton Road) Report P54
  • £10M Insurance requirement: Employers Liability, Public Liability and Professional Indemnity Report P54

Options considered

  • Rejected: Award contract to the single bidder. Bid exceeded available budget by a minimum of £1.7 million Report P91, P92
  • Chosen: Withdraw tenders and develop a revised procurement strategy. Allows review for value for money and deliverability within funding constraints Report P92, P93
  • Chosen: Run pre-market engagement and move to an open tender process. Open tender is expected to attract smaller, more local companies and better prices Report P102, P106

Implications

  • Financial: Single tender bid exceeded the available budget by at least £1.7 million, so the Council withdrew tenders rather than award an unaffordable contract. Report P91, P92
  • Risk: Tender failure has delayed the programme and is likely to put pressure on the March 2028 deadline for Government grant funding. Report P104
  • Staffing: Proposal to replace a single agency Programme Delivery contractor with two in-house fixed-term project managers recruited through Public Practice, with MHCLG match-funding one post. Report P103
  • Other: Lessons from the failed procurement include consideration of ground contamination, framework versus open tender, and packaging of works to attract bidders. Report P60, P106, P108

Who and where

  • Users of the Clacton-on-Sea town centre car park, which is the key public car park for the town Report P50
  • Future residents of the 28 new apartments planned at Carnarvon Terrace Report P48
  • Smaller, local construction firms expected to be more accessible under an open tender Report P106
  • Essex County Council redeveloping Clacton Library on the neighbouring site concurrently Report P51

Timeline

  • 6 October 2023: Cabinet: LUF and Capital Regeneration Projects progressing to planning permission Report P2
  • 24 May 2024: Cabinet: Update on LUF / CRP Report P2
  • December 2024: Cabinet: Progressing projects to production of tender information Report P2
  • August 2025: Executive Decision: LUF and CRP approach to procurement Report P2
  • January 2026: Officer Decision: Next steps on LUF / CRP Procurement Report P2
  • 10 February 2026: Task and Finish Group meeting on Carnarvon Terrace project Report P84
  • 13 February 2026: Deadline for pre-market engagement questionnaire responses Report P82, P106
  • 20 March 2026: Cabinet to consider revised procurement approach Report P100, P102
  • Summer 2026: If reprocured, target to enter into contract Report P104
  • March 2028: Drop-dead deadline for practical completion and end of grant funding Report P54, P69, P104

Plain English for the jargon

  • Levelling Up Fund / Local Regeneration Fund: Government funding programme for area regeneration, recently rebranded
  • Task and Finish Group: A working group set up by a scrutiny committee to examine a specific matter and report back
  • Pre-market engagement: Consultation with potential suppliers before issuing a formal tender, used to shape the procurement approach
  • D&B (Design and Build): Procurement route where a single contractor completes both design and construction
  • Public Practice: A not-for-profit organisation that helps councils recruit built-environment professionals, supported by MHCLG
  • Section 151 Officer: The local authority officer with statutory responsibility for financial administration
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item131

Resolved

RESOLVED that the comments made by the Carnarvon Terrace Regeneration Project Task and Finish Group be noted, and that the response of the Economic Growth, Regeneration & Tourism Portfolio Holder thereto, be endorsed.
Word for word from the decision Tendring published for this meeting. Source: tdcdemocracy.tendringdc.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Tendring's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cabinet

CABINET

20 MARCH 2026

REPORT OF THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR (CORPORATE POLICY & SUPPORT)

A.13 OUTCOME OF THE COUNCIL’S CARNARVON TERRACE REGENERATION PROJECT TASK & FINISH GROUP (Report prepared by Ian Ford)

BACKGROUND At the meeting of Council held on 14 August 2025, the work programme for the two Overview and Scrutiny Committees were approved. This included, within the scope of the Community Leadership Overview and Scrutiny Committee to, in relation to the progress and implementation of the Carnarvon Terrace regeneration project, conduct overview and scrutiny of that project and make relevant formal comments / recommendations, as appropriate.

On 3 February 2026, a decision in the name of the Assistant Director (Corporate Policy & Support) was published constituting the Carnarvon Terrace Regeneration Project Task and Finish Group and setting the date of 10 February 2026 for it to meet. Authority for that decision derived from resolution (d) to Minute 12 of the meeting of the Community Leadership Overview and Scrutiny Committee held on 29 July 2025. That provided for the aforementioned Assistant Director to be authorised, in consultation with the Chairman of the Community Leadership Overview & Scrutiny Committee, to make appointments to Task and Finish Groups and other necessary administrative arrangements.

In addition, the Community Leadership Overview and Scrutiny Committee, at its meeting held on 10 February 2026 (minute 40 refers) authorised, in view of the restricted timescales involved, the Assistant Director (Corporate Policy & Support), in consultation with the Chairman of the Committee, to directly report to the Cabinet meeting to be held on 20 March 2026 the outcome of the Task and Finish Working Group's enquiry together with its recommendations and/or comments et cetera.

The Task and Finish Group duly met on the evening of 10 February 2026.

CARNARVON TERRACE REGENERATION PROJECT TASK & FINISH GROUP’S COMMENTS / RECOMMENDATION TO CABINET

It was AGREED that Cabinet be informed that the Working Group –

(a) welcomes the use of a pre-market engagement exercise and would advocate this as an ongoing procurement policy for TDC as a good way to ensure TDC’s contract policies and specifications are sound going forward;

(b) supports the decision to end the initial procurement of the Local Regeneration Projects, including Carnarvon Terrace; (c) notes that lessons have been learned; and

(d) acknowledges and endorses that the actions taken have protected the Council’s reputation.

The Task and Finish Group’s final report is attached as an appendix to this report.

PORTFOLIO HOLDER COMMENT(S) AND RECOMMENDATION(S) TO CABINET

Economic Growth, Regeneration & Tourism Portfolio Holder’s Comments

“I would like to thank the Task and Finish Group for their questions and engagement on the issue of the procurement of the Carnarvon Terrace scheme. I appreciate their support for the approach we have taken so far, and I fully endorse their view that pre-market engagement with contractors should be a key part of the procurement process on such a scheme. I am content to return to the Task and Finish Group at a future point to update them on progress.”

RECOMMENDATION TO CABINET:

That the comments made by the Carnarvon Terrace Regeneration Project Task & Finish Group be noted and that the response of the Economic Growth, Regeneration & Tourism Portfolio Holder thereto be endorsed.

SECTION 151 OFFICER’S COMMENTS There are no comments over and above those that may be set out elsewhere within the report and/or its appendix.

MONITORING OFFICER’S COMMENTS There are no comments over and above those that may be set out elsewhere within the report and/or its appendix. A.13 APPENDIX

Community Leadership Overview and Scrutiny Committee

Final Report of the Carnarvon Terrace Regeneration Project Task & Finish Group (Progress and Implementation) Investigating the progress made on implementation and the proposed next steps

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Management Team Items: Report of the Assistant Director (Corporate Policy & Support): A.13: Outcome of the Council's Carnarvon Terrace Regeneration Project Task & Finish GroupAppendix 1.8 MB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting
114Minutes of the Last MeetingApproved 119Matters Referred to the Cabinet by a Committee - Reference from the Community Leadership Overview & Scrutiny Committee - A.1 - Grant Funding by the Council and others and its appropriateness given the needs of the DistrictNoted 120Matters Referred to the Cabinet by a Committee - Reference from the Community Leadership Overview & Scrutiny Committee - A.2 - The Council's Youth Provision for School Aged Children Task & Finish Group - Their Final Report and Committee Recommendations to CabinetNoted 121Matters Referred to the Cabinet by a Committee - Reference from the Community Leadership Overview & Scrutiny Committee - A.3 - Konectbus Attendance at the Community Leadership Overview and Scrutiny Committee MeetingNoted 122Matters Referred to the Cabinet by a Committee - Reference from the Licensing and Registration Committee - A.4 - Charitable Collections PolicyApproved 123Matters Referred to the Cabinet by a Committee - Reference from the Licensing and Registration Committee - A.5 - Scrap Metal PolicyApproved 124Matters Referred to the Cabinet by a Committee - Reference from the Licensing and Registration Committee - A.6 - Proposed Removal of the Fourth Member (Standby) for the Premises/Personal Licences Sub-CommitteeDecided 125Leader of the Council's Items - A.7 - Adoption of a Corporate Sponsorship PolicyApproved 126Cabinet Members' Items - Report of the Corporate Finance & Governance Portfolio Holder - A.8 - Timetable of Meetings: 2026/2027 Municipal Year & BeyondAgreed 127Cabinet Members' Items - Report of the Corporate Finance & Governance Portfolio Holder - A.9 - Annual Capital and Treasury Strategy 2026/27 (Including Prudential and Treasury Indicators)Agreed 128Cabinet Members' Items - Report of the Economic Growth, Regeneration & Tourism Portfolio Holder - A.10 - Local Regeneration Fund: Procurement Update and Next StepsApproved 129Cabinet Members' Items - Report of the Economic Growth, Regeneration & Tourism Portfolio Holder - A.11 - Community Regeneration Partnership: Defrayment and next steps on work in Jaywick SandsApproved 130Management Team Items - Report of the Corporate Director (Planning and Community) - A.12 - Publication of the Council's First BNG report for the Period February 2024 to December 2025Approved
131Management Team Items - Report of the Assistant Director (Corporate Policy & Support) - A.13 - Outcome of the Council's Carnarvon Terrace Regeneration Project Task & Finish GroupThis decision

Who was there

7 of 25 attended
MS
Councillor Mark StephensonChairman, present
IH
Councillor Ivan HendersonCommittee Member, apologies (outside body duties)
AB
Councillor Andy BakerCommittee Member, present
MB
Councillor Mick BarryCommittee Member, present
PK
Councillor Peter KotzCommittee Member, present
GP
Councillor Gina PlaceyCommittee Member, present
GS
Councillor Gary ScottCommittee Member, present
AS
Councillor Adrian SmithCommittee Member, present
JB
Councillor Jeff BraySpokesperson, in attendance
JC
Councillor Jayne Chapman BEMSpokesperson, apologies (other health-related reason)
PH
Councillor Paul HoneywoodSpokesperson, in attendance
ID
Ian DavidsonOfficer, absent (on leave)

All 25 on the meeting page

On this subject at Tendring

Search all
  1. Management Team Items - Report of the Assistant Director (Corporate Policy & Support) - A.13 - Outcome of the Council's Carnarvon Terrace Regeneration Project Task & Finish GroupThis decision
  2. Management Team Items - Report of the Corporate Director (Planning and Community) - A.12 - Publication of the Council's First BNG report for the Period February 2024 to December 2025Approved
  3. Management Team Items - Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.10 - (1) Local Government & Social Care Ombudsman Finding and (2) Housing Ombudsman FindingDecided
  4. Management Team Items - Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.3 - Local Government & Social Care Ombudsman FindingDecided
  5. Management Team Items - Report of the Head of Democratic Services & Elections - A.8 - Petition: "Save Citizens Advice Tendring"Decided
  6. Management Team Items - Report of the Monitoring Officer - A.8 - Housing Ombudsman Findings and other Incidental and Related mattersDecided

More from Tendring Cabinet

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
13 Nov 2026 Minutes of the Last MeetingRESOLVED that the minutes of the meeting of the Cabinet, held on Friday 23 October 2026, be approved as a correct rec... Approved Open
13 Nov 2026 Cabinet Members' Items - Report of the Portfolio Holder for Corporate Finance & Governance - A.1 - Financial Performance Report 2026/27 - General Update at the end of September 2026RESOLVED that Cabinet – (a) notes the Council’s in-year financial position as at the end of September 2026; (b) appro... Approved Open
13 Nov 2026 Cabinet Members' Items - Report of the Corporate Finance & Governance Portfolio Holder - A.2 - The Local Council Tax Support Scheme, Discretionary Council Tax Exemptions / Discounts / Premiums for 2027/28 and Annual Minimum Revenue Provision Policy Statement 2027/28RESOLVED that Cabinet – a) agrees that the underlying LCTS scheme for 2027/28 remains the same as the current year, a... Agreed Open
13 Nov 2026 Cabinet Members' Items - Report of the Housing & Planning Portfolio Holder - A.3 - Annual Housing Improvement, Performance & Assurance Report 2025/26RESOLVED that Cabinet – (a) notes the contents of the Annual Housing Improvement, Performance & Assurance Report 2025... Decided Open
13 Nov 2026 Cabinet Members' Items - Report of the Housing & Planning Portfolio Holder - A.4 - Adoption of the Conservation Area Character Appraisals and Management Plans for St Osyth and Manningtree & MistleyRESOLVED that – (a) the outcome of the public consultation exercises summarised in this report (A.4) be noted; and (b... Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies