It was agreed that the final wording of the refusal notice would be circulated to the Committee for approval. RESOLVED that Planning Application 23/1043/FUL be refused, contrary to the Officer’s recommendation. NOTE - Wording of Reason for Refusal The proposed extension by virtue of its ad hoc nature, siting, proximity to rear boundary and elevated positioning relative to the neighbouring properties to the west would, together with the existing extent of built form, result in the overdevelopment and over intensive use of the site, to the detriment of the character of the area and amenity of neighbouring occupiers. The overdevelopment of the site is further exacerbated by the increased parking shortfall which would lead to parking on the adjacent highway, to the detriment of the safe movement and free flow of other highway users. The development is therefore contrary to Policies CP1, CP10 ... view the full minutes text for item PC8/23
Word for word from the decision Three Rivers published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.threerivers.gov.uk
23/1043/FUL - Construction of part single, part two storey rear extension (roof accommodation) and alterations and additions to fenestration and rooflights to existing care home to create additional bedrooms and office space at Arden House, 31 Upper Highway, Abbots Langley, Hertfordshire, WD4 8PP
Parish: Abbots Langley Parish Council Ward: Gade Valley Expiry of Statutory Period: 09.09.2023 Case Officer: Aaron Roberts Extension of Time: 26.10.2023
Recommendation: That PLANNING PERMISSION BE GRANTED subject to conditions.
Reason for consideration by the Committee:
Called in by Abbots Langley Parish Council unless Officers are minded to refuse. Concerns include overdevelopment and being overbearing to the houses on Lauderdale Road.
Called in by 3 Members of the Planning Committee due to concerns regarding overlooking.
To view all documents forming part of this application please go to the following website:
On 30th September 2023, Members of the Planning Committee undertook a site visit following a deferral at September’s Committee.
On 9th October 2023, the case officer received amended plans 23/2713/02 REV C and 23/2713/101 REV D. Plan number 23/2713/02 REV C shows further details of the landscaping to the rear and also includes a section drawing (of the extension and rear garden).
Plan number 23/2713/101 REV D includes the addition of 0.6m high picket fencing along the front boundary (with openings for pedestrian and vehicle access). The parking configuration has also been amended to show parking for a minimum of 5 vehicles.
1 Relevant Planning and Enforcement History
1.18/795/76 - Temporary bedroom
1.28/735/78 - Replacement fire escape
1.38/197/92 - Single storey rear extension. – Permitted
1.407/1127/FUL – Single storey rear extension to residents lounge at rear with rooflight - Permitted, not implemented.
2. Description of Application Site
2.1The application site comprises a heavily extended detached building located on the western side of Upper Highway in Abbots Langley. It is currently used as a nursing home. 2.2 The building has a variety of extensions including a single-storey rear element linked to the main building. The building has a ‘U’ shaped form.
2.3There is a hard standing parking area in front of the building and two vehicular accesses onto Upper Highway.
2.4The adjacent building to the south-east, No. 29 Upper Highway is a detached residential dwelling. This dwelling is a Grade II Listed Building. This property is set further forward towards the highway compared to the application building. The rear building line of this adjacent dwelling is approximately in line with the front elevation of the application building. The dwelling is offset from the shared boundary by 8.5m. There is a 1.8m high fence on this shared boundary.
2.5The adjacent dwelling to the north, number 31A is a semi-detached residential dwelling. This dwelling is offset from the shared boundary by 3m. There is an approximately 1.8m high fence on this shared boundary.
2.6To the rear (west) of the site there are a number of detached dwellings along Lauderdale Road, which are located on a lower land level than the application site.
2.7To the south-east of the application site, there are two Grade II Listed Buildings, No. 29 Upper Highway and Queen Anne Cottage. There is another Listed building to the south of these buildings, Oak Beam (No.25 Upper highway).
3. Description of Proposed Development
3.1This application seeks planning permission for the construction of part single, part two storey rear extension (roof accommodation) and alterations and additions to fenestration and rooflights to existing care home to create additional bedrooms and office space.
3.2During the course of the application, amended plans were received. A summary of the amendments can be seen below:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.