AI summaryThurrock Cabinet extends the Matrix agency worker managed service contract by one year to 14 December 2027, keeping the current MSP in place while officers prepare a future re-procurement.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeAgreedUses existing extension option with Matrix SCM Ltd
MoneyNo new procurement costs statedMatrix system costs added to day rate of agency staff
What happens nextPrepare for re-procurement in 2027HR, Procurement, Finance and Legal to lead market engagement and specification work
Who it affectsAround 200 agency workers and supplierContinuation of supply across council directorates
What was decided
Cabinet agreed to use the one-year extension clause in the current Matrix contract, extending it until 14 December 2027, with no changes to terms, scope or pricing. Report 2.1, 1.6, P28
Cabinet delegated authority to the Executive Director of Corporate Services, with the Chief Financial Officer and Lead Cabinet Member, to formalise the extension and start preparatory work for the next re-procurement. Report 2.2, 9.5
Why
Extending preserves service continuity, compliance with IR35 and the Agency Workers Regulations 2010, and existing negotiated rate cards, while avoiding mobilisation costs of appointing a new supplier. Report P33, 1.4, 1.5, 7.1
The council is engaged in its transformation programme and Local Government Reorganisation; running a full procurement now would divert HR, Procurement, Finance and Legal capacity at a difficult time. Report P33
What happens next
Officers will give the required three months' written notice to Matrix to extend the contract, subject to call-in expiring. Report 9.2, 9.3
A contract modification form will be completed to obtain SAP approval of spend and set up a Blanket Purchasing Agreement managed by HR. Report 9.5
During the 12-month extension, HR, Procurement, Finance and Legal will carry out market engagement, options appraisal and specification development for a re-procurement in 2027. Report P30, 1.6
Options considered
Chosen: Exercise the one-year contract extension with Matrix to 14 December 2027. Maintains continuity, retains current pricing, avoids mobilisation costs, frees capacity for LGR and transformation, and creates time to plan re-procurement. Report 5.1, P36, P37, P38, P39, P40, P41, P42, P43
Rejected: Decline the extension and run an immediate full re-procurement. Would require significant HR, Procurement, Finance and Legal resource, risk transition gaps and service disruption, and divert capacity during LGR and the council's Transformation programme. Report P36, P38, P39, P41
Rejected: Allow the contract to lapse without action. Would leave the council without a compliant MSP, returning to the pre-2011 conditions of multiple agencies, higher margins, fragmented administration and off-contract spend. Report 5.3
Implications
Financial: No new procurement mobilisation or transition costs; existing negotiated rate cards and tiered agency margins are retained, supporting budget stability. Report 7.1, 7.3
Legal: The extension is treated as compliant with Public Contract Regulations 2015, regulation 72(1)(a), and the council's Contract Procedure Rules; Legal and Procurement have confirmed compliance. Report 9.2, 9.4
Legal: Because of the report timing, a full three months' written notice may not be feasible once call-in expires; this is mitigated by Matrix indicating willingness to extend. Report 9.3
Equalities: An Equality Impact Assessment relevance check found no adverse equality impacts; a full EIA was assessed as not necessary. Report 10.1, 10.3
Risk: Risks logged include service disruption if the contract lapsed, procurement non-compliance, IR35 and AWR exposure, supplier performance failure, and continued long-term agency dependency; each has identified mitigations. Report 8.1, P53
Staffing: Approximately 200 agency workers are engaged through the current arrangement; ongoing work explores transferring long-term agency workers to Matrix Payroll as permanent staff to remove the agency markup fee. Report P33
Other: No ICT or digital infrastructure implications as the Matrix managed service platform is unchanged; no TUPE or restructuring obligations arise. Report 11.3
Who and where
Matrix SCM Limited, the current managed service provider Report 1.2, P15
Around 200 agency workers currently engaged through the MSP Report P33
Council directorates using agency staff, including adults, children's and place services Report P33, P29
Council HR, Procurement, Finance and Legal teams who will lead the future re-procurement exercise Report P30
Timeline
2011: Council first contracted with an MSP for agency staffing, initially Comensura. Report 1.2
13 September 2023: Cabinet approved re-procurement via ESPO MSTAR4 framework using neutral vendor MSP model. Report P15, 1.3
15 December 2023: Current contract with Matrix SCM Ltd commenced for three years. Report 1.3, P15
5 August 2026: Risk implications and EIA relevance check verified. Report P52, P64
7 August 2026: Financial implications verified by Head of Finance Business Partnering. Report 7.3
24 August 2026: Legal implications verified. Report P59
16 September 2026: Cabinet decision to extend the contract by one year.
14 December 2026: Original contract expiry date; contract end of initial three-year term. Report 1.4, P28
14 December 2027: New contract expiry after the one-year extension. Report 1.6, 2.1, P28
2027: Future re-procurement exercise planned during the extension period. Report 1.6, P30
Plain English for the jargon
MSP (Managed Service Provider): A neutral vendor that manages the supply of agency workers on behalf of the council.
Neutral vendor MSP model: Arrangement where one provider supplies agency staff from multiple agencies at agreed rates, giving price consistency and single-point management.
IR35: Off-payroll working rules that determine the tax treatment of engagements with agency and interim workers.
AWR (Agency Workers Regulations 2010): Regulations giving agency workers equal treatment in basic working and employment conditions after 12 weeks in the same role.
ESPO MSTAR4 framework: A publicly available framework agreement used as a compliant route to market for procuring agency worker managed services.
PCR 2015 (Public Contract Regulations 2015): UK regulations governing how public bodies procure goods, services and works; regulation 72(1)(a) covers modifications allowed where the original procurement documents set out clear review clauses.
LGR (Local Government Reorganisation): Structural changes to local government in the council's area that may affect future service and procurement needs.
EIA (Equality Impact Assessment): An assessment of how a proposal may affect people with protected characteristics under the Equality Act 2010.
KPI: Key Performance Indicator, used to measure Matrix's contract performance, including fulfilment, compliance and timesheet accuracy.
LTW (Long-term worker): Agency workers on extended assignments who may be moved to the Matrix payroll model to remove the agency markup fee.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item391
Resolved
2.1 Cabinet agreed to utilise the one-year extension option contained within the current contract and extend the existing contract until 14 December 2027. 2.2 Cabinet delegate authority to the Executive Director of Corporate Services, in consultation with the Chief Financial Officer and the Lead Cabinet Member, to formalise the contract extension and to commence the preparatory work for the future re-procurement exercise ahead of contract expiry on 14 December 2027. Reason for the decision: as outlined in the report This decision is subject to call-in
Word for word from the decision Thurrock published for this meeting.Source: democracy.thurrock.gov.uk
1.1This report seeks approval of a recommendation to extend the Council’s current Managed Service Provider (“MSP”) agency worker contract for a period of a further year.
1.2Since 2011 the Council has contracted with an MSP for the provision of all its agency staffing resources. The MSP model was procured as it realised best value for the Council with significant cost reductions and ensured a consistent approach to the provision and management of good quality agency workers. A contract was originally awarded to Comensura, acting as an MSP in 2011, then later following ESPO Star framework 3 and 4 mini competitions contracts were awarded to Matrix SCM Limited (“Matrix”) in December 2015, December 2019 and the current contract was awarded in December 2023.
1.3On 13 December 2023, Cabinet considered the re-procurement of the Councils agency worker contract and agreed to continue with the neutral vendor MSP contract model (option C of the report). Following this decision, a contract was awarded to Matrix, though the (ESPO) MSTAR4 Framework, commencing on 15 December 2023 for a period of three years until 14 December 2026, and including an option to extend for a further year.
1.4The current service model of ‘neutral vendor’ MSP continues to provide the best mix of cost certainty, the ability to include local agencies and the use of tier specialist providers for hard to recruit positions. Contract performance has been good with consistent pricing, ongoing cost control and useful management information. The current contract expires on 14 December 2026 and contains an option to extend the contract for one year. This creates an opportunity to confirm continuity of agency worker provision of suitable quality and best value, whilst creating the conditions for a strategically timed future re-procurement.
1.5Spend on agency workers will remain unavoidable as there is an ongoing requirement for a flexible workforce. It is critical that the supply of agency workers is procured in a way that ensures the Council secures best value for money, retains compliance with the Agency Worker Regulations 2010 and IR35 requirements, and keeps the process of procuring agency workers as streamlined as possible.
1.6Having reviewed the available options, this report recommends that Cabinet agrees to exercise the contractually permitted one year extension with Matrix SCM Ltd from 15 December 2026 to 14 December 2027. This approach maintains service continuity, preserves financial and compliance stability and allows offers the time required to plan and deliver a strategically aligned re- procurement exercise during 2027.
Recommendations
For the reasons set out in this report, the Cabinet is recommended to:
2.1Agree to utilise the one-year extension option contained within the current contract and extend the existing contract until 14 December 2027.
2.2Delegate authority to the Executive Director of Corporate Services, in consultation with the Chief Financial Officer and the Lead Cabinet Member, to formalise the contract extension and to commence the preparatory work for the future re-procurement exercise ahead of contract expiry on 14 December 2027.
3. Commissioner’s Comments
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Thurrock Transport Strategy Adoption2.1 Cabinet approved the Thurrock Transport Strategy given in Appendix 1 to be progressed to Full Council for adoptio...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.