CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Torridge District Council
Standards, Wednesday 21 December 2016 at 2.00pm

Applications for Dispensation - Councillors Margaret Brown and Cathrine Simmons

Decided Committee 1 paper

Standards decided this item on Wednesday 21 December 2016. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item16

Resolved

Resolved : To grant a dispensation to Councillor Brown for both STITCH Group and North Devon Save Our Hospital Services (SOHS) and Councillor Simmons for SOHS, for a duration of 12 months, in order that Councillor Brown and Councillor Simmons may speak and vote on relevant matters; subject to the normal constraints. (Vote: For 3)
Word for word from the decision Torridge published for this meeting. Source: democracy.torridge.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Torridge's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Standards

REPORT OF Senior Solicitor and Monitoring Officer To: Standards Committee Subject: Applications for Dispensation – Councillors Margaret Brown and Cathrine Simmons Date: 21 December 2016 Reference: JH

PURPOSE OF REPORT: To decide whether to grant a dispensation

1. INTRODUCTION

A Councillor who has a registerable interest in a matter, unless that interest relates to an appointment to an outside body, must not take part in the discussion or the vote on that matter and must leave the room while the discussion is taking place.

A Councillor with a registerable interest can seek a dispensation under the Council’s Code of Conduct for Members. This report deals with 2 such requests for dispensation.

2. REPORT

Section 33 of the Localism Act states that an authority may grant a dispensation relieving a Councillor from the restrictions on voting or taking part in the discussion on a matter.

The dispensation must specify how long it has been granted for and that period can not exceed 4 years. Therefore a dispensation can be granted allowing a Councillor to speak or vote or both on a matter at any time in the following 4 years, or for a shorter period of time.

Before granting a dispensation, the authority must be satisfied, after considering all of the circumstances, that the dispensation is justified by reference to a particular condition set out in s33(2) of the Act. The relevant conditions are:

(a) That so many members of the decision-making body have an interest preventing participation that it would ‘impede the transaction of the business’. In practice, this means that the decision-making body would be inquorate as a result;

(b) That without the dispensation, the representation of different political groups on the decision-making body would be so upset as to alter the outcome of any vote on the matter;

(c) Granting the dispensation is in the interests of persons living in the authority's area; or

(d) It is otherwise appropriate to grant a dispensation. Two requests for dispensation have been received, both from Councillors who are members of the STITCH Group (Save The Irreplaceable Torrington Community Hospital). The requests are from Councillors Margaret Brown and Cathrine Simmons, both ward members for the Torrington area.

A dispensation was previously granted in relation to both Councillors by the Standards Committee on 8 August 2014 in relation to the same matter. Those dispensations were for a period of 2 years, but the continued activity of the STITCH Group has lead to further requests for dispensation.

For reference, the initial requests for dispensation, including the reasons for and scope of the dispensations sought are set out in emails attached as Appendix A to this report. Essentially, both Councillors wish to continue to be able to speak and vote on matters concerning the Torrington Community Hospital for an extended period of time of up to the permissible 4 years.

The earlier dispensations applied to any committee or full Council and were the same for both Councillors. It is recommended the same consistent approach is taken in relation to the current requests.

It is for Members to decide whether the granting of a dispensation is in accordance with the conditions set out in section 33(2) and the terms of any dispensation granted.

3. IMPLICATIONS

Legal Implications There are no legal implications from this decision, although there clearly are if a Member with a registerable interest speaks or votes without a dispensation.

Financial Implications There are no financial implications

Human Resources Implications There are none identified

Sustainability Implications There are none identified

Equality/Diversity There are none identified

Risk Management There are none identified

Compliance with Policies and Strategies There are no non-compliance issues.

Ward Member and Leader Member Views Not applicable

4. CONCLUSIONS

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Applications for Dispensation: Councillors Margaret Brown and Cathrine SimmonsReport 65 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

8 of 15 attended
KC
Councillor Ken CarrollChair, present
BB
Councillor Betty BoundyVice-Chair, apologies
ML
Councillor Mervyn LangmeadCommittee Member, present
SR
Councillor Sam RobinsonCommittee Member, apologies
DB
Councillor David BrentonCommittee Member, apologies
MB
Councillor Margaret BrownCommittee Member, present
GD
Councillor Gaston DezartCommittee Member, present
BB
Barbara BerkhauerIndependent Persons, present
RL
Mr Roger LevickIndependent Persons, present
RC
Richard ClarkParish Representative, present
HM
Harold MartinParish Representative, present
JH
Jamie HollisOfficer, in attendance

All 15 on the meeting page

More from Torridge Standards

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
17 Jun 2026 Minutes of the Standards Committee meeting held on 3rd December 2025That the minutes of the Standards Committee held on 03 December 2025 be amended with the above change and agreed and ... Agreed Open
17 Jun 2026 Agreement of Agenda between Parts I and II (if applicable)That the agenda, as published, be agreed. (Vote: For, Unanimous) Agreed Open
3 Dec 2025 Minutes of the Standards Committee meeting held on 18 June 2025That the Minutes of the meeting held on 18 June 2025 be agreed and signed as a correct record, with an amendment to r... Agreed Open
3 Dec 2025 Agreement of Agenda between Parts I and II (if applicable)That the agenda, as circulated, be agreed. (Vote: For Unanimous) Agreed Open
3 Dec 2025 Exclusion of Members of the PublicResolved That the meeting move to Part II. (Vote: For Unanimous) Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies