CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Torridge District Council
Plans Committee, Friday 23 July 2021 at 9.30am

Comprehensive Agenda Report

Agreed Committee 3 papers

Plans Committee agreed this item on Friday 23 July 2021. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item26b

Resolved

It was agreed that as there was only one presentation, defining each application, that a discussion would follow and each application would have an individual determination. The Development Management Team Leader presented the report detailing the main planning considerations. A discussion followed with comments and concerns raised which included: · Costs · Affordable Housing and S106 contributions · Challenge viability appraisals with the suggestion of a separate meeting being arranged. The Chair invited [name removed], from the District Valuers Office, to speak and address concerns. It was confirmed that figures used are industry standard figures established via numerous planning appeals and that it would be recommended that a S106 contribution review mechanism is included. The Planning Manager provided clarification on the viability assessment process and confirmed that a review can take place after a period. [name removed] agreed to attend a separate Plans Committee meeting to discuss viability reports further. The Chair and Planning Manager to arrange following the meeting. Following a query, it was confirmed that a review mechanism would be specified in a S106 agreement beforehand and solicitors from both parties and the three Great Torrington Ward Members would be involved. The Chair thanked [name removed] for attending and answering questions. The Development Management Team Leader confirmed that conditions in planning applications 1/0526/2020/FUL and 1/0528/2020/FULM could be amended to consider outside garden disabled access to the house designs which incorporate rear decks. This design approach is a small part of the overall scheme, specific to the flood zone area and recommended by the Environment Agency. An explanation was given by the Development Management Team Leader on the closeness of the listed building to the proposed retail and apartment building. The Legal Services Manager advised that four separate votes would need to be taken.
Word for word from the decision Torridge published for this meeting. Source: democracy.torridge.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Torridge's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Plans Committee

Viability Report: Proposed mixed use development on Land at Taddiport (former Creamery), Great Torrington, Devon

Report for: Torridge District Council

Prepared by: XXXXXXXXXXXX BSc MRICS Principal Surveyor RICS Registered Valuer DVS

Tel: XXXXXXXXXXXX

[email protected]

Case Number: 1528803

Client Reference: Torrington Creamery

Date: 9 July 2021

The VOA is an Executive Agency of HM Revenue and Customs

OFFICIAL 1. Executive Summary

Proposed Development Details:

This report provides an Independent Review of a Financial Viability Appraisal in connection with:

Proposed Development: Redevelopment of the former Creamery at Great Torrington to provide 173 dwellings, 439.26 square metres of retail, and associated infrastructure. Subject of Assessment: Former Torrington Creamery, Rolle Road, Great Torrington, Devon. Planning Refs: 1/0039/2016/OUTM, 1/1231/2018/OUTM, 1/0524/2020/FULM, 1/0526/2020/FULM Applicant: International Property Consultancy Ltd. Applicant's Viability Advisor: Messrs Alder King

Non-Technical Summary of Viability Assessment Inputs

DVS Viability Agreed Appraisal Inputs Agent Review (Y/N) 29th October 2019 and updated appraisal Assessment Date July 2021 summary dated 11th June 2021 Scheme, Gross Internal 16,860 m², 6.9 16,679 m², 6.9 N Area, Site Area hectares hectares Development Period 81 months 63 months N

Gross Development Value £41,367,337 £42,598,056 N Planning Policy / S.106 Total £0 £927,706 N Construction Cost inc. Prelims, External Works £27,267,780 £27,171,641 N and infrastructure Total Contingency 5% 5% Y Professional Fees 8% 8% Y 6% debit and 0.5% 6% debit and 2% Finance Interest rates N credit credit Other Fees Sales / Agency Fees 3% 3% Y £600 per market £600 per market Legal Fees Y unit unit Land Acquiring Costs 1.5% plus SDLT 1.5% plus SDLT Y Profit Target % 18.5% 18.5% and 6% N Benchmark Land Value £1,700,000 £1,700,000 Y

LDG31 (08.20) Private and Confidential Page 1 Viability Conclusion Planning Compliant Not viable Not viable Y Scheme Deliverable Scheme Potentially Yes Y

2 Introduction:

2.1I refer to your revised instructions dated 18th January 2021 and our Terms of Engagement at the inception of the case dated 1st December 2014.

2.2The opinion of the development viability of the proposed development scheme as re- assessed is based on a review of the planning applicants/agents report dated 29 October 2019, and revised appraisal summaries dated 19 January 2021, and most recently 11 June 2021 following a revision to the numbers of residential units, and greater clarity in regard to infrastructure costs.

2.3I have completed my viability re-assessment and. I am pleased to report to you as follows:

2.4A copy of my original Terms of Engagement dated 1 December 2014 is attached.

2.5Identification of Client

Torridge District Council

2.6Purpose of Assessment

It is understood that Torridge District Council Planning Department require an independent opinion on the viability information provided by Messrs Alder King (AK) on behalf of the applicant in terms of the extent to which their financial viability assessment is fair and reasonable, and whether the assumptions made are acceptable and can be relied upon to determine the viability of the scheme.

2.7Subject of the Assessment

Former Torrington Creamery and adjacent land, Rolle Road, Great Torrington, Devon

3 Date of Assessment / Date of Report

3.1The date of assessment is 9 July 2021.

Please note that values change over time and that a viability assessment provided on a particular date may not be valid at a later date.

4 Viability Methodology / Professional Guidance

4.1The review of the applicant’s viability assessment has been prepared in accordance with the recommended practice set out in the National Planning Policy Framework; the NPPG on Viability (July 2018, updated May 2019, September 2019) and the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) Professional Statement, Financial Viability in Planning

LDG31 (08.20) Private and Confidential Page 2

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
2021-07-09 DVS Torrington Creamery viability report v2 redactedReport 486 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
Comprehensive Agenda Report: CreameryAgenda 388 KB Download
PDF
Comprehensive Agenda ReportAgenda 155 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

8 of 22 attended
CL
Councillor Chris LeatherChair, present
MB
Councillor Margaret BrownVice-Chair, present
RB
Councillor Richard BoughtonCommittee Member, present
RC
Councillor R CraigieCommittee Member, present
RL
Councillor Rosemary LockCommittee Member, present as substitute
DM
Councillor Dermot McGeoughCommittee Member, apologies
PW
Councillor Peter WatsonCommittee Member, present
RW
Councillor Richard WisemanCommittee Member, present
SH
Steve HearseOfficer, expected
SD
Staci DoreyOfficer, expected
SK
Sean KearneyOfficer, expected
DH
David HeyesOfficer, expected

All 22 on the meeting page

More from Torridge Plans Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
30 Jul 2026 Application No. 1/0001/2026/FULMResolved – That the ... view the full minutes text for item 288. Decided Open
30 Jul 2026 Application No. 1/0386/2026That the application is approved subject to the conditions outlined in the report. A recorded vote was taken. COUNCIL... Approved Open
30 Jul 2026 Application No. 1/0258/2026/FULThat the application be approved, with an informative added for solar, rainwater capture and heat pump provision. A r... Approved Open
30 Jul 2026 Planning DecisionsResolved - That the Planning decisions for the period 23 rd June 2026 – 15 th July 2026 be noted. Noted Open
2 Jul 2026 Planning DecisionsResolved - That the Planning decisions for the period 20/5/2026 – 23/6/2026 be noted. Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies