That in light of the initial findings, Officers should not direct resources towards the production of a detailed feasibility study and business case (at the expense of delay to other priority projects) in line with the Notice of Motion presented by Councillor Brenton. That in light of the initial findings, Officers should not direct resources towards the production of a detailed feasibility study and business case (at the expense of delay to other priority projects) in line with the Notice of Motion presented by Councillor Brenton. (Vote: For 8, Against 1)
Word for word from the decision Torridge published for this meeting.Source: democracy.torridge.gov.uk
Report : Head of Communities and Place To: Community and Resources Committee Subject: High level feasibility study on the viability of using a cruise ship for temporary accommodation at Middle Dock, Appledore. Date: 23rd January 2023
PURPOSE OF REPORT: To update members on the high-level feasibility study of using a cruise ship moored at Middle Dock to provide temporary accommodation for citizens in need of housing.
1. INTRODUCTION
At the December 2022 Full Council Meeting, Councillor Brenton presented a Notice of Motion regarding the possibility of using a cruise ship moored at Middledock as a quick solution for accommodating people requiring emergency or temporary housing. Officers have undertaken a high level investigation into the feasibility of providing this facility with estimated costs.
The exact Notice of Motion that was approved by Full Council was:
With the large numbers of cruise ships being scrapped or laid up due to a fall in demand following Covid. I propose that TDC explore the feasibility of forming a partnership with our neighbouring authorities i.e NDDC, Exeter CC etc. with a view to leasing or renting a vessel to accommodate emergency or other housing list people. Cruise ships have a high standard of habitation and self-contained servicing and a suitable craft which would fit into Middle Dock could provide a quick solution for some of our desperate citizens needing housing.
2. REPORT
Berth Length – The length of the berth at Middle Dock is 98m which will immediately limit the length of the vessel to be berthed there to a maximum of about 100m. In order to safely berth a cruise vessel of this size at Middle dock, the dock wall, bollards and shore facilities would need to be significantly upgraded. We have already seen the bollards being recently pulled from their foundations by the crane barge Bristol Giant – so in essence a complete redesign and refurbishment of Middle Dock will be required. Quay wall repair and stabilisation has been investigated and costed as part of the Appledore Clean Maritime Innovation Centre project and within the Levelling Up bid a sum of £1.5M is sought for that.
Vessel Hire - Middle Dock length makes the maximum vessel size to be something of the Fred Olsen “Balmoral” Class - 710 cabins (https://www.fredolsencruises.com/our-ships/balmoral). Picture and website link included for illustrative purposes only. This vessel is not under consideration as a possible acquisition or lease.
Economies of scale have meant that most smaller cruise ships have long since been scrapped and the remaining small survivors are vessels such as the “Hebridean Princess” (72m loa) which are now fitted and crewed for the luxury bespoke cruise market and carry 49 passengers (https://www.hebridean.co.uk/cruise-calendar/hebridean-princess-cruises/).
Picture and website link included for illustrative purposes only. This vessel is not under consideration as a possible acquisition or lease.
Leasing a vessel of this sort of specification, even one already laid up, for accommodation purposes is likely to be difficult and expensive. The long term hire of a vessel removes it from sea service but the vessel machinery must still be kept functional if the ship is to maintain her certification and tickets, critical to the value of the vessel – so she will also require a crew, even it if is only chefs and engineers - all of which comes at a cost.
A rough estimate is about £25,000 a month hire figure – the final sum will depend on the vessel and the negotiating powers of TDC.
Berth Depth – Middle Dock and the navigational channel up to Middle dock “dries out” at about 2 hours either side of high tide. Their charted depth is about 0.5m above chart datum and any proposal to bring sea going ships into the river must account for this. There are 2 solutions; either make the channel deeper and maintain that depth or bring vessels that are capable of “taking the ground” with each tide.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Harbour Masters Quarterly ReportIt was agreed that future reports would state the quarterly period. When asked the Director of Communities & Place ad...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.