That the 5 identified car parks within the report become cashless parking sites be refused. (Vote: For – 10, Against – 0, Abstentions – 1) That the 5 identified car parks within the report become cashless parking sites be refused. (Vote: For – 10, Against – 0, Abstentions – 1)
Word for word from the decision Torridge published for this meeting.Source: democracy.torridge.gov.uk
To consider the suitability of converting 5 Pay and Display car parks to cashless payment only to reduce cash handling costs and extend the longevity of cash taking pay and display machines in other locations.
1. INTRODUCTION
As an early part of the budgeting process officers were tasked with suggesting proposals that either help the council to generate more income or save the Council expenditure. One such suggestion, presented to the Member Budget Working group was to reduce the costs of cash handling by making 5 car parks across the district cashless.
2. REPORT
The 5 car parks identified are:
The Cattle Market Car Park, Bideford Springfield Car Park, Bideford Odun Road Car Park, Appledore West Appledore Car Park, Appledore Well Park Car Park, Holsworthy
If approved payment for parking would be available by car payment at the machine or by the use of Ringo (app or telephone line).
Each of the car parks selected has a single pay and display machine.
The table below shows a breakdown of takings at the suggested locations in 23/24. It also shows the cost to the authority of cash collections at the car park locations.
The total income across the 5 car parks in 23/24 was £138,623
22% of transactions were made with cash. 30% of transactions were made with a credit or debit card at the machine. 48% of transactions were made by using Ringo (App or telephone)
The total cash collection cost associated with these car parks was £8,621 which represents 28% of the cash takings on those sites. Cash collection rates are due to rise by 9% later this year. Site Cash 23/24 Cards RingGo
Cattle Market £13,126.15 £10,720.00 £27,143.10
Spring Field £2,526.30 £1,316.00 £4,618.20
Odun Road £3,545.60 £14,858.70 £15,143.30
West Appledore £3,214.50 £11,579.60 £11,991.40
Well Park £8,219.85 £3,172.00 £7,449.08
Sub Totals £30,632.40 £41,646.30 £66,345.08
Cash collection cost £8,621.76
Notes:
Impending increase of 9% Fuel Surcharge not included
3. IMPLICATIONS
Legal implications
N/A.
Financial implications
The proposal will save the council circa £10K per annum in cash collection fees.
If successful the proposal will mean that the cash collection mechanisms from the cashless machines will be available for reuse in other machines , thus saving on maintenance cost and extending the lifespan of those machines.
Human Resources Implications
Within existing resources
Sustainability Implications
N/A.
Equality/Diversity
None directly related to the decision to be taken at this meeting
Risk management
Risks are not considered to be high with the proposal Compliance with Policies and Strategies
In compliance with the Off street Parking Places Order
Data Protection (GDPR) Implications
None
Climate Change
While only a small impact the proposal will reduce vehicle movements to the selected car parks by cash collectors and maintenance staff thus reducing the carbon footprint of the authority.
Ward Member and Leader Member Views
This matter was referred to Community and Resources Committee by the member Budget Working Group as any decision has implications beyond the finances of the proposal.
4. CONCLUSIONS
The potential financial savings of the proposal are clear and, given the trends in preferred payment method it is unlikely that going cashless in the suggested car parks will have an adverse effect on pay and display taking at any location. The proposal will save circa £10K per annum.
Transaction fees are applicable to electronic payment also but these are around 15% per transaction and stays within the cark park are longer when purchases are made by those means.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Harbour Masters Quarterly ReportIt was agreed that future reports would state the quarterly period. When asked the Director of Communities & Place ad...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.