Resolved
That it be approved to acquire the electric replacement vehicles as detailed in the report. (Vote: For – unanimous) That the recommendation for the purchase of two electric replacement vehicles be approved. Vote: (For – Unanimous).
Community & Resources approved this item on Monday 25 November 2024. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved
That it be approved to acquire the electric replacement vehicles as detailed in the report. (Vote: For – unanimous) That the recommendation for the purchase of two electric replacement vehicles be approved. Vote: (For – Unanimous).
To obtain resolution to purchase no.2 replacement Estates Department vans. It is proposed that a transition to electric vehicles is made at this juncture.
The Committee is requested to note the over and above capital cost of £11,744 when compared to diesel equivalents.
1. INTRODUCTION
The estates maintenance team currently operate no.2 vehicles which assist in the delivery of minor works and facilities management services across the TDC property portfolio.
The existing vehicles are 14 & 15 years old respectively and need to be replaced. This is an opportune time to consider transitioning to electric vehicles rather than conventional diesel replacement.
This report aims to highlight the rationale behind this proposal.
2. REPORT
The commercial vehicles currently used by the estate maintenance team are as follows:
Ford Transit van WF60MYG – registered 2010 with 97K miles Ford Transit Connect WF59YOC – registered 2009 with 126K miles.
Ordinarily TDC depreciates its vehicles over an 8-year period. Both these vehicles have surpassed their useful economic life. There is a real prospect of both vehicles not meeting emissions regulations at their next MOT.
The replacement of the vehicles had been budgeted for in the vehicle replacement programme FY24/25 at an estimated capital cost of £50,100.
TDC have a commitment to working towards being a Net Zero Carbon Council by 2030.The transition towards an electric vehicle fleet (where operationally and economically viable to do so) will assist in meeting this target. The gap between the capital cost of acquiring electric vehicles vs diesel has narrowed considerably and is evidenced in the table below:
Cost differential Vehicle type Diesel (ex.VAT) Electric (ex. VAT) (ex.VAT)
Toyota city icon £18,362 £24,007 £5,375
Toyota Pro ace £26,736 £33,106 £6,369
£45,368 £57,114 £11,744
Table 1.0 Financial cost comparison table.
Vehicle costs quoted are inclusive of ply lining and roof rack system for the Pro ace (Transit replacement)
The vehicles are currently based at Riverbank House which currently has two 7.5Kwh charging points. The building has a solar PV array which significantly offsets the costs of vehicle charging.
The proposed Toyota vehicles have been trialled by the team over a number of working days. A scoring matrix was produced comparing operability & range compared with the existing diesel vehicles. The electric vehicles performed well; the build quality was particularly impressive.
Testing included driving to Holsworthy & Torrington with laden vehicles to ensure sufficient range capability. Toyota a have a dealership in Barnstaple which will reduce additional travel time & cost relating to travelling to Exeter based dealerships for servicing.
A life cycle cost comparison between diesel and electric has not been undertaken in this instance. Electric vehicles have lower maintenance costs and fuelling costs, so the total cost of ownership is likely to be lower than that of a diesel vehicles.
3. IMPLICATIONS
None
• Budgeted cost - £50,100 FY 24/25 • Actual cost - £57,114 • Differential purchase cost - £11,744 (between diesel/ electric)
Human Resources Implications
None
Sustainability/Biodiversity Implications
Expanding the TDC electric vehicle fleet will help meet the 2030 Net Zero Carbon target that the Council aspires to.
Equality/Diversity
None
The reputational risk of not moving towards our Net Zero Carbon target is amplified if these minor “wins” are not capitalised on.
Compliance with Policies and Strategies
The purchase of these vehicles meets TDC sustainability policies & climate change aspirations.
Data Protection (GDPR) Implications
None
Climate Change
The proposal meets the aspirations of the Climate Change Working Group
Ward Member and Lead Member Views Cllr. R Hicks supported proposal Date of Consultation – 7th November 2024
3. CONCLUSIONS
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
PDF |
Estates Commercial Vehicle ReplacementReport | 197 KB | DownloadRead as text |
Follow Community & Resources at Torridge and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
| Meeting | Decision | Outcome | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7 Sep 2026 | Minutes of the Community & Resources Committee meeting held on 13th July 2026Resolved: That the Minutes of the meeting held on 13 th July be signed as a correct record. (Vote: For – 10, Against ... | Decided | Open |
| 7 Sep 2026 | Agreement of Agenda between Parts I and IIResolved: That the Agenda as circulated be agreed. (Vote: For – unanimous) | Agreed | Open |
| 7 Sep 2026 | Housing Enforcement PolicyRESOLVED: That the amended Housing Enforcement Policy be adopted. (Vote: For – 11, Against – 0, Abstentions - 1) Coun... | Approved | Open |
| 7 Sep 2026 | Harbour Masters Quarterly ReportIt was agreed that future reports would state the quarterly period. When asked the Director of Communities & Place ad... | Agreed | Open |
| 7 Sep 2026 | Exclusion of the PublicRESOLVED: That the public be excluded from the remainder of the meeting because of the likely disclosure of exempt in... | Decided | Open |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.