CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Torridge District Council
Community & Resources, Monday 2 February 2026 at 6.00pm

Cost and Benefits of Purchasing HVO for Torridge's Fleet

Agreed Committee 1 paper

AI summaryTorridge District Council defers decision on switching fleet from diesel to hydrotreated vegetable oil for one year, citing cost and sustainability concerns.

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeAgreedReview again with more robust information
Money£70,180 to £124,410 extra per yearAdditional HVO cost over diesel, based on September 2025
What happens nextReview decision in one yearWhen more robust information available
Who it affectsOperational Services fleetAround 319,000 litres of fuel per year

What was decided

Members voted 7 to 3 to do nothing on HVO for the next year and revisit the decision when more robust information is available. Report P3

The Council is not at this time committing to purchase hydrotreated vegetable oil (HVO) to replace diesel in its fleet, and no fuel storage tanks will be procured for the new Operational Services Centre for that purpose. Report P6, P30

Why

Officers could not obtain assurances of independent auditing of HVO feedstocks or of claimed reductions in vehicle emissions. Report P28

Lead Member for Operational Services opposed the proposal because of the large cost increase for Waste Services and unresolved sustainability and verification concerns. Report P40

Industry whistleblowers told the BBC that large amounts of feedstock may be virgin palm oil fraudulently relabelled as waste, and the Department of Transport launched an investigation in April 2025. Report P17

What happens next

Members will be asked to reconsider the HVO option in around one year once more robust evidence on sustainability, certification and cost is available. Report P3, P43

Officers note that priority should be given to battery powered vehicles to meet the Council's operational needs and the 2030 carbon neutral target. Report P41, P38

The money

  • £70,180 -124,410 Additional annual cost of HVO versus diesel for Operational Services fuel use, based on costing provided September 2025 Report P30
  • 319,000 litres Approximate annual fuel usage by Operational Services Report P30

Options considered

  • Rejected: Purchase HVO to replace diesel in the Operational Services fleet now. Extra cost and unresolved sustainability and feedstock auditing concerns Report P28, P30, P40
  • Chosen: Take no action for the next year and bring the matter back with more robust information. Vote 7 for, 3 against, 0 abstentions

Implications

  • Financial: Avoiding HVO for now avoids an extra £70,180 to £124,410 per year in fuel costs for Operational Services. Report P30, P33
  • Climate: Around 710 tonnes of carbon emissions, about 40% of the Council's total carbon footprint, come from fleet vehicles and remain unaddressed in the short term. Report P5
  • Risk: Risk to Council reputation if HVO is purchased from unsustainable sources, particularly given fraud and palm oil concerns. Report P15, P17, P37
  • Staffing: No human resources implications identified. Report P34
  • Legal: No legal implications identified. Report P32
  • Equalities: No equality or diversity implications identified. Report P36

Who and where

  • Operational Services, including Waste Services Report P6, P30, P40
  • Council tenants and residents receiving waste and other frontline services Report P6, P40
  • Two local diesel suppliers, who also offer HVO Report P30
  • Other UK local authorities that already use HVO Report P10, P11

Timeline

  • January 2025: Date of consultation on HVO Report P42
  • September 2025: Costings for HVO obtained from suppliers Report P30
  • 13th October 2025: Paper first presented to Community and Resources committee Report P3
  • December 2025: Officers consulted on revised paper Report P45
  • 2nd February 2026: Community and Resources committee votes to defer HVO decision for one year Report P1
  • 2030: Council's stated target for carbon neutral operations; EU to phase out high indirect land-use change biofuels by 2030 Report P16, P38

Plain English for the jargon

  • HVO: Hydrotreated vegetable oil, a renewable fuel made from vegetable oils, animal fats and waste oils that can be used in existing diesel engines without modification.
  • ISCC: International Sustainability and Carbon Certification, a global scheme that checks biofuels and biomass for sustainability, but the report says it does not robustly audit feedstock sources.
  • RFAS: Renewable Fuels Assurance Scheme, run by Zemo Partnership, giving fleets assurance on lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions and feedstock sustainability of renewable fuels.
  • RTFO: Renewable Transport Fuel Obligation, the UK regulation that supports renewable fuel use alongside schemes such as RFAS.
  • POME: Palm oil mill effluent, a byproduct tested for by some HVO suppliers who offer palm oil free certification.
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item602

Resolved

That it be agreed to do nothing for the next year and bring it back when we’ve got more robust information. (Vote: For – 7, Against – 3, Abstentions – 0)
Word for word from the decision Torridge published for this meeting. Source: democracy.torridge.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Torridge's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Community & Resources

REPORT OF Councillor Climate Emergency Working Group To: Community & Resources Subject: Costs and benefits of purchasing HVO for Torridge’s fleet Date: 2nd February 2026 Reference:

PURPOSE OF REPORT: To inform Councillors of the advantages and disadvantages of using hydrotreated vegetable oil (HVO) to replace diesel in the Council’s owned fleet so that they can decide if HVO is an option they wish to purchase.

Note: this paper was first presented to C&R on 13th October 2025 and is substantially the same. Comments regarding the impact of HVO on vehicle reliability, and the sustainability and certification of HVO have been added.

1. INTRODUCTION

The most recent carbon footprint calculation for Torridge District Council shows that about 710 tonnes of carbon emissions (measured as tonnes carbon equivalent) are associated with our fleet vehicles. This is approximately 40% of the Council’s total carbon footprint.

The Councillor Climate Change Working Group have asked that the Council purchase a low carbon fuel, hydrotreated vegetable oil (HVO), to replace diesel in Operational Services vehicles and to reduce our carbon emissions. HVO can only be bought in bulk and thus requires fuel storage tanks at our depots. This has not been possible to date but with the construction of our new Operational Services Centre there is an opportunity to purchase and bulk store HVO.

2. REPORT

What is HVO and how is it used? Hydrotreated vegetable oil (HVO) is a renewable fuel derived from various feedstocks including vegetable oils, animal fats and waste oils. It is produced through a hydrotreating process which removes impurities and produces a cleaner, more stable fuel.

HVO can be used in existing diesel engines without modification.

Impact on vehicles A number of organisations have chosen to use HVO in their fleet. This includes Griffiths, who worked on the A361 Link Road Upgrade, and several Local Authorities in the UK.

We have contacted Local Authorities known to use HVO, none of those who responded reported any impact on vehicle reliability.

Impact on carbon emissions HVO can be considered a carbon-neutral fuel because the carbon dioxide (CO2) released during combustion is about equal to that absorbed by the plants that originally produced the feedstocks.

Suppliers claim that HVO can reduce vehicle emissions as follows: • Up to 90% reduction in carbon emissions; • Up to 30% reduction in particulate matter; • Up to 27% reduction in nitrogen oxide; • Up to 24% reduction in carbon monoxide.

Sustainability There are significant concerns about the wider sustainability of HVO. The three main suppliers of ‘waste’ feedstocks for HVO are Indonesia, Malaysia and China.

The supply chains for HVO are complex and opaque, with insufficient information provided about the sources, transportation and production methods. Given supplies of HVO from sustainable sources are currently limited, there is strong evidence that the sharp increase in demand is driving an increase in palm oil derived HVO or palm oil used as a livestock feed alternative, contributing to further global deforestation. Even sustainably certified schemes have limitations in this area, as they do not take into consideration the significant impact of these indirect land-use changes or the full lifecycle footprint.

EU research indicates that once the effects of land use change and draining of peatland are accounted for, the greenhouse gas impact of palm-oil-derived HVO could be up to 3 times greater than standard fossil fuel diesel. Furthermore, HVO requires more vegetable oil than other methods of biodiesel production. Consequently, in 2020, the EU agreed to phase out biofuels with a high risk of indirect land-use change by 2030.

In April 2025 the Department of Transport launched an investigation into HVO after industry whistleblowers told the BBC they believe large amounts of feedstock are not waste but instead are virgin palm oil, which is being fraudulently relabelled.

Sustainability certification of HVO

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Cost and Benefits of Purchasing HVO for Torridge's FleetReport 198 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

8 of 25 attended
HG
Harvey GardnerCouncil Staff, expected
RH
Councillor Robert HicksChair, apologies
AD
Councillor Anna DartCommittee Member, apologies
DB
Councillor David BrentonCommittee Member, apologies
LB
Councillor Lauren BrightCommittee Member, present
PH
Councillor Peter HamesCommittee Member, present
KJ
Councillor Ken JamesCommittee Member, present
CL
Councillor Chris LeatherCommittee Member, present
TE
Councillor Thomas ElliottCommittee Member, present
TT
Councillor Teresa TinsleyVice-Chair, present
PP
Councillor Philip PenningtonCommittee Member, present
LP
Councillor Lyndon PiperCommittee Member, present

All 25 on the meeting page

On this subject at Torridge

Search all
  1. Cost and Benefits of Purchasing HVO for Torridge's FleetThis decision
  2. Costs and Benefits of Purchasing HVO for Torridge's Fleet.Decided

More from Torridge Community & Resources

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
7 Sep 2026 Minutes of the Community & Resources Committee meeting held on 13th July 2026Resolved: That the Minutes of the meeting held on 13 th July be signed as a correct record. (Vote: For – 10, Against ... Decided Open
7 Sep 2026 Agreement of Agenda between Parts I and IIResolved: That the Agenda as circulated be agreed. (Vote: For – unanimous) Agreed Open
7 Sep 2026 Housing Enforcement PolicyRESOLVED: That the amended Housing Enforcement Policy be adopted. (Vote: For – 11, Against – 0, Abstentions - 1) Coun... Approved Open
7 Sep 2026 Harbour Masters Quarterly ReportIt was agreed that future reports would state the quarterly period. When asked the Director of Communities & Place ad... Agreed Open
7 Sep 2026 Exclusion of the PublicRESOLVED: That the public be excluded from the remainder of the meeting because of the likely disclosure of exempt in... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies