CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Torridge District Council
Full Council, Wednesday 25 February 2026 at 6.30pm

Overview & Scrutiny Committee

Decided Committee 2 papers

AI summaryFull Council votes 27 to 1 to keep Torridge's two Scrutiny Committees, rejecting a Senior Leadership Team proposal to merge them into one after the May 2026 AGM.

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeDecidedInternal and External Overview & Scrutiny kept
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextNo next step stated in the papers
Who it affectsMembers and scrutiny arrangementsCouncil-wide governance structure unchanged

What was decided

Full Council resolved to retain the existing two Scrutiny Committees rather than merge them, by 27 votes to one.

The Senior Leadership Team's recommendation to amalgamate Internal and External Scrutiny into a single Overview & Scrutiny Committee was not approved. Report P10, P25

Why

Officers had cited persistent poor attendance, several meetings falling inquorate, embarrassment caused to visiting external speakers, and added officer time and administrative cost from cancelled meetings. Report P5, P6, P7

They also pointed to ambiguity over whether some matters, especially financial support to external organisations, sat within internal or external scrutiny, and a restriction stopping Scrutiny Members from substituting on Community & Resources. Report P9

What happens next

The papers do not set out any next steps following the vote to retain the two committees; the planned implementation after the AGM on 18 May 2026 will not go ahead as proposed. Report P25

Options considered

  • Rejected: Merge Internal and External Scrutiny Committees into a single Overview & Scrutiny Committee. Full Council voted 27 to 1 to retain the two existing committees Report P8, P10, P25
  • Chosen: Retain the current two Scrutiny Committee structure

Implications

  • Governance: Constitutional amendments to redefine the Scrutiny structure are no longer being pursued, as the report had noted such changes would be needed. Report P12
  • Risk: The risk of inquorate meetings and the resulting reputational damage, identified by the Senior Leadership Team, remains. Report P17
  • Other: The ambiguity over whether matters involving financial support to external organisations fall within internal or external scrutiny continues. Report P9
  • Staffing: Officer time spent supporting two Scrutiny Committees, rather than one, continues, with the report having flagged potential efficiency gains from a merger. Report P14
  • Equalities: No equality or diversity implications were identified in the report. Report P16
  • Climate: No climate change implications were identified in the report. Report P20

Who and where

  • Members of the Internal and External Overview & Scrutiny Committees Report P3, P9
  • Officers supporting Scrutiny, including the Chief Executive and Directors of Legal and Governance, Place and Communities, and Finance Report P27, P28
  • External speakers and partner organisations attending Scrutiny meetings Report P6

Timeline

  • 11 February 2026: Officers consulted on the proposal to merge the two Scrutiny Committees Report P26, P27
  • 25 February 2026: Full Council voted to retain the two Scrutiny Committees
  • 18 May 2026: Date the merged single committee would have been implemented, had the recommendation been approved Report P25

Plain English for the jargon

  • SLT: Senior Leadership Team of Torridge District Council
  • AGM: Annual General Meeting of the Council
  • Inquorate: Without enough members present for the meeting to be valid
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item577

Resolved

That the Council retain its two Scrutiny Committees. (Vote: For – 27, Against – 1, Abstentions – 0).
Word for word from the decision Torridge published for this meeting. Source: democracy.torridge.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Torridge's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Full Council

Purpose of report

To seek Full Council’s approval to move to a single Scrutiny Committee

1. INTRODUCTION

This report sets out the rationale and proposals for moving from the current two-committee Scrutiny structure of an Internal Overview & Scrutiny Committee and an External Overview & Scrutiny Committee to a single consolidated Overview & Scrutiny Committee. This follows ongoing concerns raised by the Senior Leadership Team (SLT) regarding operational efficiency, Member engagement, and the effectiveness of current Scrutiny arrangements.

2. REPORT

Over the past year, Senior Leadership Team and previously the Member Development Working Group have noted persistent issues affecting Member participation and meeting effectiveness. In addition to historically poor attendance at Member workshops and briefing sessions the SLT were also concerned over the course of the last year there have been several Committee meetings being unable to proceed due to being inquorate at the time the meeting was scheduled to start.

These occurrences have wider reputational consequences for the Council. Of particular concern are instances where external speakers, including representatives from partner organisations and agencies, have travelled from outside the district to attend Overview & Scrutiny meetings, only to find that the meeting cannot take place. This creates avoidable embarrassment and undermines confidence in the Council’s governance processes.

There are also practical and financial implications. Cancelled or rescheduled meetings result in additional officer time, resource expenditure, and administrative burden. They also inconvenience Members; particularly those who have taken leave from work or rearranged commitments to participate.

To mitigate these issues SLT considered the potential benefits of reducing the overall number of Member allocations to Committee seats. One viable option identified was to merge the Internal and External Scrutiny Committees into a single Scrutiny Committee. This revised structure would combine the existing functions and responsibilities of both committees into one coherent body, improving Member availability, attendance, and consistency of oversight.

Furthermore, a single Committee model would remove the current ambiguity about whether certain matters, particularly those involving financial support to external organisations, fall within internal or external scrutiny. The merger would therefore produce clearer, more transparent, and more easily understood scrutiny processes. Importantly, the proposed change would also alleviate the existing restriction where Members who sit on Scrutiny are unable to substitute on the Community & Resources Committee. With fewer Members occupied across multiple Scrutiny Committees, the pool of eligible substitutes would increase, strengthening governance resilience.

In view of these considerations, the SLT resolved to recommend to Full Council that the Internal and External Scrutiny Committees be amalgamated to form a single Overview & Scrutiny Committee.

3. IMPLICATIONS

Legal Implications Changes will require constitutional amendments to formally redefine the Scrutiny structure.

Financial Implications Potential reduction in administrative overheads due to fewer Committee meetings.

Human Resources Implications More efficient use of officer time supporting fewer Scrutiny meetings.

Sustainability/Biodiversity Implications None identified.

Equality/Diversity None identified.

Risk Management Reduced risk of inquorate meetings and reputational damage.

Compliance with Policies and Strategies The change aligns with good governance principles.

Data Protection (GDPR) Implications None identified.

Climate Change None identified.

Ward Member and Lead Member Views

This is a Council-wide report and plan so Ward member views not applicable

4. CONCLUSIONS

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Overview & Scrutiny Committee Appendix 1Appendix 112 KB Download
PDF
Overview & Scrutiny CommitteeReport 69 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

28 of 50 attended
PG
Phil GilbertOfficer, expected
SA
Councillor Shirleyann AndrewsCommittee Member, apologies
LB
Councillor Louis BachCommittee Member, present
AB
Councillor Annie BrentonCommittee Member, apologies
DB
Councillor David BrentonCommittee Member, present
CB
Councillor Chris BrightCommittee Member, present
LB
Councillor Lauren BrightCommittee Member, apologies
DB
Councillor Doug BushbyChair, present
DS
Councillor Doug SmithVice-Chair, present
CC
Councillor Cheryl Cottle-HunkinCommittee Member, present
JC
Councillor James CraigieCommittee Member, present
AD
Councillor Anna DartCommittee Member, present

All 50 on the meeting page

On this subject at Torridge

Search all
  1. Overview & Scrutiny CommitteeThis decision
  2. Annual Report for External Overview & Scrutiny Committee 2024-2025Approved
  3. Appointment of Vice-Chair on Internal Overview & Scrutiny CommitteeDecided
  4. The Devon, Cornwall and Isles of Scilly Adaptation Strategy - Recommendation from Internal Overview and Scrutiny CommitteeApproved
  5. Call in from Internal Overview & Scrutiny re The PloughApproved
  6. Annual Report - External Overview & ScrutinyAgreed

More from Torridge Full Council

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
27 Jul 2026 Council MinutesThat the minutes of the meeting held on the 22 nd June 2026 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chair.... Decided Open
27 Jul 2026 Written Notice of Motion from Councillor C LeatherThat the Notice of Motion be approved. (Vote: For – Unanimous). The Motion was carried. Approved Open
22 Jun 2026 Council MinutesThat the minutes of the meeting held on 27 th April 2026 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chair. (V... Decided Open
22 Jun 2026 Agreement of Agenda Items Part I and IIThat the agenda as circulated be agreed. (Vote: For, Unanimous) Agreed Open
22 Jun 2026 Northam Neighbourhood PlanThat Full Council: 1. Accept the recommendations of the Examiner in relation to the Northam Neighbourhood Plan, as se... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies