Item17
Resolved
DECISION NOTICE OF CODE OF CONDUCT HEARING PANEL 15 April 2015 Complaint No: T003595 (1) On 15 April 2015, the Code of Conduct Sub-Committee of Tunbridge Wells Borough Council considered a report of an investigation into the alleged conduct of Town Councillor Moon, a member of Paddock Wood Town Council. Complaint Summary (2) On 10 January 2014 [name removed], the Monitoring Officer of Tunbridge Wells Borough Council at that time, commissioned an investigation into allegations made by Councillor Sarah Hamilton against Councillor Raymond Moon (both of Paddock Wood Town Council). A general summary of the allegations within the complaint is set out below: (a) Allegation A - That Councillor Moon did not recognise or respect the integrity of a fellow Paddock Wood Town Councillor in a meeting on 15 July 2013 when suggesting that a fellow councillor (Councillor Mrs Thomas) had a conflict of interest regarding a motion under discussion. (b) Allegation B - That Councillor Moon was disrespectful to Councillor Hamilton when she was chairing a meeting, when he replied “Don’t interrupt me”. (c) Allegation C - That Councillor Moon was intimidating to Councillor Hamilton when, prior to a planning committee meeting, he alluded to an issue that was previously discussed at the confidential mediation process in May 2013. (d) Allegation D - That Councillor Moon’s method of raising a concern over the placing of a TPO on Putlands Field (as detailed in a review conducted by the Chair of Speldhurst Parish Council, dated 11 September, 2013) was potentially disrespectful to other councillors. Consultation with the Independent Person (1) The Monitoring Officer, in consultation with the Independent Person, decided to refer the allegations for formal investigation. (2) After hearing the evidence at the meeting, the Independent Person advised that he supported the Investigating Officer’s findings that, with regard to allegation (C), Councillor Moon had failed to comply with paragraph 1 of the Paddock Wood Town Council’s Code of Conduct, as set out in the Investigator’s report. Findings After considering the submission of the Investigating Officer and the views of the Independent Person, the Hearing Panel reached the following decisions: Allegation A . - That Councillor Moon did not recognise or respect the integrity of a fellow Paddock Wood Town Councillor in a meeting on 15 July 2013 when suggesting that a fellow councillor (Councillor Mrs Thomas) had a conflict of interest regarding a motion under discussion. . . Finding of facts: (i) The Hearing Panel took into account that there appeared to be no disputing that Councillor Thomas simply allowed another councillor to second the motion instead. In addition it was noted that Councillor Thomas’s withdrawal from seconding the motion had no material effect on council business as the motion was subsequently seconded by another and carried. (ii) The Hearing Panel noted that no formal complaint had been submitted by Councillor Thomas relating to the incident. (iii) The Hearing Panel concluded that there was no evidence that this incident was anything other than a legitimate question being raised ... view the full minutes text for item 17.
Word for word from the decision Tunbridge Wells published for this meeting.
Source: democracy.tunbridgewells.gov.uk