It was agreed that an example should be included within the constitution of how and when apologies should be given, and that on agendas, the exact deadline for giving apologies to enable a substitute to be arranged, would be stated. 8.5 The Panel also considered the timing of site visits and suggested that these take place 1 clear working day before a meeting (i.e. the Monday if the meeting was on a Wednesday) which would allow the Members, including any substitutes, to have read the agenda report and enough time for officers to look into any matters raised during the visit. 8.6 During discussion, Members expressed their frustrations with Joint Planning Committee meetings being rearranged or cancelled at short notice. They expressed a preference for them to take place on a regular evening, preferably, on a Wednesday, as this had become the evening that was always generally used for all planning meetings. Members were advised that there had recently been a high ... view the full minutes text for item 8.
Word for word from the decision Waverley published for this meeting.Source: modgov.waverley.gov.uk
There are no financial implications arising from this report.
Legal implications
The legal advice is set out in the body of this report.
Background 1. At the last meeting of the Standards Panel on 6 June 2017, which considered a review of the Scheme of Delegation and revisions to the constitution, it was requested that further work be undertaken on the following areas:-
i. the deadlines for giving apologies for meetings and calling substitutes ii. the application of political proportionality rules for committee members and substitutes at quasi-judicial meetings; and iii. the formatting/numbering of substitution rules in the Constitution.
These will be addressed in turn within this report. Apologies for Absence and Deadlines for calling Substitutes
2. Members are required to notify the Democratic Services team with apologies for absence when they are unable to attend a meeting, giving as much notice as possible. For those meetings which operate a substitute scheme, the section regarding substitutions in the Council’s Constitution currently states
“PR4.4 (a) The member unable to attend a Committee or Sub-Committee meeting will submit their apologies to the Head of Policy and Governance by noon at the latest on the day of the meeting and ask that a substitute be appointed”.
3. With regard to quasi-judicial meetings in particular, concerns have been expressed about the amount of time available to a substitute to read and understand the agenda papers before the meeting if they can be called as late at noon on the day of the meeting. This is particularly relevant when there are lengthy and complicated reports setting out a major planning application or consideration of a review of a licensed taxi-driver, for example.
4. Whilst it is possible that late apologies can be given because of illness or urgent matters that arise, the Standards Panel’s view is sought on a reasonable deadline for calling a substitute to a meeting once apologies have been given.
5. There are some proposed amendments to the section in the Constitution regarding substitutions later in this report, and so it is suggested that any amendments to the procedure will be further reflected in the changes.
The Application of Proportionality Rules and Substitutions
6. At the last meeting, the Panel asked officers to investigate whether it was appropriate for quasi-judicial meetings to be appointed on the basis of political proportionality given that they were taking apolitical decisions, and whether subsequently substitutes also had to be called on a political basis when apologies were given.
7. The Constitution currently states that
“PR 4.2 For each Committee, the Council will appoint the agreed number of substitutes in respect of each political group in proportion to the number of ordinary seats as that group holds on that Committee, Sub- Committee or Panel”.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Proposed Joint Executive CommitteeRESOLVED that 1. The recommendation to Council to establish a new Joint Executive Committee be noted, 2. The Monitori...
Proposed Joint Standards CommitteeRESOLVED that the recommendation to Council as follows; be supported: 1. Approve the Joint Standards Committee terms ...
Executive Working Group ProtocolRESOLVED that the recommendations to Council as follows; be supported: 1. Approve the at Guildford Borough Council, a...
Social Media Policy for CouncillorsRESOLVED that the recommendations to Council as follows; be supported: 1. The Social Media Policy, as set out at Appe...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.