(1) That the Council be recommended to agree that urgent repairs are required to the tower at Campus West and to agree a budget of £60,000 in this financial year 2016/17 to cover the estimated cost of the repairs required to the building. (2) That initially the cost be funded from the Emergency Reserve using the urgent incident procedure.
Word for word from the decision Welwyn Hatfield published for this meeting.Source: democracy.welhat.gov.uk
1.1In August this year, a large piece of concrete separated and then fell from the around a window on the fourth floor of the Campus West Tower. This highlighted there could be a problem with the window reveals and other isolated areas on the tower.
1.2Officers immediately fenced off the area and scaffolding was erected to allow for the tower to be inspected. Ashton Consulting were instructed to carry out that inspection and to produce a report to ascertain if the incident was likely to be a one-off or if there was a more widespread risk.
1.3This report advised that the risk did affect more of the building and also recommended that testing should be carried out for chlorides in the concrete.
1.4The purpose of this report is now to advise Members that urgent repairs are required to the tower to restore the external finishes to a safe state. Because these works are repairs, the cost cannot be treated as a capital expenditure and so the estimated requirement is for a one off revenue budget of £60,000 including fees
2 Recommendation(s)
2.1That Cabinet recommend to Council that it agrees that the urgent repairs outlined in this report are required and recommends to Council to agree a budget of £60,000 in this financial year 2016-17 to cover the estimated cost of the repairs required to the building.
2.2That initially the cost is funded from the Emergency reserve using the Urgent Incident Procedure.
3 Explanation
3.1During the refurbishment of the library by Hertfordshire County Council about 4 years ago, they encountered a problem with the finishes to a number of the window reveals where facing bricks (brick slips) were separating from the window lintels. This was happening because moisture had been able to penetrate the concrete behind the slips which had led to surface “spalling”.
3.2Spalling is the process where water penetrates a building material. This then may freeze due to the time of year. Ice occupies a larger volume than water which has the effect of pushing the material’s surface away allowing sections to fall. This regularly affects bricks at the foot of walls but can affect any hard material where moisture penetration can or has occurred. 3.3 The tower is subject to high temperature fluctuations and wind all of which, it now appears, has, over time, allowed moisture to penetrate the construction material. This has led to spalling occurring.
3.4Areas of the finishes to the tower have now shown signs of deterioration culminating in a section separating and falling.
3.5It is now essential that repairs are carried out to make the tower safer.
3.6These works are for remediation purposes only. They will not enhance the building nor extend its life.
Implications
4 Legal Implication(s)
4.1The forecourt area beneath the tower forms part of the fire and other evacuation routes for the Campus West complex. This route has to be as safe as reasonably possible. Now the Council is aware that this issue exists, it cannot not take action.
5 Financial Implication(s)
5.1The Council does have responsive and planned maintenance budgets but these budgets are already under significant pressure and cannot carry an additional level of expenditure of this nature.
5.2The Council is still incurring on-going costs for the scaffold hire. This was originally sourced through the minor works contract as the quickest way to ensure the area around the building was protected.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Declarations of interests by membersCouncillor Quinton declared an interest in agenda item 7b, Business Improvement District Welwyn Garden City and recus...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.