Decision The Tree Preservation Order Consent for the felling of the T1 Oak Tree be REFUSED , CONTRARY TO THE OFFICER RECOMMENDATION OF APPROVAL, due to the high amenity value the tree provided. And, Councillor Neal also proposed that the Tree Preservation Order Consent for the felling of the T8 Scots Pine be refused, as per the Officer recommendation, This was duly seconded by Councillor Andy Drummond. Upon being put to the vote and with the vote being unanimous, it was resolved that Decision The ... view the full minutes text for item 24.
Word for word from the decision West Suffolk published for this meeting.Source: democracy.westsuffolk.gov.uk
Development Control Committee 7 August 2019 Planning Application DC/19/0759/TPO – 3 Forest Way, Mildenhall
Date 08.04.2019 Expiry Date: 03.06.2019 Registered:
Case [name removed]: Split Decision Officer:
Parish: Mildenhall Ward: Mildenhall Kingsway and Market Proposal: TPO/2007/02 - TPO/1996/06 - Tree Preservation Orders - (i) T1 - 1no. Oak - Fell (ii) T8 - 1no Scots Pine - Fell
Site: 3 Forest Way, Mildenhall
Applicant: [name removed]: Application under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 and the (Listed Building and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 and Associated matters.
Recommendation: The formal decision as to whether the application will be determined at Development Control Committee or by delegated authority will be made by the Assistant Director (Planning and Regulatory Services). However, it is recommended that the Delegation Panel advise the Assistant Director (Planning and Regulatory Services) of their opinion as to whether this application should be referred to the Development Control Committee for determination or whether it should otherwise be determined using delegated powers.
CONTACT CASE OFFICER: Nicolas Yager Email: [email protected] Telephone: 01284 757629 Background:
This application is referred to the Development Control Committee following consideration by the Delegation Panel.
The Officer’s recommendation is to grant consent for the felling of the T1 – 1no. Oak and to refuse consent for the felling of the T8 – 1no. Scots Pine.
Negotiation sought to secure changes to the proposal, so that limb reduction works took place instead to the Scots Pine. However, the applicant did not agree to the suggested proposal change from Officers therefore making the recommendation a ‘split decision’.
It was referred to the Delegation Panel as the Town Council and Ward Member (Mildenhall Kingsway & Market) both object to the felling of the trees, therefore, contrasting with the Officer’s recommendation to fell T1 – 1no. Oak Tree.
A site visit is proposed for Monday 5 August 2019.
Proposal:
1. TPO consent is sought to fell 1no. Oak and to fell the T8 – 1no. Scots Pine.
2. However, the officer’s recommendation is for a split decision to fell the T1 – 1no. Oak and to refuse the felling of the T8 – 1no. Scots Pine, for reasons that are set out and discussed below. The recommendation includes conditions to secure the replacement planting of the Oak with a Lime tree.
Application Supporting Material:
- Application Form - Tree Location Plan - T1 Tree Location Plan - T8 Tree Location Plan - Tree Inspection Report - Photographs - Arboricultural officer annotated photographs 001
Site Details:
3. The application site comprises of a detached bungalow located along 3 Forest Way, Mildenhall. The Scots Pine is located to the west side of the dwelling which is therefore visible from Thetford Road and Forest Way. The Oak tree is located in the north east corner of the site and again can be seen from both Thetford Road and Forest Way. The property is adjacent to the tree preservation orders 02(2007) and 06(1996).
Planning History:
Reference Proposal Status Decision Date DC/19/0759/TPO TPO/2007/02 - Pending TPO/1996/06 - Tree Decision Preservation Orders - (i) T1 - 1no. Oak - Fell (ii) T8 - 1no Scots Pine - Fell F/2008/0561/TPO Reduce oak tree by two Refuse 18.09.2008 thirds F/2009/0332/TPO Crown reduction of 3m to 1 Approve with 02.11.2009 Oak tree (as amended Conditions 28/10/2009). F/2007/0787/FUL Part demolish end of Approve with 16.11.2007 existing bungalow, erection Conditions of side and front extensions (to North, South and East elevations) F/2010/0088/TPO Fell 1 x Silver Birch (as Approve with 01.04.2010 amended by email received Conditions 02/03/2010) F/2003/0353/TPO Lift the canopy of 1 Oak Application 30.06.2003 tree and 1 Pine tree - TPO Approved 6/96
Consultations:
4. The arboricultural officer recommended the felling of the Oak tree and the refusal of the felling of the Scots Pine ( for reasons set out below).
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.