CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
West Suffolk Council
Development Control Committee, Wednesday 4 November 2020 at 10.00am

Planning Application DC/20/1003/FUL - Abbots Hall, Smallwood Green, Bradfield St George (Report No: DEV/WS/20/051)

Refused Planning 3 papers

Development Control Committee refused this item on Wednesday 4 November 2020. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item73

Resolved

Decision Making Protocol would not be invoked in this instance; meaning that the motion would not be ‘minded to’. The Planning Officer then verbally outlined the conditions that could be appended to a permission. Upon being put to the vote and with 7 voting for the motion and 8 against, the Chair declared the motion lost. Councillor Ian Houlder then moved that the application be refused, as per the Officer recommendation, and this was duly seconded by Councillor Roger Dicker. Upon being put to the vote and with 8 voting for the motion, 6 against and with 1 abstention it was resolved that Decision Planning permission be REFUSED for the following reason: The pattern of development in the area is of relatively isolated and sporadic dwellings in the countryside. The existing property on the site is of a simple design and of a modest scale and is not considered to be of any particular historic or architectural merit. Given that the proposed dwelling is of a significantly and materially larger scale and form, it will appear dominant and visually prominent within the open, rural street scene. In particular, the combined scale, height and massing of the building would have an urbanising effect on the rural location, to the detriment of the character and appearance of the area. Overall The proposed dwelling is judged to be in material conflict with policy CS4 of the Core Strategy Document, policies DM1, DM2 and DM5 of the Joint Development Management Policies Document, and the advice contained within the National Planning Policy Framework which seeks to ensure that new development is sensitive to the defining characteristics of the local area.
Word for word from the decision West Suffolk published for this meeting. Source: democracy.westsuffolk.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from West Suffolk's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Development Control Committee

DEV/WS/20/051

Development Control Committee 4 November 2020 Planning Application DC/20/1003/FUL – Abbots Hall, Smallwood Green, Bradfield St George

Date 3 July 2020 Expiry date: 28 August 2020 registered:

Case Alice Maguire Recommendation: Refuse application officer:

Parish: Bradfield St. George Ward: Rougham

Proposal: Planning Application - 1no. dwelling (following demolition of existing dwelling)

Site: Abbots Hall, Smallwood Green, Bradfield St George

Applicant: Mr & [name removed]: Application under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 and the (Listed Building and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 and associated matters.

Recommendation: It is recommended that the Development Control Committee determine the attached application and associated matters. CASE OFFICER: Alice Maguire Email: [email protected] Telephone: [phone removed] Background:

This application is presented to the Development Control Committee following consideration at Delegation Panel on 22/09/2020. It was presented to the Delegation Panel due to the support from the Parish Council. The application is recommended for REFUSAL.

Proposal:

1. Planning permission is sought for 1 dwelling. The proposed dwelling is two storey in height, and would have 3no. bedrooms. It would measure approximately 4.200 metres to the eaves, 7.800 metres to the ridge, with an overall depth of 15.300 metres, and an overall width of 11.100 metres at its widest point.

2. The proposed dwelling would be a replacement of the existing dwelling on the site. It does not extend the residential curtilage. It does not propose a new access and would utilise the existing access.

3. The external footprint of the existing dwelling measures 80.86 square metres and the proposed external footprint measures 130.70 square metres (representing a 49.84 square metre increase). The ridge height of the existing dwelling measures 5.41 metres, and the ridge height of the proposed dwelling measures 7.83 metres; an increase of 2.42 metres.

4. Amended plans were provided by the agent on 26/08/2020 showing an amended block plan and elevations. The amended plans substitute the original drawing submitted on 03/07/2020. They were amended to show the omission of the detached cart lodge, following concerns raised by officers. The amended submitted elevation drawings also show an orange line, whereby the agent has indicated what they could achieve through permitted development.

Application supporting material: 5. - Location Plan - Proposed location plan - Covering Letter - Application Form - Existing block plan - Proposed block plan - Planning, Design and Access Statement - Biodiversity survey Phase 1 - Biodiversity survey Phase 2 - Tree Categorisation Report - Front Perspectives - Rear Perspectives - Land contamination assessment - Land contamination questionnaire - Ground floor plans - First floor plans - Roof plan - Proposed elevations (east and west) - Proposed elevations (north and south). Site details:

6. The application site is outside of any settlement boundary, and in policy terms is therefore within designated countryside. It is within the parish of Bradfield St George, and the settlement boundary is approximately 2.40km to the north-west. The site is relatively isolated in nature, with no residential dwellings within close proximity. There are some other buildings adjacent to the plot, however these are in agricultural use. The site is to the east of Smallwood Green, where there is an existing access from the highway serving the site.

Planning history:

7. There is no relevant planning history on the application site.

Representations:

Parish Council:

17.07.2020 –

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
DEV.WS.20.051 Abbots Hall, Smallwood Green, Bradfield St George: Location PlanPlan 41 KB Download
PDF
DEV.WS.20.051 Abbots Hall, Smallwood Green, Bradfield St George: Site PlanPlan 1.1 MB Download
PDF
Planning Application DC/20/1003/FUL: Abbots Hall, Smallwood Green, Bradfield St George (Report No: DEV/WS/20/051)Report 307 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

16 of 19 attended
JB
Councillor John BurnsCommittee Member, apologies
JC
Councillor Jason CrooksCommittee Member, present
M(
Councillor Mike (Michael) ChesterVice-Chair, present
RD
Councillor Roger DickerCommittee Member, present
A(
Councillor Andy (Andrew) DrummondCommittee Member, present
SG
Councillor Susan GlossopCommittee Member, present
IH
Councillor Ian HoulderCommittee Member, present
DP
Councillor David PalmerCommittee Member, apologies, sent representative
DR
Councillor David RoachCommittee Member, present
DS
Councillor David SmithCommittee Member, present
PS
Councillor Peter StevensCommittee Member, present
AS
Councillor Andrew SmithChair, present

All 19 on the meeting page

On this subject at West Suffolk

Search all
  1. Planning Application DC/20/1003/FUL - Abbots Hall, Smallwood Green, Bradfield St George (Report No: DEV/WS/20/051)This decision
  2. Planning Application DC/26/0963/FUL - 9 Short Brackland, Bury St Edmunds (Report No: DEV/WS/26/026)Approved
  3. Planning Application DC/26/0283/FUL -Development Site, Stoke Road, Clare (Report No: DEV/WS/26/022)Approved
  4. Planning Application DC/26/0487/VAR - West Suffolk Operational Hub, Bury Road, Fornham St Martin (Report No: DEV/WS/26/023)Approved
  5. Planning Application DC/26/0228/ADV -14 Prospect Row, Bury St Edmunds (Report No: DEV/WS/26/019)Refused
  6. Planning Application DC/25/2028/FUL - West Suffolk Council Depot, Olding Road, Bury St Edmunds (Report No DEV/WS/26/013)Approved

More from West Suffolk Development Control Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
5 Aug 2026 Planning Application DC/26/0963/FUL - 9 Short Brackland, Bury St Edmunds (Report No: DEV/WS/26/026)Decision Planning permission be GRANTED subject to the following conditions: 1. Time Limit The development hereby per... Approved Open
1 Jul 2026 Planning Application DC/26/0283/FUL -Development Site, Stoke Road, Clare (Report No: DEV/WS/26/022)Decision Planning permission be GRANTED subject to the following conditions: Time limit The development hereby permit... Approved Open
1 Jul 2026 Planning Application DC/26/0487/VAR - West Suffolk Operational Hub, Bury Road, Fornham St Martin (Report No: DEV/WS/26/023)Decision Planning permission be GRANTED subject to the following conditions: 1. The development hereby permitted shal... Approved Open
3 Jun 2026 Election of Chair 2026/2027That Councillor Andrew Smith be elected Chair for 2026/2027. Councillor Smith then took the Chair for the remainder o... Decided Open
3 Jun 2026 Election of Vice Chair(s) 2026/2027That Councillor Jon London be elected Vice Chair for 2026/2027. Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies