Resolved
Decision Making Protocol was invoked, requiring a Risk Assessment to be prepared which was contained within Report No DEV/WS/24/035 for the Committee’s consideration. The reasons given by Members for granting approval, contrary to the recommendation, were the enhancement the proposed development would make to the amenity of the area and the environment, together with the weight to be attributed to the fallback position offered by an extant Class Q permission on the existing buildings. Officers continued to recommend that the application be refused, for the reason set out in Paragraph 17 of the report. However, if Members remained minded to approve the application conditions to be appended to a permission were listed in Paragraph 16. Speakers: Councillor Mike Chester (Ward Member: Chedburgh and Chevington) spoke on the application. Oliver Neil (applicant) spoke in support of the application. (On conclusion of the public speaking Councillor Mike Chester left the meeting during the Committee’s further consideration of this item, at the same point Councillor Phil Wittam joined the meeting and the Lawyer advised Councillor Wittam that he would be unable to take part in the discussion and voting on this item as he had not been privy to the presentation .) Councillor Don Waldron opened the debate and proposed that the application be approved, contrary to the Officer recommendation, for the reasons cited by the Committee at the September meeting. This was duly seconded by Councillor Ian Houlder. Councillor Jon London spoke on the benefits of the proposed scheme above a Class Q permission, as the application would result in a more sustainable construction and he suggested that this be added to the reasons for approval. The Service Manager (Planning – Development) explained that if this was to be added as a reason for approval a related additional condition would also need to be added in order to request sustainability credentials of the proposed development from the applicant. The Chair sought clarification from the proposer and seconder that they were content to add the additional reason and related condition, as proposed, and Councillor Waldron and Houlder confirmed agreement. However, as ... view the full minutes text for item 491.