Item32
Resolved
The Cabinet agrees to defer consideration of this motion until the outcome of the Village Green application for Ashfield Playing Fields has been determined and that the Council be informed accordingly. (b) In accordance with motions 5 and 7, the Council acknowledged that 20.2 of the Constitution allowed for motions to be deferred to Cabinet for consideration of proposed amendments to the constitution prior to resubmission to Council on 7 November 2012. Motion 5 submitted by Councillor Gareth Fairhurst and seconded by Councillor George Fairhurst : “This Council now recognises that in the open and transparency world that we live in and in the interest of a true record of the full Council meetings this council now supports that we video the proceedings and posting the video recordings on Wigan Council web site.” Motion 7 submitted by Councillor Carmichael and seconded by Councillor Gareth Fairhurst : “This Council recognises the excellent work of council officers in producing minutes of meetings that often take place at unsociable hours. Actively discouraged from taking verbatim notes, officers must rely on speed written notes to capture the essence of the debate and decisions taken. Commendably, errors are rare. However, when one occurs, the process of challenge is unreliable, as resolution often relies on attendees at meetings having to remember what was said several weeks earlier. To assist council officers in their duties and to provide an accurate and verbatim record that can be used to resolve reported anomalies, council agrees that all future Council, Cabinet and Scrutiny meetings be electronically recorded.” The Cabinet agrees:- (1) that in relation to motion 5, the Council be advised that the Cabinet does not support the videoing of proceedings and posting of video recordings on the Wigan Council web site and therefore no changes to the constitution are necessary; (2) that in relation to motion 7, the Council be advised, that in view of the motion being taken as an amendment at minute 23(a) of the Council meeting, which was then lost, the Cabinet agrees that no action be taken in relation to meetings being electronically recorded and therefore no changes to the constitution are necessary. The Cabinet agrees to defer consideration of this motion until the outcome of the Village Green application for Ashfield Playing Fields has been determined and that the Council be informed accordingly. The Council confirmed that as the sale of land is an Executive Decision, there was no further debate on this motion and therefore this motion was lost. In response to motion 5 submitted by Councillor G W Fairhurst and seconded by Councillor G A Fairhurst as set out below:- “This Council now recognise that in the open and transparent world that we live in and in the interest of a true record of the full Council meetings this council now supports that we video the proceedings and post the video recordings on Wigan Council web site. In accordance with Rule 20.2 of the Constitution, this motion was deferred without discussion to the next ordinary meeting of the Council after having been considered by Cabinet, to consider the proposed amendment to the constitution.” The decision of Cabinet had been:- The Council be advised that the Cabinet does not support the videoing of proceedings and posting of video recordings on the Wigan Council web site and therefore no changes to the constitution are necessary; In response to motion 7 submitted by Councillor Carmichael and seconded by Councillor G W Fairhurst as set out below:- “This Council recognises the excellent work of council officers in producing minutes of meetings that often take place at unsociable hours. Actively discouraged from taking verbatim notes, officers must rely on speed written notes to capture the essence of the debate and decisions taken. Commendably, errors are rare. However, when one occurs, the process of challenge is unreliable, as resolution often relies on attendees at meetings having to remember what was said several weeks earlier. To assist council officers in their duties and to provide an accurate and verbatim record that can be used to resolve reported anomalies, council agrees that all future Council, Cabinet and Scrutiny meetings be electronically recorded. In accordance with Rule 20.2 of the Constitution, this motion was deferred without discussion to the next ordinary meeting of the Council after having been considered by Cabinet, to consider the proposed amendment to the constitution.” ... view the full minutes text for item 32.
Word for word from the decision Wigan published for this meeting.
Source: democracy.wigan.gov.uk