Agreed: The Panel requests that: (1) A working group is set up to look at the recommendations in the report and feedback to a future meeting of this Panel so that the report can be accepted and recommendations be included in policies where possible; (2) The allocations flowchart be subjected to a critical path analysis and then brought back to a future meeting of this Panel; and (3) Any future scrutiny exercises ensure that the Tenant Panel Members receive administrative support from Officers.
Word for word from the decision Wigan published for this meeting.Source: democracy.wigan.gov.uk
This scrutiny report has been produced by the tenant members of Wigan Council Housing Advisory Panel (HAP). The scrutiny sub group is convened to ensure that the housing services provided by Wigan Council are operating to a high standard, provides an excellent service to tenants, offers value for money and meets the ‘lettable standard’ for Wigan Council as well as national standards.
This report is solely concerned with the 'Keys in to Keys out' process. It examines what happens to a 'void' property from when the keys are delivered to the Council from the previous tenant; through the inspection of the property, the repair process and the allocations procedure.
The scrutiny exercise took place between November 2018 and the final report being presented to the HAP meeting in April 2019. It involved examination of documents and reports, interviews with Wigan Council staff and contractors and surveys carried out with tenants.
SCOPE OF THE SCRUTINY
The report focuses on the ‘keys in to keys out’ process. It does not examine the allocations policy, though it does look at the allocations procedure and how it impacts on the voids process. The scoping document can be found in Appendix 1.
SCRUTINY PROCESS
We were able to examine a number of documents produced by the Council as well as reports produced specifically for the exercise. Several of the documents examined are attached as appendices to this report:
* The Wigan Borough Lettable standards document. (appx 2) * Hand over document for Voids property. (appx 5) * Void property pre-inspection template. (appx 6) * Void property pre-inspection check list. * Allocation team check list. * Allocations team flow chart. (appx 7) * Allocations team 'Notice' flow chart. (appx 8) * Final internal audit report (2016/17) for management of voids. * Voids process map (flow chart) for repairs (seven pages). (appx 3) * Voids – simplified ‘to be’ process flow chart (four pages). (appx 4) * Void Property Benchmarking document. Examining these documents enabled the group to gain a good understanding of what the lettable standard is, what the tenant’s offer is and how long the process of ‘keys in to keys out’ takes. The panel were also able to compare Wigan Council’s performance against the Council’s own standards and against other similar organisations.
It is clear that there is a significant increase in the length of time properties are left void. This fact became the focus of the scrutiny and underpinned much of the questioning that took place during the interviews with staff and contractors.
We also carried out a survey of some tenants who had recently taken out a tenancy to find out their experience of the pre-tenancy process.
FINDINGS
Inspections and repairs
While there is a lettable standards document (Appendix 2) there does seem to be a problem around the inspection process that takes place to determine if the property is ready to let.
During interviews it has become clear that the inspection process is not working well at the moment. There are not enough inspectors and, it seems, that those that are in post are not in a position to carry out a whole property inspection in a timely manner. While it is obvious that gas/electrical inspections are specialised and require a separate inspection it is also clear that a recently introduced asbestos inspection has created an additional pinch point in the process. This is leading to a significant increase in the length of time being taken to bring the property to a lettable state.
From what we understand, one (asbestos inspecting) contractor has been stopping all access to the property until the asbestos inspection has taken place. However, now a new contractor has been appointed who will only restrict access to specific areas that have been identified as containing, or likely to contain, asbestos.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.