What was decided
Cabinet approved capital spending of up to £480,000 for professional fees, site surveys and investigation work, funded from the unallocated new homes capital budget, and noted this carries a financial risk to the council. Report P1, 2.4
The Corporate Head of Asset Management, in consultation with the Cabinet Member for Good Homes, was authorised to prepare and submit a planning application, enter any required planning or legal agreements, and invite tenders for a design and build contract. Report P2, P3, P4
A Final Business Case, including valuation and appropriation of the site from the General Fund to the Housing Revenue Account, will come back to Cabinet after tenders are evaluated, alongside progress reports to the Cabinet Committee: Housing. Report P5, P6
Why
The site is allocated in the Adopted Local Plan 2020-2040 for 30 dwellings under Policy W3, and the proposal aims to exceed that number to meet high demand for affordable homes in the district. Report 11.6, 11.11, 1.9
Officers cited a 2026 Hampshire Home Choice figure of 1,698 households on the housing register, including 1,117 needing a one bed home, and pointed to the council's target of 1,000 new affordable homes by 2032. Report P78, P79, P80, P81, P82, P83, 1.9
The scheme is expected to align with the Council Plan 2025 to 2030 and the Housing Development Strategy 2025 to 2032, supporting carbon neutrality, sustainable travel and regeneration of a brownfield city centre site. Report 1.1, 1.3, 1.5, 1.7, 1.9
What happens next
A planning application will be prepared and submitted for a scheme currently sized at 40 one and two bed flats and 4 three bed houses, subject to further surveys and feasibility work. Report P2, 2.1, 11.9, 11.10
If planning is granted, the project will be tendered using a JCT Design and Build contract, with a Final Business Case returning to Cabinet once the tender price is known. Report 3.8, 2.5, 11.18, 11.19
Local residents and businesses will be consulted before the planning application is submitted, in addition to the statutory planning consultation. Report 6.2, 1.13
The money
- £480,000 Estimated fees for site surveys, investigations and professional work to support a planning application, funded from the unallocated new homes capital budget. Report 2.4
- approximately £395,000 Gross income from the car park in 2025/26 in parking and enforcement revenue. Report 2.6
- £33,000 Business rates paid on the site in 2025/26, which would be saved if the car park closes. Report 2.6
- in the region of £8m Likely level of council subsidy in the form of S106 affordable housing commuted sum, if grant funding is secured and the scheme is viable. Report 2.8
Options considered
- Rejected: Other options considered. The report states that no other options were considered. Report P94, P95
Implications
- Financial: If planning is refused or the scheme is not viable, the £480,000 of fees would be abortive and expensed to the Housing Revenue Account. Report 2.4
- Financial: Appropriating the site from the General Fund to the Housing Revenue Account would increase the HRA's Capital Financing Requirement and reduce the General Fund's annual Minimum Revenue Provision charge and interest costs. Report 2.6
- Legal: The site will be appropriated from the General Fund to the Housing Revenue Account under Section 122(1) of the Local Government Act 1972 and Section 19(1) of the Housing Act 1985 before construction starts. Report 3.1, 5.1
- Risk: Key risks include loss of car park income, brownfield ground conditions, potential loss of grant funding, community opposition, higher build or interest costs, and project delay, with mitigations set out in the risk register. Report P61, P62, P63, P64, P66
- Equalities: The Housing Strategy 2023-2028 and Housing Development Strategy 2025-2032 have been subject to an Equality Impact Assessment, and equality matters will be considered throughout design, procurement and tendering. Report 8.1, 8.2
- Climate: Designs will target the council's carbon neutrality commitment, use low carbon heating, achieve biodiversity net gain, address the adjacent Air Quality Management Area, and incorporate sustainable urban drainage for the site's high groundwater levels. Report 7.1, 7.2, 7.3, 7.5
- Staffing: The project will need input from Finance, Procurement, Planning, Housing, Estates and Legal teams, with external professionals used where council resources are limited. Report 4.1, P66
Who and where
- Households on the Hampshire Home Choice housing register, totalling 1,698 in the April 2026 annual report. Report P82, P83
- Users of St Peter's Car Park, which currently provides 165 spaces, and nearby residents on North Walls and St Bede's Primary School. Report 11.2, 11.3
- Owners of dwellings along North Walls whose rear gardens are accessed through the site, and Winchester School of Art, which has an access route into the car park. Report 3.2
- Users of the St Swithun's Way long distance footpath, which crosses the site and must remain open and accessible during construction. Report 3.4, 1.7
Timeline
- June 2026: Architecture PLB were commissioned to refresh capacity studies for the site. Report 11.9
- 2025/26: The car park produced a gross income of approximately £395,000 and incurred business rates of £33,000. Report 2.6
- 2026-08-25: Winchester City Council Cabinet considered this report and approved the recommendations.
- by 2032: Council target of delivering 1,000 new affordable homes. Report 1.9
- after tenders are evaluated: A Final Business Case will return to Cabinet, including valuation and appropriation of the site, to decide whether to proceed and award a design and build contract. Report P5, 2.5, 11.19
Plain English for the jargon
- HRA (Housing Revenue Account): A ringfenced account councils use for income and spending on their own housing stock.
- General Fund: The main council account for non housing services, funded largely by council tax, business rates and government grants.
- Appropriation: The formal transfer of a council owned site from one account or use to another, here from the General Fund to the Housing Revenue Account.
- JCT Design and Build: A standard construction contract where a single contractor takes on both the design and the building of the scheme.
- BLRF (Brownfield Land Release Fund): Central government grant funding intended to support the development of affordable homes on previously developed land.
- S106 commuted sum: A payment made under a Section 106 planning agreement, here used as a council subsidy towards the affordable housing scheme.