Resolved (12:0) – That the application be refused on the grounds that: The proposed development will be more than half the width of the side garden between the original property and the adjacent highway, which the Local Planning Authority considers to be detrimental to the general character of the street scene due to its prominent corner location. This is contrary to Unitary Development Plan Policy HS.11 and SPG.11 - House Extensions.
Word for word from the decision Wirral published for this meeting.Source: democracy.wirral.gov.uk
Planning Committee 19 July 2011 Reference: Area Team: Case Officer: Ward: APP/11/00495 South Team [name removed]: 133 DIBBINS HEY, SPITAL, CH63 9HE Proposal: Proposed garage, lounge and porch extension
Planning History: APP/10/01157 - Erection of front and side extensions Refused 25/11/10 - Subsequent Appeal also dismissed 31/3/11
Summary Of Representations and Consultations Received:
REPRESENTATIONS Having regards to the Council's Guidance on Publicity for Applications, 4 adjoining residential properties have been notified and a Site Notice was displayed. No representations have been received
CONSUTLATIONS Director of Technical Services (Traffic Management & Highway Maintenance) - No objections
Director's Comments: The application was deferred from Committee on the 21 June 2011 to allow for a Committee Site Visit.
REASON FOR REFERRAL Councillor Cherry Povall asked for this application to be taken out of delegation on the grounds that it will not be detrimental to the character of the surrounding area and it is therefore a proposal in accordance with UPD Policy HS 11
INTRODUCTION The application is for the erection of single storey extensions to the front and side. The front extension projects 2.4 metres and includes the conversion of the existing garage to create additional living accommodation, the side extension would be 3.8 metres wide and would provide a new garage.
This is a revised application following the refusal of a similar proposal in November last year. The width of the side extension has been reduced by 1 metre to overcome the reason for refusal.
PRINCIPLE OF DEVELOPMENT The site is located in an area designated as primarily residential where the erection of extensions to dwellings is acceptable in principle.
SITE AND SURROUNDINGS The property is an end house in a row of 3 similar houses built on a staggered building line, however, due to the various extensions that have been carried out, their original design/character has been lost. The house is built on a corner plot at the junction of Dibbins Hey and Morello Drive. The front garden is open plan and the side/rear garden, facing into Morello Drive, is enclosed by 1.8 metre high fencing.
POLICY CONTEXT Policy HS.11 and Supplementary Planning Guidelines: House Extensions have been taken into consideration in the determination of this application.
APPEARANCE AND AMENITY ISSUES To preserve the openness around corner plots and to protect the character of the street scene the house extension policy requires extensions to be no more than half the width of the garden between the house and the adjacent highway. The side garden is currently enclosed by fencing and some greenery presenting a pleasant, open feel at the entrance to Morello Drive.
The revised application is for an extension that is set in from the Morello Drive boundary by 1 metre, all other elements of the previous application have been repeated. The extension would still occupy 3.8 metres of the available 4.8 metre wide side garden and therefore would still conflict with current house extension policies/guidelines.
The development creates a dominant feature in this prominent corner location. The impact of the side extension is exacerbated by the forward projection of the extension towards Dibbins Hey and the high gable feature above the garage doors.
The applicant appealed against the previous decision and The Planning Inspectorate upheld the Council's decision to refuse agreeing with the view that the development would be detrimental to the character of the street scene.
Overall it is considered that the amended proposal would not overcome the reasons for refusal in the previous application.
SEPARATION DISTANCES Separation distances do not apply in this instance.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.