That (1) the Committee thanks the Mayor for the referral of this Notice of Motion and regrets that there has been a delay in it being brought to the Committee for its consideration, though it accepts that this was due to a number of circumstances which were not in its control; and (2) the Committee considers that factors to be considered when determining what constitutes proper, fair representation of Wirral’s population go beyond simply numbers and so proposes that it establishes a Task and Finish Panel to undertake a more in depth examination of the issues and that this be added to the Committee’s Work Programme.”
Word for word from the decision Wirral published for this meeting.Source: democracy.wirral.gov.uk
The Committee considered the following Notice of Motion referred to it by the Council at its meeting on 20 October 2014 (Minute No. 57 refers). It had been proposed by Councillor J Green and seconded by Councillor L Fraser that:
‘Council notes the recent decision taken by Knowsley Council to begin consulting its residents over reducing the number of Councillors from 63 to 45.
This Council believes that instead of presenting the public with petty, vindictive, rehashed and previously rejected budget options including:
pulling the plug on school crossing patrols introducing car parking charges at Wirral’s Country Parks not filling grit bins removing Council Tax over 70s discount closing public conveniences increasing fees and charges for football pitches, allotments, bowling greens, burials and cremations
The Leader of the Council should be consulting the public over reducing the number of Councillors.
In the absence of the Leader of the Council’s willingness to act Council requests the Boundary Commission for England commence an inquiry into the number of Councillors, and the electoral cycle, in Wirral, on the Council's wish to reduce the number of councillors to 44.
Council therefore instructs the Chief Executive to invite the Boundary Commission for England to meet with representatives of all parties represented on the Council and agree a timetable for the inquiry.’
The Chair set out the way in which she intended to deal with this item of business. As Councillor J Green was not in attendance at the meeting she invited Councillor L Fraser to address the Committee and set out the reasons for the Motion. The matter would then be open for debate, Councillor L Fraser would be given two minutes to respond to what was said and following that the Committee would reach its conclusions.
Councillor L Fraser informed that, in the light of the diminishing size of the Council’s work force, following the cost-cutting departure of more than 2,000 staff consideration should be given to consulting residents of the Borough on reducing the total number of Wirral Councillors. She proposed that the Boundary Commission be requested to assess Wirral’s requirements with a view to cutting the number of Councillors from 66 to 44. Councillor L Fraser proposed that as the Council’s middle managers’ pay had reduced by 10% Councillors should make cuts as well. She proposed that at a time when employees were being asked to do more for less and go the extra mile, the number of Councillors should be reduced and elections should be held every four years.
Councillor L Fraser informed that the Local Government Association had a view which it had reached this year, that the public wanted each Councillor to represent a distinct area. This enabled them to be held to account. She was aware that some Councillors took on some additional duties as a matter of choice but she did not consider that should be a mitigating factor. Reducing 66 Councillors down to 44 meant there would be two to represent each ward.
Councillor L Fraser made reference to Knowsley Council which was reducing the number of its Elected Members from 63 to 45 in order to make savings of £250,000 over the next two years. She quoted the Council’s Leader, Andy Moorhead who had said that
“It was a tough decision, but the right one. Quite simply, it means that us as Councillors have to work that bit harder. We’re asking our employees to do exactly the same. I think it is fair that we do the same.”
Councillor L Fraser proposed that the Chief Executive be requested to write to the Boundary Commission to invite it to undertake an eight week consultation exercise on whether to conduct a Local Government Boundary Review in Wirral.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Appointment of Independent PersonsResolved – That the appointment of the following Independent Persons of the Constitution and Standards Committee be a...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.