Item5
Resolved
DECISION The Panel gave careful consideration to the Investigator’s Report, all relevant documentary evidence and the representations made by all the parties to this matter. Panel was satisfied that a satisfactory investigation and report had been undertaken and produced in relation to all of the complaints. The Investigator had appropriately considered the evidence and afforded all the parties the opportunity to participate and adduce all relevant information and evidence for consideration. The Panel examined in detail all the matters and issues arising from the complaints during the hearing and was satisfied that all the parties had been afforded a fair opportunity to clarify any specific points and ensure the Panel understood their respective positions and responses. The Panel will provide its full decision within the next seven days; however, will deliver its decision in respect of the complaints made this evening. The Panel has noted there are a number of aggravating and mitigating factors arising in this matter which it has examined and considered in reaching its decision. Those factors will be set out in the full decision. The Panel considered the representations of the Independent Person in reaching its decision. The Independent Person was satisfied that a thorough investigation was undertaken; and agreed with the findings and conclusions reached as detailed within the Investigator’s Report. On balance, the Panel found all the complainants and their evidence credible; whereas the Panel found the evidence of Councillor Louise Reecejones to be inconsistent, vague and misleading. The Panel did not therefore find Councillor Reecejones to be credible. Accordingly the Panel: 1. accepted the Investigator’s Report; 2. agreed with all the conclusions of the Investigator as set out at paragraph 10.1 of the Investigator’s Report, namely: a. in respect of complainant 1, Tamsin Coates, the Panel found Councillor Reecejones to be in breach of the Code of Conduct in making an unjustified complaint to Tamsin Coates’ employer and pursuing her own personal agenda in her capacity as a councillor. Councillor Reecejones failed to treat Tamsin Coates with respect and conducted herself contrary to the council's duty to promote and maintain high standards of conduct. b. in respect of complainant 2, Jessica Smyth, the Panel found Councillor Reecejones to be in breach of the Code of Conduct in making an unjustified complaint to the organisation for which Jessica Smyth volunteers and alleging that Jessica Smyth’s tweets and conduct amounted to harassment/stalking. Councillor Reecejones failed to treat Jessica Smyth with respect and conducted herself contrary to the council's duty ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Word for word from the decision Wirral published for this meeting.
Source: democracy.wirral.gov.uk