Resolved
Resolved – That in accordance with Standing Order 12(2) all three motions be debated in one debate with separate votes on each. Councillor Chris Blakeley moved and Councillor Gerry Ellis seconded the following Motion – “Council notes that in excess of £1 million of Council taxpayers’ money has, so far, been utilised to support this project, as well as Council Officers’ and consultants’ time, while Cabinet itself has stated that golf in Wirral is in decline. Council also notes that the Celtic Manor Resort, formerly known as the Hoylake Golf Resort, is dependent on 160 higher-band houses and 40 apartments being built on a location within Wirral’s precious Green Belt with further Council support suggested at up to £26 million. Council recognises the widespread concern at this proposal, including the opposition voiced recently by Local Campaign Forum of the Labour Party. Council is advised by the Director of Governance and Assurance that, under the Leader and Cabinet system (as operated by Labour in Wirral), it does not have the power to demand or force the Cabinet to drop this unwanted scheme in its entirety. However, given the uncertainty, the massive public opposition, the financial risks to the taxpayer and the harm that would be caused to Wirral’s Green Belt, Council strongly recommends that Cabinet listen to the people of Wirral and withdraws from this scheme in its entirety and notify all stakeholders of its intention not to proceed.” Councillor Phil Gilchrist moved and Councillor Alan Brame seconded the following motion submitted in accordance with Standing Order 7 – “ Council remains concerned that this speculative development is still being put forward based on assumptions that no longer appear relevant at a time of economic uncertainty, growing concern about development in the Green Belt and greater recognition of the importance of ensuring future food supply in a period of climate change. In this context, the National Planning Policy Framework states… ‘Green Belt boundaries should only be altered where exceptional circumstances are fully evidenced and justified (para 136)' , albeit offering potential exceptions (para 145b) on a case by case basis. Without prejudging these issues, Council recognises that the planning considerations covering the special circumstances of this case would take considerable time and effort to justify and resolve. Council observes that the Hulton Park project in Bolton was called in by the Secretary of State after a lengthy period of preparation. Council believes that it is no longer reasonable to put stretched managerial and officer capacity into this Golf Resort project. Wirral’s key priority should be to bring together a Local Plan that protects agricultural land, makes a strong case against intrusions into the Green Belt and creates the conditions for urban regeneration and re-use of brownfield ... view the full minutes text for item 93.