Item22
Resolved
Resolved (35:26) 1 abstention that, Council notes the Ministerial Statement on 24th June 2025 whereby Jim McMahon MP, Minister of State for Local Government and English Devolution said: “The Government plans to legislate to abolish the committee system, requiring those councils currently operating this model to transition to the leader and cabinet model” Council notes that the ‘Cabinet system’ in local government was introduced by the Blair Government reducing the input of residents and non-Cabinet councillors in the decision-making process and that Wirral Council determined to address this democratic deficit by moving to a committee system in September 2020 from its leader and cabinet model . Decisions taken quickly are not necessarily the right decisions, as the Cabinet member and Chief Officer will sometimes not be aware of all the available information without contributions from councillors and residents. Council recalls the consequences of the introduction of the Cabinet in Wirral, including how 56 of the Borough’s 66 Councillors were left unaware of many decisions, until published, including: ? The development of a Hoylake Golf Resort ? 2016 OFSTED report: Children’s services in Wirral are inadequate ? Publication of the Wirral View newspaper ? The Strategic Asset Review to close libraries and leisure centres ? The proposal to release 21 areas of Green Belt for development ? Cessation of maintenance of Hoylake Beach ? Creation of the Wirral Growth Company Council believes that committee-based decision making is more open and transparent and enables greater input and scrutiny by Members and residents. Council notes that the Labour Party Manifesto at the 2024 General Election made no reference to the forced conversion to a Cabinet for all local authorities, promising merely to ‘review the governance arrangements for combined authorities.’ Council believes the committee system of governance is a significant improvement on the old, opaque cabinet system: it is inclusive, calls upon all councillors for input into how Wirral is governed, and has fostered a much more collegiate way of working between political parties. Council notes how, following a review by the Local Government Association (LGA) in 2022, a report said: “During each respective discussion with political groups, participants were asked to describe how the committee system of the council currently felt from their perspective. Through this question we heard positive replies such as ‘inclusive’, ‘democratic’ and ‘participatory’, highlighting the engaging and open aspects of the system that exist. Council acknowledges the work already undertaken in light of the peer reviews in 2021 and 2024 to improve and refine the committee system of governance and agrees that ... view the full minutes text for item 22.
Word for word from the decision Wirral published for this meeting.
Source: democracy.wirral.gov.uk