That the Cabinet: 1. resolve to retain the Cemeteries and Crematorium service, but note that this position should be kept under review; 2. note that capital investment in the service will be required, and that whilst any investment will be subject to demonstration of appropriate business cases, this is likely to require an increase in prices to support capital funding; 3. note the recommendations for service improvement and that the Cabinet Member for Cleaner & Greener City reviews the individual recommendations with officers to agree service improvements, subject to existing delegations.
Word for word from the decision Worcester published for this meeting.Source: committee.worcester.gov.uk
1.1To agree the direction of future management of Astwood Crematorium and Astwood and St Johns Cemeteries.
Background
2.1In September 2011 cabinet resolved to commission a due diligence investigation and report regarding the future management of the Crematorium.
2.2The remit of the report was to consider all future options for management of the service, to inform a decision on arrangements to provide the best outcome in terms of income generation and of quality of service for customers. The report was not intended to provide robust business cases, which would be required before implementation of any recommendations.
2.3A consultant was commissioned to carry out the review, which took place throughout mid 2012. The report is attached at Appendix 1. Sections of the report that are commercially sensitive or relate to individuals are not included, but have been considered by appropriate officers.
3.0Findings of the Review
3.1In summary, the review found that;
3.2The service has a high demand, which is likely to remain fairly stable over coming years, although there are some risks of competition.
3.3There is a requirement for significant capital investment due to the age of the facilities and in order to modernise and improve the service. This includes replacement of cremators and the need to address mercury abatement requirements.
3.4The service makes a significant contribution to Service and Council revenue running costs, although it should be noted that this contribution is fully accounted for in the Council’s base budgets.
3.5There is potential for greater revenue generation.
3.6There is potential to improve the service provided, in terms of customer service and efficiency.
3.7There is interest from the private sector in owning and / or operating the crematorium. 3.8 Based on the opening offers from private sector investors, and projections for income and expenditure, it would seem that the most financially advantageous option, over a 15 year period, is for the service to be retained by the Council, with carefully considered capital investment and service improvements to enhance the quality of service provided and increase revenue. However, it should be noted that this requires some £2m plus of capital investment, which would have to be subject to a business case exercise to demonstrate value for money and affordability, as the Council does not currently have £2m available to invest in this asset.
4.0Recommendations of the review
4.1The report, which is produced at Appendix 1, includes a financial options appraisal and then a section on recommendations under the following headings;
• Asset Recommendations • Employee Recommendations • Income Generating Recommendations
4.2Asset Recommendations
4.3The primary asset recommendation is that the Council decides on the preferred option for future management of the service, based on the options within the financial options appraisal. These include options for outright sale, retention with capital investment, and leasing arrangements.
4.3The report summarises eight possible scenarios for the future management of the service, and estimates a net value to the Council of each option calculated over a 15 year period. It should be noted that this financial analysis has been calculated on a high level summary basis for ease of understanding, and it does not take into account the time value of money through net present value calculations. This is something that would be done as part of the development of a robust business case.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Worcester City Masterplan UpdateThat the Cabinet agree to: 1. approve the allocation £75k from the “City Plan Fund” towards the production of an upda...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.