CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Worcester City Council
Planning Committee, Thursday 23 May 2013 at 1.30pm

Overturned Decisions Monitoring Report

Noted Planning 1 paper

Planning Committee noted this item on Thursday 23 May 2013. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item181

Resolved

That the Committee note the report.
Word for word from the decision Worcester published for this meeting. Source: committee.worcester.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Worcester's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning Committee, 3 pages

Purpose of the report

1.1To consider the report.

Background

2.1In 2002, as part of its audit work for the year 2000/01, the District Auditor submitted a report on Probity in Planning for Worcester City Council. One of the recommendations was:

“Worcester City Council should introduce formal monitoring and reporting of overturned decisions, which should include whether the case was subject to public speaking for or against.”

2.2This recommendation was accepted by the Probity in Planning Working Party. This is the twelfth monitoring report and, in accordance with the report to Planning Committee on 24 April 2003, it is expected that the report is made every six months, but this is the first for eighteen months.

2.3The District Audit’s Review of planning activity indicates that any number of overturns representing more than 2% or less than 0.5% of all cases received and processed would be a cause for concern. The reference to “all cases” includes delegated decisions which are not referred to Committee.

2.4The schedule below shows the cases where decisions did not follow recommendations for the period April 2012 to March 2013:-

Public Application Location Recommend’n Decision Speaking P13H0047 160 Astwood Road Refusal Approved No

2.5These statistics include all planning, listed building, advertisement and tree applications and can be summarised for the last ten years as follows:-

Recommendations Total Applications Annual Year Overturned Determined Percentage 2000/01 15 690 2.17 2001/02 15 746 2.01 2002/03 16 817 1.96 2003/04 8 855 0.93 2004/05 17 916 1.85 2005/06 12 784 1.53 2006/07 5 782 0.64 2007/08 4 767 0.52 2008/09 10 659 1.51 2009/10 6 566 1.06 2010/11 2 580 0.35 2011/12 6 553 1.08 2012/13 1 490 0.20 Total 117 9205 1.27

2.6The number of overturns (1) is below the lower limit of the range advised by the Audit Commission. Members have demonstrated good practice in considering material planning considerations and scrutinised the recommendations of officers and therefore I am not overly concerned that members are not scrutinising recommendations sufficiently. Officers place considerable weight to the opinion of the Highway Authority in respect of highway safety, but there are cases where members have a different opinion. I do not consider that the number of applications involved demonstrates a significant difference in opinion between officers and members in respect of highway safety, but the overturned decision involved a classified road which are the most important roads in the city to ensure highway safety.

2.7The District Auditor report also recommended monitoring where public speaking may have influenced the outcome. The table of overturned decisions in paragraph 2.4 above records the occasions at which public speaking took place. In the first two years of reporting there was clear evidence that a significant proportion of overturned decisions had arisen where public speaking occurred. Over recent years this has not been the case and I am satisfied that the period covered by this report continues to demonstrate that, albeit an issue to continue monitoring.

2.8The total number of applications considered by Planning Committee has reduced as shown in the table below:-

Year Number Determined Percentage Determined by Committee By Committee 2000/01 279 40.4 2001/02 325 43.6 2002/03 300 36.7 2003/04 249 29.1 2004/05 (1st Half) 109 22.3 2004/05 (2nd Half) 114 28.3 2005/06 (1st Half) 76 18.1 2005/06 (2nd Half) 51 14.0 2006/07 (1st Half) 64 17.3 2006/07 (2nd Half) 50 14.5 2007/08 (1st Half) 62 14.7 2007/08 (2nd Half) 41 11.6 2008/09 (1st Half) 51 13.5 2008/09 (2nd Half) 54 19.2 2009/10 (1st Half) 36 12.0 2009/10 (1st Half) 39 14.7 2010/11 63 10.0 2011/12 69 12.4 2012/13 37 7.75 2.9 In total seven proposals were the subject of speakers which can be split into the following categories:-

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Overturned Decisions Monitoring ReportDecisions 3 pages DownloadRead as text

More from Worcester Planning Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
13 Aug 2026 Minutes of Previous Planning CommitteeThat the minutes of the meeting held on 23 rd July 2026 be approved as a correct record and signed by the Chair, subj... Approved Open
23 Jul 2026 Minutes of Previous Planning CommitteeThat the minutes of the meeting held on 21 st May 2026 be approved as a correct record and signed by the Chair. Approved Open
23 Jul 2026 Application 26/00440/LB - Worcester City Museum and Art Gallery, Foregate StreetThat the Committee grant Listed Building Consent, subject to conditions set out in section 9 of the report. Decided Open
23 Jul 2026 Planning Committee Annual Report 2025/26That the Committee approve the Planning Committee Annual Report and recommend it to Council for information. Approved Open
21 May 2026 Minutes of Previous Planning CommitteeThat the minutes of the meeting held on 16 th April 2026 be approved as a correct record and signed by the Chair. Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies