That the Committee refuse planning permission for the following reasons: The proposals relate to a Beech tree that is located in a prominent position in the garden of 1 Ostler Drive. The tree is part of part of an extensive tree preservation order that includes many trees in the surrounding area which predate the Ostler Drive estate. The Beech tree is considered to have high amenity value and is a good example of the species being a mature tree of good form with an evenly balanced canopy, in apparent good health that is visually prominent in local and longer range views on approach from various directions. Physiologically the tree appears in good condition with no obvious structural or physiological signs to suggest that it is stressed, in decline or that any parts are at risk of collapse. The tree is also proposed to be felled on grounds relating to potential danger, liability, excessive shading and low amenity value and that the tree has outgrown the garden area and is blocking majority of sunlight to gardens. In the opinion of the of the Local Planning Authority insufficient evidence or justification has been submitted to warrant an overriding need for the removal of a healthy Beech tree with high amenity value, which would be unacceptable and harmful to the visual amenity of the site, surrounding area and group value of the tree preservation order.
Word for word from the decision Worcester published for this meeting.Source: committee.worcester.gov.uk
1.1The Deputy Director of Economic Development and Planning recommends that the Planning Committee refuse the application for the following reasons:
The proposals relate to a Beech tree that is located in a prominent position in the garden of 1 Ostler Drive. The tree is part of part of an extensive tree preservation order that includes many trees in the surrounding area which predate the Ostler Drive estate.
The Beech tree is considered to have high amenity value and is a good example of the species being a mature tree of good form with an evenly balanced canopy, in apparent good health that is visually prominent in local and longer range views on approach from various directions. Physiologically the tree appears in good condition with no obvious structural or physiological signs to suggest that it is stressed, in decline or that any parts are at risk of collapse.
The tree is also proposed to be felled on grounds relating to potential danger, liability, excessive shading and low amenity value and that the tree has outgrown the garden area and is blocking majority of sunlight to gardens.
In the opinion of the of the Local Planning Authority insufficient evidence or justification has been submitted to warrant an overriding need for the removal of a healthy Beech tree with high amenity value, which would be unacceptable and harmful to the visual amenity of the site, surrounding area and group value of the tree preservation order.
Background
2.1This application is referred to the Planning Committee at the request of Councillor Mitchell on grounds relating to the proposed removal of a mature Beech tree located in the garden of 1 Ostler Drive.
2.2The application was received on 26th January 2017 and the target date for determination is 27th March 2017. An extension of time for the determination of the application to 26th May 2017 has therefore been agreed with the application to allow consideration of the application by the Planning Committee. 3. The Site and Surrounding Area
3.1The tree is located in the garden of 1 Oster Drive, which is located on Oldbury Rd and the Worcester University grounds are located directly North. The tree is part of TPO 88 which consists of a number of trees, the Beech tree is within a group (ref G4 in the order) of mature trees which predate the Ostler Drive estate.
3.2In my opinion, the Beech tree does have a high amenity value; this is based on the fact that it is a mature tree of good form, in apparent good health and its prominence within the local area and further afield where it can be seen on the skyline.
3.3Conditionally the tree is good; there are no obvious structural or physiological signs to suggest that it is stressed, in decline or that any parts are at risk of collapse. It should also be noted that the canopy is evenly balanced and which is a contributing factor in why it has high amenity value, this is a good example of the species.
3.4The application site is within St Clement Ward. It is not a within a conservation area nor adjacent to a statutory listed building.
4. The Proposal
4.1The submitted proposal seeks consent for the Beech Tree to be felled on the grounds relating to potential danger, liability, excessive shading and low amenity value. The applicant is of the opinion that the tree has outgrown the relatively small rear gardens (it is in excess of 70ft tall), and is blocking majority of sunlight to gardens.
4.2The applicant has confirmed that if approval was granted then replacement tree planting of smaller, more suitable species would be undertaken.
5. Planning Policy
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Minutes of Previous Planning CommitteeThat the minutes of the meeting held on 23 rd July 2026 be approved as a correct record and signed by the Chair, subj...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.