That the Committee: 1. note the contents of the update report; 2. agree an increased sum of £5,750.00 to be allocated from the £100,000 total Gateway Project budget to pay for replacement signs; and 3. agree the new signs based on the preferred option, as set out in Section 3 of the report, and delegate to the Chair and Vice Chair, in consultation with the Public Art Working Group, to approve the final design.
Word for word from the decision Worcester published for this meeting.Source: committee.worcester.gov.uk
1.2agree an increased sum of £5,750.00 to be allocated from the £100,000 total Gateway Project budget to pay for replacement signs; and
1.3agree the new signs should be based on the preferred option as set out in section 3 of the report.
Background
2.1At its meeting on 23 July 2019 the Committee approved the sum of £2,500 to improve the look of the existing City of Worcester road signs (as shown in the picture to the right) which are located at various points on the highway network along the city’s boundary.
2.2A subsequent audit of these signs located 10 signs in the following locations:
1. Ombersley Road (A449 North) 2. Droitwich Road (A38 North) 3. Blackpole Road (B4850) 4. Whittington Road 5. Bath Road (A38 South) 6. Malvern Road (A449 South – Powick Bridge) 7. Hallow Road (A443) 8. Martley Road (B4204) 9. Bromyard Road (A44) 10. B4636 – East Worcester 2.3 The audit found that all of the signs were in need of renovation
City Crest at the top of the sign – in need of repainting Twinning info at the bottom of the sign – in need of repainting “City of Worcester” – in need of refreshing of the paintwork Outline Frame – in need of refreshing of the paintwork Outline City Image – in need of refreshing of the paintwork
2.4The condition report outlining the various issues relating to the existing signs was sent to the Environmental Operations team to quote for the necessary refurbishment works. Information received from Environmental Operations as follows:
The signs are at least 20 years old and well past their expected lifetime. They were installed when the City Council had the District Engineers and Highways services in house. As such there is no information on the costs of these signs. The signs are made of fibreglass and as such would need to be taken down, taken off site, rubbed down and repainted with a suitable paint.
2.5The County Council have been contacted with regard to replacing the signs. They have advised that under the 2016 legislation the existing signs could not be replaced on a like for like basis.
2.6The County Council have confirmed they are governed in this regard by the TSRGD 2016, (Statutory Instruments 2016 No. 362 The Traffic Signs Regulations and General Directions 2016 - Made - 16th March 2016, Laid before Parliament - 22nd March 2016, Coming into force - 22nd April 2016).
3. Preferred Option
3.1A pictorial sign, such as those Evesham has recently had installed (as shown in the picture to the left).
3.2However, the County Council has said they do not recommend photographic signs, because the reflective covering over the picture makes it look out of focus and also, depending on the subject of the picture, dark.
3.3We could however put an image of the city rather than a photograph, examples of which are shown below. 3.4 Examples of images used in City Boundary signs elsewhere.
3.5The preferred option is replacement of the existing signs with a design to be agreed, with a suitable city image and wording to be agreed with the highways authority.
Alternative options considered
4.1Refurbishment of existing signs - Traffic Management costs for both removal and reinstallation of the existing signs would need to be added to the refurbishment costs for existing signs, meaning the costs would likely exceed more than £1,000 per sign (so more than £10K in total) to refurbish the existing signs. Replacing the signs is therefore by far the most economically advantageous option.
4.2Other options meeting legislative requirements suggested by the County Council
The "hump" sign with the symbols that go throughout the city.
We could add something like the city crest in the “hump” area of the sign.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.