That the Committee delegates authority to the Corporate Director – Finance and Resources and the Corporate Director – Operations, Homes and Communities to make a direct award of contract to Dennis Eagle for the purchase of 7 Refuse Collection Vehicles for a total price of £1.65m.
Word for word from the decision Worcester published for this meeting.Source: committee.worcester.gov.uk
1.1Delegates authority to the Corporate Director - Finance and Resources and the Corporate Director – Operations, Homes and Communities to make a direct award of contract to Dennis Eagle, for the purchase of 7 Refuse Collection Vehicles for a total price of £1.65m.
Background
2.1As part of the vehicle replacement capital programme, a programme for replacing vehicles across Worcester City Council has been drawn up until 2036 with subsequent replacements year-on-year, depending on type of vehicle and usage.
2.2Due to impacts from external forces and world-wide economy, procurement of vehicles is realising a lead in time of up to 52 weeks from placement of order to delivery.
2.3In years 2023/24 and 2024/25 Environmental Operations are due to replace seven refuse and collection vehicles (RCVs). Capital budgets of £1,611,090 have previously been agreed by Council for their replacement for their replacement.
2.4The existing RCVs are currently supplied by Dennis Eagle, which are narrow-bodied vehicles tailor made for densely populated urban areas with narrow streets. Dennis Eagle are the only known supplier worldwide who can supply these. These are preferable for service delivery as they are necessary in accessing the many narrow streets in Worcester City. Appendix 1 is examples of the type of access required for the day-to-day operation.
3. Preferred Option
3.1To bring forward the procurement of all seven vehicles from Dennis Eagle as a one- off procurement exercise, due to the lead in time from purchase to delivery.
3.3A quote has been received from Dennis Eagle to directly purchase the vehicles and a considerable discount has been offered for being a previous customer, and, if the contract is secured earlier than the Council had originally programmed.
Alternative options considered
4.1Procure from an alternative provider Other manufacturers have been considered; however, as no other organisation builds these types of narrow vehicles, different manufacturer would result in the service being unable to operate in certain locations.
4.2Whilst the existing fleet is currently supplied by Dennis Eagle a change of vehicle manufacturer could also cause service disruption from a maintenance point of view. This is due to the mechanics, who currently service existing vehicles, being trained and familiar with Dennis Eagle vehicles and a change would mean they would need to undertake additional training to bridge the skills gap.
4.3Consideration has been given as to whether these particular Dennis Eagle vehicles should be procured directly from the manufacturer Dennis Eagle, or via a pre- procured framework. Examination of prices via framework routes has demonstrated that the best price can be obtained by purchasing directly from the manufacturer.
4.4Procure electric or bio-fuel vehicles Work is underway to plan for procuring electric RCVs from 2025/2026 rather than continuing to use diesel vehicles. An opportunity to explore the use of electric vehicles has been sought and officers are currently waiting to demonstrate an electric RCV from Dennis Eagle. However, the current waiting list means that there are several months before we can undertake a trial.
There are some unknowns with regards to operating electric RCVs with regards to the payload, the real-world mileage of the vehicle, and whether they have sufficient range for our day-to-day operation. It is felt within the industry that the exponential growth of the technology the battery tech is improving for the future. The preferred electric RCV would be the Denis Eagle eCollect, which is not currently eligible for Office for Zero Emission Vehicles (OZEV) grants, and has, therefore, a high purchase price. At present it is approximately £450,000 to purchase per vehicle.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.