That the Committee agrees to: 1. note the contents of the report and, in particular, the ‘CDS Feasibility Review of Cremator Replacement at Astwood Crematorium’ at Appendix 1; 2. approves preferred Option B as set out within the report and delegates authority to the Corporate Director - Operations, Homes and Communities in consultation with Chair and Vice Chair to procure and appoint design and development consultants to develop detailed and fully costed designs for approval; 3. recommend to Council a capital budget allocation of £250,000 to complete the work referred to in recommendation 2; and 4. note that as a major capital project, further updates and requests for approvals will be presented to the Policy and Resources Committee.
Word for word from the decision Worcester published for this meeting.Source: committee.worcester.gov.uk
1.1Notes the contents of the report and, in particular, the ‘CDS Feasibility Review of Cremator Replacement at Astwood Crematorium’ at Appendix 1;
1.2Approves preferred Option B as set out within the report and delegates authority to the Corporate Director (Operations, Homes & Communities) in consultation with Chair and Vice Chair to procure and appoint design and development consultants to develop detailed and fully costed designs for approval;
1.3Recommends to Council a capital budget allocation of £250,000 to complete the work referred to in recommendation 1.2; and
1.4Notes that as a major capital project, further updates and requests for approvals will be presented to Policy and Resources Committee.
Background
2.1At its meeting of March 2023 this Committee received an UPDATE REPORT setting out the need for development of Astwood Crematorium and a summary of appraisal work that had been carried out for the Council to better understand its options for how it could continue to provide a crematorium facility into the future.
2.2The current cremators at Astwood Crematorium are approaching the end of their life and require replacing and, in addition, there is a high likelihood of new statutory environmental targets being applied to existing crematoria by a set date, likely to be during 2027/28.
2.3With a limited development footprint available at Astwood, due to the chapel and crematorium being immediately surrounded by consecrated ground or access roads, a risk had been highlighted that replacing the existing 3 cremators, and needing to include all the required environmental abatement would not be achievable.
2.4Initial appraisal work considered establishing a new crematorium facility elsewhere and explored several potential sites near the city. Clearly a number of significant planning considerations would apply to any new site. Initial advice provided by the Council’s Planning Service confirmed that any such application would need to meet a sequential series of tests to justify why a move away from a site that already benefits from planning permission for crematoria is required. 2.5 In addition, it was clear that the costs of acquiring a new site and attempting to secure a planning consent would represent a major challenge to delivering a new set of cremators to benefit the city of Worcester, within an acceptable timeframe and budget.
2.6As a result, it was necessary to undertake further appraisal work for remaining at Astwood. At the March meeting, Committee approved an allocation of £100,000 funding to enable further technical feasibility work to be undertaken to investigate whether continued use of Astwood for cremations is feasible. The funding was drawn from the Cremator Reserve – a revenue fund established to support repair and replacement of the cremators in due course.
2.7Following this meeting, further work was undertaken to investigate the feasibility of operating with two cremators at Astwood, instead of the three the Council has historically operated with. Specialist consultants CDS were appointed to undertake this work as an extension of the feasibility studies that they had undertaken.
2.8Modern cremators include additional abatement technology and so a critical consideration was whether three new cremators could be accommodated within the available developable footprint without undermining customer experience (i.e. reduced chapel size) or staff welfare (reduced office or rest facilities for staff).
2.9This work has clarified that there are relatively local sites operated by District Councils that are undertaking between 1900 – 2000 cremations per year on two cremators compared to the 1600 on average that Astwood undertakes via its three cremators.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.