RESOLVED - That the draft response to the consultation, attached as Appendix A to report HCCS/39/15, be supported subject to the addition of the following text in the response to Consultation Question 2: ‘Whilst the Welsh Government notes that any such new powers should be carefully circumscribed and available in specific and exceptional circumstances, an alternative model could be that where the Ombudsman has identified wider systemic concerns following an initial investigation into a complaint, he then writes to the Auditor General for Wales (or relevant inspectorate) advising him/her to undertake a special inspection or produce a Public Interest Report into the matter.’
Word for word from the decision Wrexham published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.wrexham.gov.uk
Consultation on an inquiry into the consideration of powers of the Public Services Ombudsman for Wales - Response from Wrexham County Borough Council.
This response is a supplementary response to that of the WLGA, which Wrexham County Borough Council fully supports.
Consultation Questions
1. What are your views on the effectiveness of the current Public Services Ombudsman (Wales) Act 2005?
Own initiative investigations
2. Currently, the Ombudsman may only investigate a matter that is the subject of a complaint made to him/her. What are your views on ‘own initiative’ investigations powers, which would enable the Ombudsman to initiate his/her own investigations without having first received a complaint about an issue. Please explain your answer.
Wrexham County Borough Council (WCBC) remains unclear as to what action or incident could cause the Ombudsman to begin an investigation if this were not prompted by a complaint.
We believe that if this were to be implemented, the Ombudsman should have strict timescales to adhere to, as Local Authorities have in managing complaints. This would reduce the work pressures on the relevant departments and provide clarity for all parties on the length of the process.
3. Do you have any concerns that own-initiative investigation powers could result in the Ombudsman’s responsibilities overlapping with the responsibilities of other bodies? How could this be managed?
WCBC shares the concerns of the WLGA and Welsh Government regarding the potential duplication with inspections by other bodies. It is not clear that there is an unmet need for investigations by the Ombudsman outside the current scope of his powers.
The impartiality of the Ombudsman could be compromised if he were regularly involved with non-complaint based investigations in Local Authorities?
4. Do you have a view on the likely financial costs and benefits of the Ombudsman having own-initiative powers?
The primary concerns would be for the resources required to support the Ombudsman in undertaking any such investigation. As stated above, the timescales and procedures for any investigation would need to be clearly defined to ensure the Council can comply with this and support any staff that may be central to the investigation. Oral Complaints
5. At present, the Ombudsman can only accept complaints in writing. What are your views on the Ombudsman being able to accept complaints made orally? Please explain your answer.
WCBC accepts complaints made in any form the customer wishes to. This ensures we do not discriminate against those who do not have the capacity to put things in writing. However, where this is the case, we ensure that the method we have used for recording the complaint is agreed by the complainant (e.g. if complaint made verbally, the notes would be written up by an officer and the accuracy of these notes confirmed by the complainant.)
6. What other type/form of submission should be acceptable (e.g. email, website form, text messages)
As above
7. Do you have a view on the financial costs and benefits of this provision?
There is no additional cost to meeting a complainant other than officer time. However the council would not refuse a meeting where there is merit.
Complaints handling across public services
8. At present there is no consistency in the way public bodies deal with complaints. Adoption of the model complaints policy issued by the Welsh government is voluntary. What are your views on the Ombudsman preparing a model complaints policy which public bodies would be obliged to adopt. Please explain your answer.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.