Application No: P/2026/0174 - First and Second Floor Flat, 36 Brook Street, Wrexham, LL13 7LL
RefusedPlanning1 paper
AI summaryWrexham Planning Committee refused permission to convert a 3-bedroom flat at 36 Brook Street into a house in multiple occupation, against officer advice, citing HMO overconcentration and parking concerns.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeRefusedCommittee overturned officer recommendation to grant
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextNot stated
Who it affects36 Brook Street, WrexhamApplicant and nearby residents in Offa ward
What was decided
The committee refused planning permission for the change of use from a 3-bedroom flat to a 3-bedroom house in multiple occupation for a maximum of 4 occupants. Report P5, P8
The committee gave two reasons for refusal: the development would result in an overconcentration of HMOs within a 50 metre radius, and would give rise to demand for on-street parking to the detriment of highway safety. Report P32
Why
Two existing HMOs are within 50 metres of the site boundary, at Snowdon Hall on Abbot Street and Vicarage Hill, and the proposal would technically push the area above the 10% threshold set by Policy H4 and Local Planning Guidance Note 5. Report P32, P31
There is no off-street parking provision for the existing or proposed property, and the committee concluded the development would generate on-street parking demand that would harm highway safety under policies GDP1 and T8. Report P23, P46
The community council objected to the application, raising concerns about the impact on the River Dee and Bala Lake Special Area of Conservation, and two representations were received from neighbours. Report P12, P17, P29
What happens next
The papers do not set out next steps following the refusal; the applicant may appeal to the Welsh Ministers or submit a revised application.
Options considered
Rejected: Grant planning permission, as recommended by the Chief Officer Economy and Planning. Committee found the development conflicted with UDP Policy H4 and LPGN 5 on HMO concentration, and with policies GDP1 and T8 on parking and highway safety. Report P8, P32, P46
Chosen: Refuse planning permission. Two reasons for refusal set out relating to HMO overconcentration and on-street parking demand harming highway safety.
Implications
Legal: The applicant may seek to appeal the refusal or submit a revised application for the same change of use.
Other: Officers concluded the proposal would have no unacceptable impact on visual amenity, residential amenity, biodiversity or flood risk, and that nutrient impacts on the River Dee and Bala Lake Special Area of Conservation could be screened out. Report P49, P51, P53
Who and where
The applicant, who sought to convert the flat to a 3-bedroom HMO for up to 4 occupants Report P3, P5, P11
Neighbours of 36 Brook Street who responded to the public consultation Report P29
Offa Community Council, which objected to the application Report P17
Residents and businesses in the Brynyffynnon ward within 50 metres of the site Report P6, P32
Timeline
2026-09-07: Planning Committee considered application P/2026/0174 and resolved to refuse permission.
P/2024/1362 (prior application): A previous application to convert the flat into 3 apartments was refused due to phosphate increases and flood risk. Report P13
Plain English for the jargon
HMO: House in Multiple Occupation, a property shared by several tenants who are not from one household.
UDP: Unitary Development Plan, the local development plan used by Wrexham.
LPGN: Local Planning Guidance Note, supplementary guidance adopted by the council.
SAC: Special Area of Conservation, a protected habitat under conservation law.
TAN: Technical Advice Note, national planning guidance issued by the Welsh Government.
NBB: Net Benefit for Biodiversity, a planning requirement to deliver biodiversity gains.
Flood Zone 2: An area identified as having a medium probability of river flooding.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item33
Resolved
RESOLVED – That planning permission be refused. Reasons for decision (i) The development will result in an overconcentration of HMOs within the immediate area of the site contrary to Policy H4 (d) of the adopted Wrexham Unitary Development Plan and Local Planning Guidance Note No. 5 'Conversion of Dwellings into Houses in Multiple Occupation' which sets out a maximum of 10% of HMOs within a 50 metres radius. (ii) The development will give rise to demand for on-street parking in the vicinity of the site to the detriment of highway safety. The development therefore conflicts with policies GDP1 and T8 of the Wrexham Unitary Development Plan.
Word for word from the decision Wrexham published for this meeting.Source: moderngov.wrexham.gov.uk
Agent [name removed] Address FIRST AND SECOND FLOOR FLAT, 36 BROOK STREET, WREXHAM, LL13 7LL
Description of Development NEWID DEFNYDD O FFLAT 3 YSTAFELL WELY (DOSBARTH C3) I DŶ AMLFEDDIANNAETH 3 YSTAFELL WELY (TAI AMLFEDDIANNAETH) (DOSBARTH C4) - UCHAFSWM O 4 PRESWYLYDD / CHANGE OF USE OF 3 BEDROOM FLAT (CLASS C3) TO 3 BEDROOM HOUSE IN MULTIPLE OCCUPATION (HMO) (CLASS C4) - MAXIMUM 4 OCCUPANTS
Ward Brynyffynnon/Brynyfynnon
Community Offa/Offa
Recommendation Grant
Officer Report
Site Description The site comprises a 3-bedroom residential flat over the first and second floors of the building, with a retail unit beneath on the ground floor. Report of the Chief Officer Economy and Planning
Proposal Permission is sought for the change of use of the existing 3-bedroom flat to a 3- bedroom, 4-person HMO.
Reason for Committee Determination Community Council objection.
Site History P/2024/1362 - RETENTION OF GROUND FLOOR AS SHOP WITH STORAGE AREA TO REAR, NEW SHOPFRONT AND CONVERSION OF FLAT ON FIRST AND SECOND FLOORS INTO 3 NO. APARTMENTS - Permission Refused due to increase in Phosphates from the site and flood risk associated with increased number of units.
Development Plan Unitary Development Plan Policy PS1 - The Broad Location of Development Policy PS2 - The Broad Location of Development Policy GDP1 - Development Objectives Policy T8 - Parking Policy EC6 - Biodiversity Policy EC13 - Flood Risk Policy EC14 - Protection of Controlled Waters Policy H4 - Sub-division of dwellings
Local Planning Guidance Notes (LPGN’s) LPGN 05 – Houses in Multiple Occupancy LPGN 16 – Parking Standards
Relevant National Policy Technical Advice Note (TAN) 11: Noise Report of the Chief Officer Economy and Planning
Consultation Responses Community Council: Objects. Raises concerns about the impact of the development upon the River Dee and Bala Lake SAC, due to potential increase in nutrients / phosphates from the HMO.
Local Member: No response received.
Natural Resources Wales: Raise no objections.
The planning application proposes highly vulnerable development (conversion to HMO). The Flood Map for Planning identifies the application site to be at risk of flooding and within Flood Zone 2 (Rivers). Given the nature of the proposed development, with no change in vulnerability (and in the absence of a flood consequences assessment) we consider the proposals could be acceptable, subject to the developer being made aware of the potential flood risks and consequences.
Dwr Cymru Welsh Water: Raises no objection and confirms capacity exists within the public sewerage network in order to receive the domestic foul only flows from the proposed development site
Highway Officer: Raises no objection.
There is no off-street parking provision for the existing or proposed property. There is no increase in the number of bedrooms as part of the proposal and therefore no increase in parking demand. the proposed development is in a highly sustainable location. It is also likely that the proposed apartments will appeal to those who don’t own a car. The LHA would raise no objections to the proposed development in respect of parking provision.
Both the existing apartment and proposed 3 bed HMO have the same cycle storage requirements ie/ minimum of 2 cycle spaces. As both the existing and proposed accommodation have the same shortfall in adequate cycle parking / storage ie/ no provision, the LHA would raise no objections in this instance.
Clarification on whether the bins / recycling will be brought to the footway at the front of the building for collection by an external entrance on the ground floor.
Contaminated Land Officer: No comments.
Public Protection Officer: Raise no objection subject to a condition to secure noise attenuation measures between floors and advisory notes in relation to licensing requirements. Report of the Chief Officer Economy and Planning
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.