CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Wychavon District Council
Development Control Committee, Thursday 4 August 2005

Planning application Ref W/05/00773/PN - Retirement residential development comprising 71 flats, warden's accommodation, communal facilities and car parking. Land at High Street and Cherry Orchard, Pershore WR10. Morbaine Limited.

Refused Planning 1 paper

Development Control Committee refused this item on Thursday 4 August 2005. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item129

Resolved

Resolved Refused for the following reasons:- (a) The application site is allocated for mixed use development by policy SR4A in the Wychavon District Local Plan Review - Revised Deposit. The proposal for solely residential development would undermine the objectives of this policy to bring new life into towns, help produce balanced communities and reduce the need to travel. The proposal is contrary to Policy SR4A of the Wychavon District Local Plan Review - Revised Deposit, Policy D13 of the Worcestershire County Structure Plan and the provisions of PPG3 (b) The scale of the development is inconsistent with the modesty in scale of neighbouring buildings in the Conservation Area. The design of the elevations echoes the scale of the building, with large formal Georgian and Victorian style frontages, contrary to the modesty and simplicity of the elevations of neighbouring small houses and cottages. The siting of the building behind front gardens defined by railings is inconsistent with the back of pavement siting of buildings in the Conservation Area. The proposal would see the removal of existing trees which make a positive contribution to the character and appearance of the area. The proposal therefore does not preserve or enhance the appearance and character of the conservation area contrary to policy QE5 of the West Midlands Spatial Strategy, Policy CB3 and CB4 of the Wychavon District Local Plan, Policy ENV13 of the Wychavon District Local Plan Review - Revised Deposit, Policies CTC19 and CTC20 of the Worcestershire County Structure Plan and the provisions of PPG15. (c) The proposed building would block views of Pershore Abbey from Cherry Walk. For this reason and the reasons outline above the proposed development will not preserve or enhance the setting of a number of Listed Buildings contrary to policy QE5 of the West Midlands Spatial Strategy, Policy CB5 of the Wychavon District Local Plan, Policy ENV16 of the Wychavon District Local Plan Review - Revised Deposit, Policy CTC19 of the Worcestershire County Structure Plan and the provisions of PPG15. (d) The proposed building would lead to a loss of light and privacy, as well as cause a significant overbearing effect to the nearby residences on the opposite side of High Street and Redlands on the opposite side of Cherry Orchard. The development would cause unacceptable harm to the amenities of these properties contrary to policy Policy GB2 of the Wychavon District Local Plan Review - Revised Deposit (e) The proposal does not include any affordable housing units in an area where there is an identified need for such accommodation. As such the proposal is ... view the full minutes text for item 129.
Word for word from the decision Wychavon published for this meeting. Source: mgov.wychavon.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Wychavon's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Development Control Committee

Development Control Committee - 04/08/2005

W/05/00773/PN Parish: Pershore

Grid Ref: E:394890.84 N:246066.62 Ward: Pershore 28

Major Application Description: RETIREMENT RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT COMPRISING 71 FLATS, WARDEN'S ACCOMMODATION, COMMUNAL FACILITIES AND CAR PARKING.

Site: Land at High Street and, Cherry Orchard, Pershore, WR10

Applicant: Morbaine Limited

Agent: Not applicable

Date Valid: 24/05/2005 Case Jonathan Edwards Officer: Expiry Date: 23/08/2005 Tel: 01386 565324 Member(s): Cllr C G J Tucker Cllr J T Grantham Cllr Mrs G A M Amphlett

1. Site Description and Details of Proposal

This is a full application which relates to an area of land measuring some 0.5 hectares and located on the corner of High Street and Cherry Orchard/Kings George's Way. The site currently accommodates a number of buildings including a Texaco petrol station and ATS tyre and exhaust depot. A number of matures trees lie along the southern boundary of the site.

The site adjoins the Pershore Market site and New Inn (a listed building) on the southern side. The site is on the opposite side of the road to a number of dwellings on the west side of High Street as well as Redland House (residential apartments) and Redlands (a residential cul-de-sac) on the opposite side of Cherry Orchard.

The application proposes the demolition of all existing buildings and the erection of a new building containing 71 retirement flats with warden's accommodation and communal facilities (lounge, conservatory, laundry) at ground floor level. The footprint of the building would form three sides of a courtyard area including parking area with 42 car parking spaces and small garden area. Vehicular access to the site is shown off King George's Way, close to the vehicular access to the Market Area.

The proposed building is designed to have three main elevations facing out onto the High Street, Cherry Walk and King George's Way. The elevation facing the High Street would be four storeys high with the upper storey partly provided within roofspace. The elevation facing Cherry Walk would be partly four, partly three storeys high again including parts where the upper floor would be provided within roof areas. The elevations facing King George's Way would be three and two storey high with parts where dormer windows are shown to allow use of loft space.

The site lies within Pershore Conservation Area.

The application has been submitted with supporting comments and a design brief, making the following points:-

- lengthy pre-application discussions have taken place; - a financial report is provided which justifies why a pure residential use is proposed and why no affordable accommodation can be offered; - this is a brownfield site with considerable development costs; - design layout has taken the natural form of the site and this affords where possible independent access to the majority of apartments at ground floor level; - scheme retains character of the existing fabric of the town which has a victorian/georgian character; - differing roof levels provide a non uniform structure typical of the town centre; - one occupant of each unit will need to be 55+ years of age; - Local Plan policy and SPG aspirations for the site were part of desk top exercise and did not emanate from a full detailed appraisal of the site in terms of preparing layouts, assessing costs and proving viability; - mixed use will never happen and only our scheme would see the site regenerated; - 34 units was only meant as a guide; - these units will be for elderly people and no children will live on the site. Therefore no education contribution is necessary; - query request for contributions towards cycling strategy.

An application seeking Conservation Area Consent for the demolition of the existing buildings on the site (ref. no. W/05/00943 is reported elsewhere on this agenda).

The application is the subject of a members site visit.

2. Planning Policies

West Midlands Spatial Strategy

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Planning application Ref W/05/00773/PN: Retirement residential development comprising 71 flats, warden's accommodation, communal facilities and car parking. Land at High Street and Cherry Orchard, Pershore WR10. Morbaine Limited.Report 61 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting
116Minutes.Approved 118Planning application Ref W/05/00971/PN - Erection of 10 new dwellings which comprise 1 No. 3 bedroom house, 7 No. 2 bedroom houses and 2 No. 2 bedroom bungalows and associated external works. Land at, Ivy Lane, Bretforton, WR11. Nexus Midlands Housing Association Limited.Agreed 119Planning application Ref W/05/01113/PN - Removal of condition No 3 (restricting use of buildings to be in connection with existing buildings) on Planning Permission W/04/1055/PN . Glassier, Worcester Road, Drakes Broughton, WR10 2AG. Glassier.Approved 120Planning application Ref W/05/00998/PN - Erection of Dormer Bungalow and detached garage on land adjoining existing house. 1 St. Augustine Drive, Droitwich Spa, WR9 8QR. Mr and Mrs L Barron.Refused 121Planning application Ref W/05/01081/PN - Removal of 3 redundant antennas, 1 dish, and 1 equipment cabin and installation of 3 Vodaphone Antennas, 1 dish and 2 equipment cabinets (and ancillary works). Yew Tree Hill Water Tower, Newland Road, Droitwich Spa, WR9. Vodaphone Ltd.Approved 122Planning application Ref W/05/00936/PN - New dairy complex, alterations and extension. Greville Hall, Hinton-on-the-Green, Evesham, WR11 7QX. Lasletts (Hinton) Charity.Approved 123Planning application Ref W/05/01123/PP - Rear conservatory and replacement of flat roof with sloping tiled roof. 10 Waterlaide Road, Hartlebury, DY11 7TP. Mr and Mrs R Hamilton Gray.Approved 124Planning application Ref W/05/01163/OU - Outline application for planning permission to erect four two storey detached dwellings. Land adj, The Coach House, Old Road, Whittington, WR5. The Trustees of the Berkeley Settlement.Deferred 125Planning application Ref W/05/01162/PN - Erection of noise attenuation Bund. Land adj, The Coach House, Old Road, Whittington, WR5. The Trustees of the Berkeley Settlement.Deferred 126Planning application Ref W/05/00983/CU - Alterations and improvements to existing outbuilding to form residential extension to existing dwelling. Yew Tree House, Lineholt Lane, Ombersley, Droitwich Spa WR9 OJX. Mrs J Scaife.Agreed 127Planning application Ref W/05/00984/LB - Alterations and improvements to existing dwelling. Yew Tree House, Lineholt Lane, Ombersley, Droitwich Spa WR9 0JK. Mrs J Scaife.Approved 128Planning application Ref W/04/01732/CU - Erection of a Granny Annexe. Pensham Farm, 47 Pensham Hill, Pershore, WR10 2HB. Mr R Lamb.Agreed
129Planning application Ref W/05/00773/PN - Retirement residential development comprising 71 flats, warden's accommodation, communal facilities and car parking. Land at High Street and Cherry Orchard, Pershore WR10. Morbaine Limited.This decision
130Planning application Ref W/05/00943/CA - Demolition of all structures and clearance of the site to make way for retirement development (planning application submitted concurrently). Land at High Street and Cherry Orchard, Pershore WR10. Morbaine Limited.Refused 131Planning application Ref W/05/00979/DW - Proposed Stakepark. Abbey Park, Abbey Road, Pershore, WR10. Wychavon District Council.Approved 132Planning application Ref W/05/00946/PN - Fishing Lake for 25 No fishing pegs, car parking and landscaping. Pincox Farm, Naunton Beauchamp, WR10 2LG. Mr S Bowyer.Approved 133Proposed Diversion and Creation of Footpath at the Wharf Inn, Holt Fleet.Agreed 134Tree Preservation Order Defford No 1 2005, Arden Sailing Club.Decided 135Summary of Appeal Decisions.Noted

On this subject at Wychavon

Search all
  1. Planning application Ref W/05/00773/PN - Retirement residential development comprising 71 flats, warden's accommodation, communal facilities and car parking. Land at High Street and Cherry Orchard, Pershore WR10. Morbaine Limited.This decision
  2. Planning Application Ref W/26/01261/FUL.Decided
  3. Planning Application Ref W/26/01241/LB.Approved
  4. Planning Application Ref W/24/01768/FUL. Locks View, Charlton Lane, Torton, Hartlebury. Three new gypsy plots each comprising one touring caravan, one static caravan and one utility block - (Variation of condition 1 Ref 19/02686/FUL and Appeal Ref APP/H1840/W/20/3256477). Mr Steven LockApproved
  5. Planning Application Ref W/26/00768/FUL. 18 Coronation Street, Evesham, WR11 3DA. Part change of use from Class F2 social club to Class F2 social club and Class E(f) children's day nursery. Mrs Susan TredellApproved
  6. Planning Application Ref W/26/00695/RM.Refused

More from Wychavon Development Control Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
28 Apr 2011 Minutes.Resolved That the Minutes of the Committee held on 31 March 2011 be approved as a correct record of the proceedin g s... Approved Open
28 Apr 2011 Planning Application Ref W/11/00298/PN.Resolved Conditionally approved:- Z001 The development hereby permitted shall be begun no later than the expiration o... Approved Open
28 Apr 2011 Planning Application Ref W/10/03096/RM. Reserved Matters Application following the granting of Outline Planning Permission Ref W/09/01690/OU for construction of 28 dwellings. ( Including 8 no. Affordable Units). Land to the rear of including and, 27 Brewers Lane, Badsey. Crest Nicholson.Resolved That this matter be deferred to await receipt of a revised layout plan to address comments made by the Count... Deferred Open
28 Apr 2011 Planning Application Ref W/11/0004/PN. Erection of two detached dwellings. Land Adjacent, 19 Oak Tree Lane, Cookhill. Mr Ryan.Resolved That this item be refused for the following reason:- It is considered that the erection of two detached dwel... Refused Open
28 Apr 2011 Planning Application Ref C/11/00658/CM. Proposed Anaerobic Digestion Plant, new roundabout access and associated ancillary infrastructure. Spring Hill Farm, Salters Lane, Fladbury, WR10 2PE. Mr A Bille.Resolved That the Council provide the following comments in response to the County Council consultation. The Council ... Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies