Planning application Ref W/09/00833/PP - Single garage and first floor extension with alterations to the existing elevations. 113 Cheltenham Road, Evesham, WR11 2LF. Mr Hibberd.
RefusedPlanning1 paper
Development Control Committee refused this item on Thursday 25 June 2009. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved Refused for the following reasons:- Z001 It is considered that the proposed extension which incorporates two gables both of greater depth than that of the original two-storey part of the property, as well as a wide roof valley, so that its overall depth is more than doubled, is not subservient in scale to it. In addition, the depth of the proposed gables, combined with the variation in proposed eaves heights of the rear and side elevations, is not considered to reflect the simple design of the original two-storey part of the property, nor its character as a modestly sized dwelling. In these ways the proposal is considered to be out of scale and not in keeping with the character and appearance of the original part of the house, causing an adverse impact on its contribution to the street scene when viewed from Cheltenham Road, as well as the outlook of the adjacent property, No.111 Cheltenham Road, contrary to Policies GD2 and SUR6 of the adopted Wychavon District Local Plan, QE3 of the West Midlands Spatial Strategy and advice contained in the Council's House Extensions Advice Note. Z002 In addition, it is considered that the dwelling as extended will cause undue overshadowing to part of No.111 Cheltenham Road 's plot by virtue of its height and close proximity on the northern boundary of the application site, contrary to Policies GD2 and SUR6 of the adopted Wychavon District Local Plan and Policy QE3 of the West Midlands Spatial Strategy. Notes:- Drawing no/s: 113/001; 113/002; 113/003; 113/004 Rev D; 113/005; 113/006 Rev D; 113/007 Rev D; 113/008 Rev D; 113/011 Rev A
Word for word from the decision Wychavon published for this meeting.Source: mgov.wychavon.gov.uk
Description: Single garage and first floor extension with alterations to the existing elevations
Site: 113 Cheltenham Road, Evesham, WR11 2LF
Applicant: [name removed]: Not applicable
Date Valid: 07/04/2009 Case Gavin Greenhow Officer: Expiry Date: 02/06/2009 Tel: 01386 565369 Member(s): Cllr Andrew L Dyke Cllr Wendy Dyke
1. Site Description and Details of Proposal
This proposal consists of a two storey rear extension on a detached property, 113 Cheltenham Road, Evesham. The application follows on from a somewhat larger proposal submitted in 2008 which was withdrawn by the applicant following discussions with the case officer.
The application appears on the Committee Agenda at the request of the local Ward Member, Cllr Dyke, who has also requested a Member's Site Visit.
2. Planning Policies
Worcestershire County Structure Plan Relevant Policies are:
Policy CTC.1 (Landscape Character - includes criteria relating to impact on the landscape for the assessment of all proposals) Wychavon District Local Plan June 2006 Relevant Policies are:
Policy GD2 (General Development Control – includes general criteria used for the assessment of all proposals) Policy ENV1 (Landscape Character – includes criteria relating to impact on the landscape for the assessment of all proposals) Policy SUR6 (Extensions to buildings – includes criteria for assessing extensions to existing buildings)
West Midlands Regional Spatial Strategy Relevant Policies are:
Policy QE3 (Creating a high quality environment for all – promotes the creation of high quality built environments)
3. Planning History
W/08/00985/PP Demolition of existing single storey flat roof extension and construction of new two storey extension - Withdrawn 23/5/08 W/82/00792 Extension - Approved 9/9/82 W/86/01324 Bedroom extension - Approved 30/9/86
4. Consultation Responses
Town Council:
Recommended for approval subject to the proposal not adversely affecting neighbouring properties.
County Highways:
No objection.
District Council Drainage Engineer:
The Applicant is intending to install a rainwater harvesting system as the proposed means of surface water disposal. They will need to ensure the correct size of tank is used to prevent additional flow being discharged downstream so that flooding problems are not exacerbated or created.
- The extension is of overpowering size/stature, in contrast to the existing situation, and its proximity to the boundary of our property would be only 4 feet. The current space between the properties is 12 feet 5 inches and the proposed reduction would result in a nearly 70% decrease in space; this separation is far too small. - Whatever extension proceeds we do not want a new wall astride the boundary line but the existing boundary fence between the two properties maintained and any new wall built wholly on No.113's land. - The proposal includes a plan to recycle rainwater via a pump to the house and wants confirmation that the pump would not cause any intrusive noise. - If the extension was confined to the existing footprint of the house then we would have no objections.
Supporting comments
- The applicants have made significant effort to improve their property from a fairly dilapidated condition to its current state and this proposal is the next step to providing a functional family home; - the proposals are not dissimilar to other properties along Cheltenham Road and would fit well within the road;
7. OFFICER APPRAISAL
The main issues in the determination of the current application are the design/visual impact of the extension, its impact on neighbouring properties and surface water drainage.
Design/visual impact
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Planning application Ref W/09/00833/PP: Single garage and first floor extension with alterations to the existing elevations. 113 Cheltenham Road, Evesham, WR11 2LF. Mr Hibberd.Report
29Planning application Ref W/09/00833/PP - Single garage and first floor extension with alterations to the existing elevations. 113 Cheltenham Road, Evesham, WR11 2LF. Mr Hibberd.This decision
Planning application Ref W/09/00833/PP - Single garage and first floor extension with alterations to the existing elevations. 113 Cheltenham Road, Evesham, WR11 2LF. Mr Hibberd.This decision
Planning Application Ref W/11/00298/PN.Resolved Conditionally approved:- Z001 The development hereby permitted shall be begun no later than the expiration o...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.