CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Wychavon District Council
Development Control Committee, Thursday 15 October 2009

Planning application Ref W/09/01600/PN - Demolition of existing farmhouse & construction of new house, change of use of existing barn to include 2 staff flat as ancillary accommodation.

Refused Planning 1 paper

Development Control Committee refused this item on Thursday 15 October 2009. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item112

Resolved

Resolved Refused for the following reason:- Z001 The existing building is a moderately sized, two-storey dwelling, which is proposed to be demolished. The Council do not consider this building to be particularly incongruous with its surroundings. The development as proposed would result in a substantially larger five-bedroomed property, with a footprint much greater than that of the existing dwellinghouse, and which constitutes a disproportionate increase in the size and volume of the residential element. This would perpetuate the visual impact of the development from public vantage points within an attractive area of open countryside, which is visible from the surrounding areas, particularly to the south from Bredon Hill. The dominating appearance of the development on the surrounding area, would be further exacerbated by the scale and proportions of the proposed three bay car port. Furthermore the proposed dwelling is not preferable to the existing for reasons of design. The proposal would therefore fail to comply with Policies SD2, CTC1 and D10 of the adopted Worcester County Structure Plan and Policies ENV1, SUR1 and Policy RES9 (which provides the criteria under which replacement dwellings are considered acceptable within the open countryside) of the Wychavon District Local Plan (2006).
Word for word from the decision Wychavon published for this meeting. Source: mgov.wychavon.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Wychavon's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Development Control Committee, 8 pages

Development Control Committee - 15/10/2009

W/09/01600/PN Parish: Little Comberton Grid Ref: E:397198.73 N:244075.34 Ward: Elmley Castle & Somerville 15

Description: Demolition of existing farmhouse & construction of new house, change of use of existing barn to include 2 staff flat as ancillary accommodation. Domestic boundary for new drive. Demolition of existing store/garage & construction of new stables. Construction of grass tennis court.

Site: Old Fallow Farm, Wick Road, Little Comberton, Pershore, WR10 3ES

Applicant: [name removed]:

Date Valid: 13/07/2009 Case Heather Pearson Officer: Expiry Date: 07/09/2009 Tel: 01386 565325 Member(s): Cllr Mrs D A Mackison

1. Site Description and Details of Proposal

The site is located in the parish of Little Comberton approximately 1km from the village. The site is in open countryside surrounded by rolling agricultural land and is relatively isolated. There are no immediate neighbouring dwellings. The site is located approximately 500m from the boundary of the AONB with a number of footpaths passing nearby. Access to the site is along a 400 metre private driveway. The existing house is a white rendered building of approximately 300sqm. Along side the dwelling is a long barn with outbuildings attached. Whilst not listed, the barn is architecturally interesting. The barn has an existing permission to convert to a live/work unit granted in 2006. Another large outbuilding lies to the north west of the dwelling within the existing domestic curtilage. The existing domestic curtilage is extensive at 1.1ha.

The proposal is to replace the existing dwelling with one that is larger and constructed of brick and timber with rendered panels. The existing building is plain white rendered 'T' shaped property. The proposal would replace this with a much grander gabled structure orientated with the front facade facing east as opposed to the current dwelling that faces south. It is also proposed to convert the barn to an indoor swimming pool and two units of staff accommodation for use by groom and ground staff. An outdoor swimming pool, tennis court and new stable block to accommodated 6 loose boxes forms part of the application. The domestic curtilage is partially extended to accommodate a new driveway to the east of the existing boundary.

Foul drainage is to be dealt with by a new package treatment plant located within the garden area.

The application is to be subject of a Committee site visit and is called to the Committee at the request of the local member Cllr Mrs Mackison.

2. Planning Policies

Worcestershire County Structure Plan Relevant Policies are: SD2 (Care for the Environment) CTC1 (Landscape Character) CTC5 (Trees, Woodland and Hedgerows) CTC12 (Sites of Regional or Local Wildlife Importance) CTC17 (Archaeological Sites of local Importance) CTC21 (Reuse and Conversion of Buildings) SD2 (Care for the Environment) D10 (Housing in the Open Countryside Outside the Green Belt) D16 (Reuse and Conversion of Buildings)

Wychavon District Local Plan June 2006 Relevant Policies are:

GD2 (General development Control) RES8 (Conversion of Existing Buildings outside Defined Development Boundaries) RES9 (Replacement Buildings in the Countryside outside Defined Development Boundaries) ENV1 (Landscape Character) ENV6 (Protected Species) ENV8 (Protection of Hedgerows, Trees and Woodland) ENV10 (Sites of Archaeological Significance) ENV18 (Development in areas of Low to Medium Flood Risk) COM14 (Specialist Sport and Recreation Facilities in the Countryside) SUR1 (Built Design) SUR2 (Landscape Design) SUR7 (Annexe Accommodation) SUR8 (Extensions to Curtilages)

West Midlands Regional Spatial Strategy Relevant Policies are:

QE3 (Creating a high quality built environment for all)

Government Policy Planning Policy Statement 7- Sustainable Development in Rural Areas Planning Policy Statement 9 - Biodiversity and Geological Conservation (2005) 3. Planning History

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Planning application Ref W/09/01600/PN: Demolition of existing farmhouse & construction of new house, change of use of existing barn to include 2 staff flat as ancillary accommodation. Domestic boundary for new drive. Demolition of existing store/garage & construction of new stables. Construction oReport 8 pages DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting
107Minutes.Approved 108Enforcement Report - IN/0900424 Spring Hill Nurseries, Spring Hill Farm, Salters Lane, Fladbury.Decided 109Enforcement Report – Land at Canada Bank, Charlton.Decided 110Enforcement Report – Land at Shernal Brook Farm, West Side, North Littleton, Evesham, Worcestershire.Refused 111Planning application Ref W/09/02104/PN - Variation of condition to facilitate relocation of constructors compound outside application site in an operationally superior location. Spring Hill Farm, Salters Lane, Fladbury, WR10 2PE. Springhill Nurseries.Noted
112Planning application Ref W/09/01600/PN - Demolition of existing farmhouse & construction of new house, change of use of existing barn to include 2 staff flat as ancillary accommodation.This decision
113Planning application Ref W/09/01798/PN - New dwelling on land currently occupied by a detached garage within the residential curtilage of Pennypots. Pennypots, Spring Bank, Defford, Worcester, WR8 9BB. Mr & Mrs Feast.Refused 114Planning application Ref W/09/01697/PP - Two storey extension to side and single storey extensions to rear together with conversion of existing garage, new dormer window to rear and new roof lights. Grey Gables, Manor Road, Wickhamford, Evesham, WR11 7SA. Mr G Fagan.Approved 115Planning application Ref W/09/01802/PP - proposed conversion of garage to form new dining room, bedroom and shower room together with detached garage workshop and storage to rear and formation of new driveway. Aldwick View, Eckington Road, Bredon, Tewkesbury, GL20 7EY. Mr T Brunsden.Deferred 116Summary of Appeal Decisions.On the agenda

On this subject at Wychavon

Search all
  1. Planning application Ref W/09/01600/PN - Demolition of existing farmhouse & construction of new house, change of use of existing barn to include 2 staff flat as ancillary accommodation.This decision
  2. Planning Application Ref W/26/01261/FUL.Decided
  3. Planning Application Ref W/26/01241/LB.Approved
  4. Planning Application Ref W/24/01768/FUL. Locks View, Charlton Lane, Torton, Hartlebury. Three new gypsy plots each comprising one touring caravan, one static caravan and one utility block - (Variation of condition 1 Ref 19/02686/FUL and Appeal Ref APP/H1840/W/20/3256477). Mr Steven LockApproved
  5. Planning Application Ref W/26/00768/FUL. 18 Coronation Street, Evesham, WR11 3DA. Part change of use from Class F2 social club to Class F2 social club and Class E(f) children's day nursery. Mrs Susan TredellApproved
  6. Planning Application Ref W/26/00695/RM.Refused

More from Wychavon Development Control Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
28 Apr 2011 Minutes.Resolved That the Minutes of the Committee held on 31 March 2011 be approved as a correct record of the proceedin g s... Approved Open
28 Apr 2011 Planning Application Ref W/11/00298/PN.Resolved Conditionally approved:- Z001 The development hereby permitted shall be begun no later than the expiration o... Approved Open
28 Apr 2011 Planning Application Ref W/10/03096/RM. Reserved Matters Application following the granting of Outline Planning Permission Ref W/09/01690/OU for construction of 28 dwellings. ( Including 8 no. Affordable Units). Land to the rear of including and, 27 Brewers Lane, Badsey. Crest Nicholson.Resolved That this matter be deferred to await receipt of a revised layout plan to address comments made by the Count... Deferred Open
28 Apr 2011 Planning Application Ref W/11/0004/PN. Erection of two detached dwellings. Land Adjacent, 19 Oak Tree Lane, Cookhill. Mr Ryan.Resolved That this item be refused for the following reason:- It is considered that the erection of two detached dwel... Refused Open
28 Apr 2011 Planning Application Ref C/11/00658/CM. Proposed Anaerobic Digestion Plant, new roundabout access and associated ancillary infrastructure. Spring Hill Farm, Salters Lane, Fladbury, WR10 2PE. Mr A Bille.Resolved That the Council provide the following comments in response to the County Council consultation. The Council ... Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies