Resolved
Resolved Refused for the following reasons:- (1) The applicant has failed to accurately assess the level of flood risk to the proposed development and impact on flood risk elsewhere. As such it has been unable to demonstrate that the proposals are appropriate given the potential level of flood risk. Nor has it been demonstrated that the proposals will not have a detrimental impact to adjacent properties/land areas. This is contrary to the precautionary, risk based approach of PPS25. Furthermore the submitted Flood Risk Assessment has failed to assess the condition of the existing culvert, include any detail with regard to the proposed replacement of a "55 metre" section or any new headwall and/or trash screen required as a result. Given the historic flood risk (2007) and the potential for flood risk, the site may be located in Flood Zones 2 or 3. The Flood Risk Assessment has not demonstrated that the site is not located in Flood Zones 2 or 3 (the medium risk or high risk zones). If the application site lies within an area at High or Medium Flood Risk, PPS25 would require sequential and exceptions tests to be carried out. No information has been provided to show that such tests have been carried out and can be passed. The Flood Risk Assessment has therefore failed to demonstrate that the proposals are in accordance with PPS25 and to policy ENV17 and/or ENV18 of the Adopted Wychavon District Local Plan 2006. In addition the proposals are also contrary to the aims of the South Worcestershire SFRA with regard to the protection and enhancement of watercourses. (2) By virtue of the height, length and positioning of the proposed building, the proposed development would cause an overbearing effect upon neighbouring residential properties to the south of the application site. Furthermore the proposed development includes a new servicing yard in close proximity to a number of existing residences to the east and south of the application site. Noise and disturbance from this servicing yard will also adversely affect the amenities of existing residential properties. For these reason the proposed development would have an ... view the full minutes text for item 209.