Resolved
Resolved Refused for the following reasons:- Z001 The proposal will result in the loss of a public house which is regarded as an important community facility. Adopted Local Plan Policy COM11, Protection of Community Facilities, states that the loss of a community facility will only be permitted where an acceptable and feasible alternative facility exists or a replacement can be provided. Although there are a number of other pubs and facilities which are within walking distance of the site, these are located in Pershore town centre at least half a mile away. The public house on the site is the only public house in this part of Pershore. It is considered that insufficient evidence has been provided to demonstrate that the pub is no longer viable, or that there is not some other alternative community use of the building or site achievable. In these circumstances, the proposal as submitted does not meet the requirements of Policy COM11 of the adopted Wychavon District Local Plan. In addition, retention of the pub, or some other community use, on the site may also be important in protecting or retaining other nearby local services, such as the shops in Fulbert Avenue , in accordance with the objectives of Policy COM11. Z002 The application submissions include a daytime bat inspection survey report by CSa Environmental, which concludes that, w hilst it found no evidence of bats being present, there is a medium level risk of bats occurring and recommends that further bat surveys are carried out to establish this. These should consist of at least one dawn and one dusk survey during the bats' active season. As the pub building would be demolished to achieve the proposed development, any bat roosts (if present) would be lost. W ithout further surveys and being party to the findings it cannot be confirmed if any species of bat use the site, or how many. The Council is unable, therefore, to determine whether the proposed development would result in significant harm to interests of biodiversity through adverse effects or risk of adverse effect to protected species (bats). Also, without survey results to identify the significance of the ecological importance of the application site, the Council is unable to determine whether significant harm can be prevented, adequately mitigated against or compensated for. As such, insufficient information has been provided to ascertain whether the proposed development would be in accordance with policy ENV6 of the Wychavon District Local Plan, the EU Habitats Directive as well as the provisions of PPS9 on Biodiversity and Geological Conservation. The lack of sufficient survey work and subsequent survey results is also contrary to the provisions of Planning for Biodiversity and Geological Conservation: A Guide to Good Practice. Z003 Whilst noting the applicant’s willingness to enter into a ... view the full minutes text for item 12.