Planning application Ref W/10/01272/CU - Proposed conversion of redundant agricultural building to Live / Work use, including associated parking and amenity. Springfield Barn, Uphampton Lane, Ombersley. Mr A Smith.
RefusedPlanning1 paper
Development Control Committee refused this item on Thursday 24 June 2010. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved Refused for the following reason, subject to no new material objections being raised by residential consultees (consultation period expires on the 30/06/10):- Z001 Local Planning Authorities are required to apply the 3 “Tests” of the Habitat Regulations when considering planning applications involving European Protected Species. It is not considered that this application can be justified in compliance with Test One which requires that the application will have public health or safety benefits or overriding social, economic or environmental public interests in the conversion of the existing building. The second test requires that there would be no satisfactory alternatives to the conversion of the dwelling. In the opinion of the Local Planning Authority an alternative approach is available through the use of the building to remain as agriculture. On this basis, the application also fails in compliance with Test Two as it has not been demonstrated to a satisfactory degree that these alternatives have been thoroughly considered. Approval of this application would therefore be contrary to Wychavon District Local Plan Policy ENV6, the requirements of the Habitat Regulations 1994 and PPS9 – Biodiversity and Geological Conservation.
Word for word from the decision Wychavon published for this meeting.Source: mgov.wychavon.gov.uk
Description: Proposed conversion of redundant agricultural building to Live / Work use, including associated parking and amenity
Site: Springfield Barn, Uphampton Lane, Ombersley
Applicant: [name removed]: Alan Smith Associates
Date Valid: 18/05/2010 Case Simon Rees Officer: Expiry Date: 13/07/2010 Tel: 01386 565389 Member(s): Cllr Mrs Jean C Dowty
1. Site Description and Details of Proposal
This proposal is to convert an existing brick and tile building situated in a countryside location, outside the settlement of Uphampton, to form a one bedroom Live/Work unit with associated parking and amenity.
There is a long history related to this site and it would appear that the building has never been actively used. Though the applicant confirms within their Design & Access Statement that the building was constructed for agriculture in 1991 under Part 6 of the General Permitted Development Order.
In 1996, an application (Plan No W/96/01036) for the conversion of the building to residential use was refused Planning Permission and dismissed at Appeal. The application was refused by virtue of its insufficient architectural/historical quality and the proposed alterations and additions having served to give the building a domestic character. The proposal to include a large detached garage/store would have also been visually prominent within its rural surroundings outside of a defined settlement boundary.
Another application for the change of use of the building from agricultural to office/industrial use in 1998 (Plan No W/98/00163) was also refused Planning Permission. In this case the application was refused because of the detrimental impact to the amenities of the occupiers of existing nearby residential properties, particularly as a result of the increase in activity on the site and traffic to and from it.
A further application in 2004 (Plan No W/04/00071) for the change of use to residential was again refused Planning Permission and dismissed at Appeal. The reasons for refusal in this application related to conversion of the building to a residential dwelling having resulted in alterations to the building, which would have given it more of a domestic appearance than a traditional barn. The proposal was also unsuccessful on the basis that the existing building being incongruous within the traditional surroundings of the area, which would have had an adverse impact upon the setting of the Uphampton Conservation Area. The proposed loss and alteration to the existing hedgerow to form the acceptable access was also considered to have a harmful impact upon the visual character of the area and setting upon the Uphampton Conservation Area. A further reason for refusal was due to applicant not submitting a wildlife survey to ensure than any protected species or their habitats were affected by the proposal.
Another planning application was submitted in 2006 (W/06/01823) and was for the alteration to the existing access to the agricultural barn. This was refused on the basis that the proposed loss and alteration to the existing hedgerow for the creation of an acceptable access would have opened up the lane in a manner which was considered harmful to the character and appearance of the area and the setting of the Uphampton Conservation Area.
In 2008, the applicant submitted an application Ref. W/08/00555/CU for 'Change of use of redundant barn to live/work use', which was refused by the Development Control Committee on grounds relating to the failure to demonstrate that the building could not be used for alternative means; the incongruous nature of the building upon surroundings and in particular the surrounding conservation area as a result of the substantial loss of boundary hedging required to meet the visibility requirements as set out by the County Highways.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Planning application Ref W/10/01272/CU: Proposed conversion of redundant agricultural building to Live / Work use, including associated parking and amenity. Springfield Barn, Uphampton Lane, Ombersley. Mr A Smith.Report
36Planning application Ref W/10/01272/CU - Proposed conversion of redundant agricultural building to Live / Work use, including associated parking and amenity. Springfield Barn, Uphampton Lane, Ombersley. Mr A Smith.This decision
Planning application Ref W/10/01272/CU - Proposed conversion of redundant agricultural building to Live / Work use, including associated parking and amenity. Springfield Barn, Uphampton Lane, Ombersley. Mr A Smith.This decision
Planning Application Ref W/11/00298/PN.Resolved Conditionally approved:- Z001 The development hereby permitted shall be begun no later than the expiration o...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.