Resolved
Resolved Refused for the following reasons:- (1) The site is located adjacent to a grade II Listed Building and set within the Evesham Conservation Area. The proposed residential development in this area would, by virtue of its height and siting, relate poorly to No.63 Port Street, as such it would appear as an over dominant and discordant feature, unsympathetic to the character, appearance and setting of this Grade II Listed Building and harmful to the character and appearance of this part of the Conservation Area. The site is in a predominately commercial area of Evesham with commercial development on three sides of the site. Residential development of this site is considered inappropriate and out of character with surrounding development. The proposed development would thereby conflict with Policies ENV1, ENV12, ENV14 and SUR1 of the adopted Wychavon District Local Plan (June 2006), Policy CTC19 of the adopted Worcestershire County Structure Plan and Section 16 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 and the advice and guidance set out in PPS5 ‘Planning and the Historic Environment’. (2) The site is currently an employment site occupied by a commercial building. Policies within the adopted Local Plan seek to protect employment land and ensure that there is sufficient land in a range of locations to cater for the different land/locational requirements of a variety of business uses. Insufficient evidence has been submitted to demonstrate compliance with any of the criteria set out in policy ECON1 of the Wychavon District Local Plan. The Council consider that the residential development of the site is not appropriate given the uses on adjoining and nearby sites and as such criterion (c) is not complied with. Also it has not been demonstrated that the existing premises are no longer capable of meeting employment needs. The proposed development would therefore conflict with Policy ECON1 of the adopted Wychavon District Local Plan (June 2006). (3) The proposal represents a density of 167 dwelling per hectare. This is considered to be a very high density that does not reflect the character of the surrounding built environment. As a consequence of this high density the two blocks of accommodation are sited 5.1 metres apart leading to a poor relationship between the two blocks of residential property with potential for direct overlooking and overshadowing of windows, amenity space and buildings. The amount of land available for cycle storage, bins, drying facilities and communal amenity is not considered to be adequate for 9 units of accommodation. As a consequence the proposal fails to comply with adopted policies GD2, ENV1 and SUR1 of the adopted Wychavon Local Plan (2006) and the guidance set out in the adopted supplementary planning guidance – Residential Design Guide (September 2010). (4) The proposal ... view the full minutes text for item 102.