Resolved
Resolved Refused for the following reasons:- (1) This is an incongruous brick building, which was erected as permitted development as an agricultural barn, but does not appear to have been ever actively used for these purposes. The application relates to the conversion of this existing building located within open countryside, outside a defined development boundary. It is the policy of the Local Planning Authority, as set out in the adopted Wychavon District Local Plan (June 2006) to ensure that conversion of existing buildings outside defined development boundaries to live/work use will only be permitted where efforts to secure alternative uses other than residential, have been unsuccessful. The applicant has advertised the building solely for agricultural let, despite the previous applicant’s contention that it was unsuitable for any commercial agricultural use. However, the proposal for the conversion of these buildings to residential units is contrary to Policy D10 of the approved Worcestershire County Structure Plan, Policies GD2 and RES8 of the adopted Wychavon District Local Plan (June 2006) and guidance contained within the Adopted Supplementary Planning Guidance on the 'Reuse of Rural Buildings'. (2) It is considered that the conversion of the agricultural building would perpetuate an incongruous structure, which is not in character with existing traditional agricultural buildings within the surrounding area. The alterations proposed and the addition for further openings and roof lights would further change the form and appearance of the building, which already has little in terms of its design or construction that identifies it as part of the agricultural building vernacular or allows its integration with its surroundings in an environmentally acceptable manner and it would therefore have an adverse impact upon the setting of the adjacent Uphampton Conservation Area and the landscape character of the surrounding area. It is therefore considered contrary to Policies CTC20 and CTC1 of the Adopted Worcestershire County Structure Plan Policies GD2, ENV1 and ENV12 of the Adopted Wychavon Local Plan as well as guidance contained within the Adopted Supplementary Planning Document on the 'Reuse of Rural Buildings'. (3) It is considered that the conversion of the agricultural building would result in a material loss of amenity with regards to a loss of privacy to the adjoining residential property Greenlands. This is by reason of the first floor side elevation bedroom window, which faces towards Greenlands own private amenity space. The proposal therefore fails to comply with Policies GD2 of the adopted Local Plan (2006) as well as guidance contained within the adopted SPD Residential Design Guide (2010).