CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Wychavon District Council
Development Control Committee, Thursday 3 March 2011

Planning application Ref W/10/02622/LB. Request for retrospective listing building consent for provision and installation of 6 windows to rear of property and replacement kitchen door. 1 The Hop Kilns, Mill Lane, Aldington, Evesham, WR11 7YQ. Mr & Mrs A Hughes.

Refused Planning 1 paper

Development Control Committee refused this item on Thursday 3 March 2011. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item198

Resolved

Resolved (1) Refused for the following reason:- Z001 The replacement of the original timber framed windows and door on the rear elevation of the grade II listed building with 'Rosewood' colour wood effect upvc double glazed windows and door is contrary to Local and National Planning Policies designed to protect the Historic Environment. Upvc is not considered to be a traditional material and therefore is deemed to have a harmful impact upon the character, special interest, setting and fabric of the listed building. Accordingly the proposed development contravenes policy ENV13 of the adopted Wychavon District Local Plan, policy CTC.19 of the Worcestershire County Structure Plan and the guidance contained in the National Planning Policy Statement 5: Planning for the Historic Environment. (2) The Head of Legal and Support Services be authorised in consultation with the Head of Housing and Planning to issue a listed building enforcement notice pursuant to section 38 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990; and (3) The Head of Legal and Support Services be authorised to commence and pursue a prosecution against the owner(s) of the building pursuant to section 43 of the Planning ( Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 in the event that the listed building enforcement notice is not complied with.
Word for word from the decision Wychavon published for this meeting. Source: mgov.wychavon.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Wychavon's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Development Control Committee, 4 pages

Development Control Committee - 03/03/2011

W/10/02622/LB Parish: Aldington Grid Ref: E:406460.42 N:244070.82 Ward: Badsey 01

Description: Request for retrospective listing building consent for provision and installation of 6 windows to rear of property and replacement kitchen door.

Site: 1 The Hop Kilns, Mill Lane, Aldington, Evesham, WR11 7YQ

Applicant: Mr & [name removed]:

Date Valid: 16/12/2010 Case Officer: Vicky Stone Expiry Date: 10/02/2011 Tel: 01386 565328 Member(s): Cllr Reginald A Jakeman

This application is being reported to the Committee at the request of the Local Ward Member, Councillor Jakeman.

1. Site Description and Details of Proposal

This retrospective Listed Building Consent application is for the retention of 6 replacement windows and a kitchen door to the rear elevation of a grade II terraced listed building. 1 The Hop Kilns is a Grade II Listed Building and sits within the Aldington Conservation Area. The property lies off Mill Lane and forms part of a terrace of 6 properties, 4 of which are also listed. The original windows were stained timber construction with single light opening panes. The owners of the property have replaced the inserts in the rear elevation with 'Rosewood' colour wood effect UPVC double glazed windows to the exact same configuration of the original windows.

This site has recently had a Listed Building Consent application (proposed) refused for a similar scheme, the replacement of the existing timber windows and door on the front elevation of the property with 'Rosewood' colour wood effect UPVC double glazed windows. 2. Planning Policies

Worcestershire County Structure Plan Relevant Policies are:

CTC.19 - Areas and Features of Historic Significance

Wychavon District Local Plan June 2006 Relevant Policies are:

ENV13 - Alterations to Listed Buildings

Government Policy

Planning Policy Statement 5: Planning for the Historic Environment

Parish Plans

None

3. Planning History

W/10/02623/LB - 9 Replacement Windows and Door to Front Elevation - Refused 04/02/11

4. Consultation Responses

Parish/Town Council:

The Parish Council raised no objections to the application.

County Highways:

No comment required.

5. Representations Received

None

6. Representations Made

None

7. OFFICER APPRAISAL

As this is a Listed Building Consent application, the only material considerations required to be assessed when determining the application are with regards to the impact of the replacement windows and kitchen door upon the character, appearance, fabric and setting of the Grade II listed building.

1 The Hop Kiln used to form part of a larger property, together with No.2. With 17th Century origins, it was extended in 1882 and remodelled in late 20th Century. Its constituent materials are course lias rubble with ashlar dressings and machine tile roof. As stated in the introduction this application is retrospective. The window frames and door in the rear elevation have already been constructed and inserted into the elevation using 'rosewood' colour effect UPVC.

Your Officers consider that the principle of wholesale window replacement in this property is acceptable, however the proposed materials are inappropriate. The material for the frames to the windows should be timber, not UPVC. Your Officers consider that the retrospective replacement of the timber frames with 'rosewood' colour effect UPVC is contrary to Local and National Planning Policies designed to protect the Historic Environment.

Policy ENV13 of the adopted Wychavon District Local Plan states that changes to listed buildings should compliment the historic and architectural character of the building and will be expected to be of an appropriate design, using traditional materials and appropriate building techniques. UPVC is not considered to be a traditional material and therefore would have a harmful impact upon the character, special interest, setting and fabric of the listed building and contrary to this policy.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Planning application Ref W/10/02622/LB. Request for retrospective listing building consent for provision and installation of 6 windows to rear of property and replacement kitchen door. 1 The Hop Kilns, Mill Lane, Aldington, Evesham, WR11 7YQ. Mr & Mrs A Hughes.Report 4 pages DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting
185Minutes.Approved 186Kemerton Village Design Statement, Harvington Parish Plan and Harvington Village Design Statement.On the agenda 187Enforcement Report IN/09/00578 - North Manor House, Elmley Road, Ashton Under Hill, Evesham WR11 7SWAgreed 188Planning application Ref W/10/02978/OU. Outline Planning Application with means of site access from the junctions at Broomhall/Crookbarrow Road and Talavera Road to be determined (internal access, layout, scale, appearance and landscaping reserved for subsequent approval)Approved 189Planning application Ref W/10/02992/PN. Erection of single storey office building. Farncombe Estate, Farncombe Drive, Broadway. Sorven Properties Limited.Approved 190Planning application Ref W/10/02369/CU. Construction of two fishing lakes, access track and reinstatement of public footpaths (retrospective). Land Adjacent to Little Goosehill Wood, Goosehill Lane, Broughton Green, Hanbury. Mr Banham.Approved 191Planning Application Ref W/10/03013/PP. Entrance porch and first floor rear extension. The Sett and, Acacia Cottage, Elmley Road, Ashton under Hill. Mr & Mrs Moore/ Mr & Mrs Sanger-Davies.Approved 192Planning application Ref W/10/03023/CU. Temporary agricultural workers dwelling. Willow Farm, Mount Pleasant Lane, Ombersley. Miss K DanielsApproved 193Planning application Ref W/11/00127/PN. Variation of condition 12 on application W/10/02418/PN to allow work to be commenced prior to the submission of the 2 evening Bat Surveys. 112 Tagwell Road, Droitwich Spa, WR9 7AQ. Mr Duggan.Approved 194Planning application Ref W/10/02427/CU. Change of use of land for the temporary siting of two mobile homes for use by agricultural worker. Construction of driveway, turning and parking area. Woodhall Farm, Brickyard Lane, Drakes Broughton. Gouldlife Poultry and Smallholding Ltd.Approved 195Planning application Ref W/10/02640/CU. Change of use from residential to dental surgery. 9 Cheltenham Road, Broadway, WR12 7BY. Broadway Dental Care.Approved 196Planning application Ref W/10/02386/PN. Replacement Day Room, Utility & Wash room. Land off, Pitwell Lane, Aldington. Mr Saunders.Deferred 197Planning application Ref W/10/02780/CU. Change of use from agricultural ground to two plot caravan site. Orchard Place, Bretforton Road, Badsey. Mrs M Smith.Refused
198Planning application Ref W/10/02622/LB. Request for retrospective listing building consent for provision and installation of 6 windows to rear of property and replacement kitchen door. 1 The Hop Kilns, Mill Lane, Aldington, Evesham, WR11 7YQ. Mr & Mrs A Hughes.This decision
199Summary of Appeals DecisionsOn the agenda

On this subject at Wychavon

Search all
  1. Planning application Ref W/10/02622/LB. Request for retrospective listing building consent for provision and installation of 6 windows to rear of property and replacement kitchen door. 1 The Hop Kilns, Mill Lane, Aldington, Evesham, WR11 7YQ. Mr & Mrs A Hughes.This decision
  2. Planning Application Ref W/26/01261/FUL.Decided
  3. Planning Application Ref W/26/01241/LB.Approved
  4. Planning Application Ref W/24/01768/FUL. Locks View, Charlton Lane, Torton, Hartlebury. Three new gypsy plots each comprising one touring caravan, one static caravan and one utility block - (Variation of condition 1 Ref 19/02686/FUL and Appeal Ref APP/H1840/W/20/3256477). Mr Steven LockApproved
  5. Planning Application Ref W/26/00768/FUL. 18 Coronation Street, Evesham, WR11 3DA. Part change of use from Class F2 social club to Class F2 social club and Class E(f) children's day nursery. Mrs Susan TredellApproved
  6. Planning Application Ref W/26/00695/RM.Refused

More from Wychavon Development Control Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
28 Apr 2011 Minutes.Resolved That the Minutes of the Committee held on 31 March 2011 be approved as a correct record of the proceedin g s... Approved Open
28 Apr 2011 Planning Application Ref W/11/00298/PN.Resolved Conditionally approved:- Z001 The development hereby permitted shall be begun no later than the expiration o... Approved Open
28 Apr 2011 Planning Application Ref W/10/03096/RM. Reserved Matters Application following the granting of Outline Planning Permission Ref W/09/01690/OU for construction of 28 dwellings. ( Including 8 no. Affordable Units). Land to the rear of including and, 27 Brewers Lane, Badsey. Crest Nicholson.Resolved That this matter be deferred to await receipt of a revised layout plan to address comments made by the Count... Deferred Open
28 Apr 2011 Planning Application Ref W/11/0004/PN. Erection of two detached dwellings. Land Adjacent, 19 Oak Tree Lane, Cookhill. Mr Ryan.Resolved That this item be refused for the following reason:- It is considered that the erection of two detached dwel... Refused Open
28 Apr 2011 Planning Application Ref C/11/00658/CM. Proposed Anaerobic Digestion Plant, new roundabout access and associated ancillary infrastructure. Spring Hill Farm, Salters Lane, Fladbury, WR10 2PE. Mr A Bille.Resolved That the Council provide the following comments in response to the County Council consultation. The Council ... Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies