(i) That election rules be set and agreed before the process is run again and that a clear timetable and rules be established and agreed 3 months in advance of the election date. REASON: To ensure the fair and smooth running of the election process. (ii) That further exploration regarding the process to be adopted be undertaken with young people and schools, and a report on the outcome brought back to the next meeting of the Working Group. REASON: So that the Group can be clear about the wishes of young people and the resources that schools are able to offer before making a decision on the process, with a view to ensuring that the chosen option involves the widest possible participation and is run along similar lines to an adult election process. (iii) That it be agreed that the selection process should be run every 2 years and that the next process should be undertaken in October 2007. REASON: In order that young people be given as many opportunities as possible to participate in the election process during their time at school.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
Report of the Director of Learning, Culture and Children’s Services.
REVIEWING THE CHILDREN AND YOUNG PEOPLE’S CHAMPION SELECTION PROCESS Summary 1. This paper looks at the lessons learned from the selection process for the Children and Young People’s Champion this year and sets out actions for consideration in designing and undertaking future selection.
Background 2. In April/ May 2006 City of York involved 1600 children and young people in selecting the City’s first Children and Young People’s Champion. This selection process was undertaken via primary and Secondary schools councils. The opportunity to participate was also extended to all secondary schools in the City via a DVD and small resource pack. 4 secondary schools took this up. The selection process was run on a very short timescale, because of the opportunity presented by the School council Conferences.
3. This first selection process can be viewed as a pilot. There are a number of areas where we can learn from and develop the process in future years:
a. There were no clearly set out or agreed election rules Action: Draw up and agree election rule before the process begins.
b. Due to short notice candidates were not always available for hustings Action: Draw up and publish an election timetable at the beginning of the process so that any potential candidates are aware of dates in advance.
c. Officers performed mixed roles, acting as returning officer as well as election agents Action: Returning Officer role to be fulfilled by representative from Democratic Services.
d. Whilst all primary and secondary schools within the LEA were offered the opportunity to participate in the process, not all accepted and not all offered the opportunity to vote to all students, as a consequence of which not all children and young people had the same opportunity to participate. Action: Be clear about the selection process, whether it is a full election open to all or a selection by a sample of the age group.
Options 4. There are a number of options for undertaking the selection process in following years which are outlined below:
Option 1: Full election process run in all schools
5. Full election process- involving all primary and secondary schools within the City. This would cost around £4k (£3k for transport of polling booths/ ballot boxes. £210 for production of 22000 numbered ballot cards , £500 To produce materials to support the election process that would be distributed to schools). Young people themselves would be involved in organising the elections within the schools with support from teachers, this includes counting the ballot papers.
Analysis 6. This option is very expensive and would use most of the remaining Voice and Influence budget. It would also require additional Officer time it terms of getting schools on board and co-ordinating the process, which is not currently available. If schools were not willing to participate, the children/ young people from that school would not be able to participate. It would extend the number of children and young people who are able to participate and promote the work of the Champion. The children and young people would have limited opportunities to have face to face contact with the candidates as organising visits to the 67 schools across the City would be problematic.
Option 2: Election at the primary/ secondary school council conferences 7. This would be similar to the process run this year with voting being open to the children and young people who attend the school council conferences for primary and secondary schools. This would include a hustings which both candidates would attend and the children and young people would vote based on this.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.