Economic Development Partnership Board noted this item on Tuesday 26 September 2006. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
That the report and the Board’s comments be noted. REASON: In order to gain the views of the EDPB on the proposal to expand the range of activities encompassed by the initiative; to establish it as a company limited by guarantee owned by the stakeholders; and to appoint a chief executive as described in the report.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
Economic Development Partnership Board 26th September 2006
Report of the Director of City Strategy
Science City York: Future Governance Summary 1. Representatives of the key stakeholders in Science City York (SCY), the City Council, the University of York, and Yorkshire Forward, have met to discuss the longer-term future of the partnership. A proposal has emerged from these discussions to expand the range of activities encompassed by the initiative; to establish it as a company limited by guarantee owned by the stakeholders; and to appoint a chief executive. The Executive Leader endorsed these proposals on behalf of the City Council on the 11th September. This report informs the EDPB of the proposals.
Background 2. The last meeting of the Executive Member Advisory Panel for City Strategy on the 17th July 2006 considered a report on Science City York, which included a section on discussions between the key stakeholders about the future governance of the partnership. It was reported that consultations were taking place at a high level between the City Council, the University of York, and Yorkshire Forward to consider how best to manage and govern the initiative, to enable it to be more effective in a very competitive environment, and to deliver the benefits we seek for York and the surrounding areas.
3. The Stakeholder Board, with representatives of the three key partners, the Chair of the SCY Strategy Group, and an independent Chair, commissioned consultants SQW to report on the options for future governance and management of Science City York. SQW consulted each stakeholder and other interested parties involved with the initiative, and considered a range of possible alternative future governance arrangements for the initiative. The consultants recognised that SCY is operating in an increasingly competitive environment: government sponsored science cities have been established in all other regions; other parts of our region have increasing aspirations; and other universities and agencies are becoming increasingly experienced at converting intellectual capital into business opportunities. We need an active fit-for-purpose organisation if SCY is to remain in a leading position.
4. SQW conclude that “(the) informal structure of the partnership, based on trust between key individuals, has been a real strength, and in practice has enabled a considerable degree of devolved decision making on public funds. But as the people involved move on, resources - and expectations - increase, and agendas become more complex and involve wider interests, the case for change becomes stronger. The implication is to move towards a more transparent – and inevitably more formal – structure, that can allow the partners to pursue an shared agenda to the benefit of the city, while also providing for clarity on decision taking and responsibility.”
5. The consultants considered a number of different more formal structures and concluded that a Company Limited by Guarantee, owned by the key stakeholders, is the most appropriate organisational arrangement for SCY. As well as creating formal ownership and management structures it would more readily enable SCY to enter into joint venture agreements with other parties.
6. The Stakeholders Board considered the report from SQW and accepted its conclusions. The members agreed to recommend to their respective organisations that:
i) “The work of Science City York going forward should where possible include the following, subject to detailed negotiations with the individual Stakeholders’ organisations and/or other relevant bodies:
* The budgets and functions currently managed by the City of York Council on behalf of Science City York, and possibly other related aspects of the Council’s work.
* Assets and functions currently associated with York Science Park Innovation Centre Ltd.
* Some functions currently undertaken within the University’s Enterprise and Innovation Office.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.